Brazzil

Since 1989 trying to understand Brazil

Search

Custom Search

Cheap Mobile Phones
---------------
Members : 2562
Content : 3357
Content View Hits : 20837929

Who's Online

We have 214 guests and 1 member online

Login Form




Pingo
Breaking News from Brazil
From Brazzil Mag news team
Brazzil Magazine


If I Were Brazilian I Might Also Become an Illegal in the US PDF Print E-mail
Written by Bob McCulley   
Sunday, 09 July 2006 16:50

Brazilians in a New Jersey street festivalI travel to Brazil often on business and most of my travels are in Amazônia where very few people speak English. Even in the hotels and shops in Manaus few can speak the language. My business requires me to fly into the interior and it is difficult to find interpreters who are willing to travel with me for extended periods of time.

As a result, I decided to learn Portuguese. I also have a business in the states so it was not possible for me to attend classes in Brazil. I live in the Northeast which is a fairly large area with many colleges and universities, so I sought out classes in Portuguese.

They are very few and far between and only offered during the day for full time students. I then went on the Internet to find help. I bought everything I could find to help me with my quest to learn Portuguese.

Despite all my gadgets and electronic aides my progress was slow and I realized I needed to be able to speak with someone in order to improve my pronunciation. I didn't know any Brazilian or for that matter whether there were any Brazilian in my city.

I soon found out there was a large community of Brazilians (mostly undocumented) living on the fringe of the city and in nearby New Jersey.

This is where my story begins, I was introduced to the Brazilian community several years ago by a Catholic missionary. I now teach English each Sunday after mass to his Brazilian parishioners. Many of them have befriended me and this has exposed me to the day to day life and struggle of the undocumented Brazilian immigrants in the USA.

For the most part they have one common goal, that is to make enough money to return to Brazil in five years and buy a farm or shop and provide a better life for their family.

Although, I don't condone them coming here illegally and breaking our laws I have been to the cities and interior of Brazil and seen first hand the poverty and despair. I would not hesitate to do what they have done to provide for my family.

Most of the Brazilian women clean houses in the suburbs and the men work construction. The obstacles to succeed in these endeavors are not speaking English, not having a driver's license and a social security number. The women can get by without a social security number but driver's license and understanding and speaking English are essential.

The other major obstacle is time. They work long hours and travel long distances to and from their jobs and they have very little time to learn English. Sunday is their only free day and they have tasks to prepare for the week ahead.

Post 9/11 it has become almost impossible to get a driver's license without documentation, and as a result every traffic stop by police or traffic ticket is a major problem. This has created a booming black market for bogus international driver's licenses that have no credibility at all with local police, but most Brazilians don't know that when they pay the US$ 1,000 to the seller.

I have developed a relationship with a local city hall attorney that specializes in traffic violations and I take my Brazilian friends to him with their traffic problems. To date, none have been deported but that may soon change with new proposed immigration law.

Culture Shock

Although I don't have a lot of experience in these matters, I suspect that my experience with the family from Rio is typical of the migration of Brazilians into our region. One family member comes, establishes himself and then others follow in the coming months or years. In the case of the Rio family the sister came first and the three brothers followed and in the space of two year all the siblings were here.

The sister worked for another Brazilian with an established house cleaning service and the brothers worked for a Portuguese subcontractor that had a contract with a national company. They all lived together in a small house and pooled their money to pay off the coyotes that had smuggled them into the country and at the same time attempted to save money to bring their wives into the US.

I know it took more than a year for them to pay off the bill for the three brothers. With respect to the wives the cost was higher because they chose the deluxe package. The ride in the van over the border and the flight from California as opposed to the trek through the desert and bus to the east coast. I later found out that the fee for the wives was US$ 23,000.

The siblings struggled financially for the first couple years just to establish themselves and pay off the coyotes. Fortunately, their family in Brazil supported their wives during this period. The aroma of rice and beans was ever present in their house. I never made my weekly visit to read the mail and interpret the English phone messages without a bag of treats or a case of beer for the brothers.

At this point, two years into their stay, the siblings realized that their original plan to come here work five years and go back to Brazil with a large sum of money was unrealistic. It would require a longer stay and they would have to learn English to get better jobs and be able to venture outside the Brazilian community to seek other opportunities.

This realization plus the constant fear of deportation and their inability to obtain a driver's license, bank accounts etc., etc. placed a lot of stress on the family. At this point, the brothers homesick for their wives and family wanted to go back to Brazil, but the strong willed sister would have none of that and she put the boys back on track. How I don't know, but she pulled it off.

The weather was also a bit of a shock to these Cariocas who were accustomed to year round beach weather. The winter weather here in the Northeast is cold and long in duration. Fortunately, I had just sold a vacation home in the mountains and the entire contents of the cottage, lots of down comforters and winter clothing were available.

In addition, I have a client that gave me several cartons of new winter clothing that were left over from his Christmas gift to the poor program. I still see remnants of my cottage when I visit with Brazilians other than this Rio family.

Evidently they shared the clothing and quilts with other needy friends. The snow was another novel experience, they were at first fascinated by its beauty but soon found that in the narrow street of the inner city it meant gridlock and no way to get to work.

They soon adapted to the ever present cold weather and snow and compensated by wearing beach attire around the house. They warmed up around the TV with Globo and dreamed of when they would return to Rio and the warm weather and beach. This and the Sunday telephone calls to family and wives sustained them during the first year or two.

Another strong influence was their faith. They are devout Roman Catholics and there is a nearby church with a mass in Portuguese every Saturday night and several support groups for new immigrants.

Bob McCulley is a CPA in private practice with several businesses in the US. He also has a forestry business in Brazil "Brazilforestbargains.com". He has a graduate degree in business and an undergraduate degree in liberal arts. McCulley lived and studied in Europe for several years and speaks Portuguese, Spanish and German. He hopes to settle in Brazil when he retires. He welcomes comments at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it

Comments (17)Add Comment
A Day Late And A Dollar Short
written by Guest, July 09, 2006
NO AMNESTY !!!!!!! NO GUESTWORKER !!!!!!!!!
...
written by Guest, July 10, 2006
a better title would be... If I Were Brazilian I Might NOT Become an Illegal in the US

sounds like they were quite miserable and unsuccessful at their goal... if all that effort were spent improving things in brasil itself might have been more productive
...
written by Guest, July 10, 2006
well bob it's a heart touching story, to a degree.

But the problem is this problem has become an epidemic in the U.S. While millions upon millions of illegal aliens come to the U.S. to "make money" and go home. Or send remittances back to their families in other countries. Naturally Mexicans are the lions share of this population, but there are also an estimated 1 million brazilians as well. Brazilians are the #1 perpetrator of illegal aliens being caught on the southern border classified as OTM(other than mexican).

Many try to argue that the U.S. was built on immigration, and they would be correct. BUT, immigration throughout the history of the U.S. was not conducted in this fashion. Matter of fact the very definition of immigration is not to go to a country "temporarily" to leach off its system and then return to the country of origin years later. It's to build a new life and settle in the new homeland and acclamate to it's laws and culture.

The solution for brazils economic problems, distribution of income, and poverty are not to export them to the U.S.

I can fully understand and appreciate the difficulties these people encounter while living in the U.S. illegally, but it's not the solution, and people around the world can fully understand why finally, after many years, the vast majority of americans have had their fill with illegal aliens and the problems they bring to the american economy, educational system as well as health care system, it's not as if they weren't problematic before.

Very soon this problem is going to have a solution, one way or another, good or bad for the illegal alien, and when/if many are deported back to their countries of origin, the U.S. will be the "bad guy" once more to many countries throughout the world....the countries with the perpetrators of course.
Demographic detail
written by Guest, July 10, 2006
I don't think the dirt-poor maids and construction workers you met in the Amazon are representative of Brazilian illegals in the US: such people cannot afford the plane ticket or a coyote; actually, paying for the passport would be non-trivial for them.

From the stories I saw on TV, I guess most illegals (e.g. the Governador Valladares crowd) are from the lower-middle class. Not 100% sure about this though...
IBEU
written by Guest, July 10, 2006
...has several Portuguese as a Foreign Language ("Português para estrangeiros") courses. Their site is http://wwwant.ibeu.org.br
No sympathy from me
written by lev, July 13, 2006
No sympathy from me. The old saying "the grass is greener on the other side " is in the minds of Brasilians. They find out the hard way that life in the States is not like the sopa operas that they watch here. It's a shame that they cannot put the time and energy here, in Brasil, making their lives better, that they put in the life that they CHOSE in the States.
...
written by guest, July 13, 2006
well, they CHOSE a life in the states because at least they can live in a reality that is not of "miseria".

The political system in brazil is what needs changed, and that requires the will of the masses, and moreso than just the will, but action.
...
written by guest, July 14, 2006
quote:

"No sympathy from me. The old saying "the grass is greener on the other side " is in the minds of Brasilians. They find out the hard way that life in the States is not like the sopa operas that they watch here. It's a shame that they cannot put the time and energy here, in Brasil, making their lives better, that they put in the life that they CHOSE in the States."

Last time I checked there was nothing keeping brazilians in the U.S., legal or otherwise, from leaving and coming back to brazil. It's fairly obvious by the huge numbers of them staying illegally that at a minimum they have a life there that they would never have in brazil.
dreams
written by Lance, July 15, 2006
Maybe Brazil needs to become the sort of place where people can see their dreams becoming reality. If you ask me, people who work menial jobs for peanuts without any social services are not "leeching" off the system. Having lots of babies here on purpose, different story.
...
written by guest, July 15, 2006
it is leaching off the system when you're not legally allowed to participate in it in the first place, and when these illegals are sending remittances back to their home countries to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars.
Nice try.......
written by Judge Dread, July 17, 2006
Nice try at making us all feel sorry for the flood of illegal immigrants into our countries. I'm British, and I can tell you that articles like yours, and the bleeding heart mentality behind it, is way off line. These people should be back in their own country, making things better there, not fleeing to somewhere else and then bemoaning their conditions.
above post...
written by guest, July 17, 2006
you hit the nail on the head!
It is heart breaking !!!!!
written by jean-jacques, July 21, 2006
It is truly heart breaking because unlike most mexicans brazilians are heart loving , sincere people. The people who repels immigrant don't have a clue about what the US is getting from other countries in the world ( cooperation in the fight against terrorism, oil from Nigeria , diamond from south africa etc,..) While I support legal and orderly immigration I think a guest worker program will give some relief and for people who have sacrified everything to come here.there is a lot of hatred in this country against immigrants. Violence ,insults ,robbery and humiliation against immigrants occur on a daily basis ,totally ignored . Even though I am documented , I personally plan also to live in Brazil one day too. I can not leave in this foulishness and hatred forever.Brazilian are wonderful people.
jean jacques
written by paula_schul, August 02, 2006
jean jacques what a moron

not all brazilians are sincere loving people, neiother all mexicans are a*****es

gotta love some of these americans and their hillbilly backwards 19th century stereotypes
Should have visited with them longer
written by a guest, August 20, 2006
I do not feel bad for them as either should the writer if she stays to know them longer she will see that in a few more years they will own businesses, own houses and cars and have lots of money in the bank. While many of us may think farms as what we see in in small towns or New york they will be buying farms like the texas farms or building appartment buildings. I know many who would never want papers because we with our papers ,are the ones who suffer and lack what is needed. Their plans all change while here for a while but all end of the same retire with lots of Reis at the youthful age of 40 While we work until are bodies won't allow us to any longer. Feel bad for the middle class who won't take hand outs and have to work forever not for those who will be retired and be happy even with all the problems in Brazil they will be very happy enjoying lots of time with their families. I know Brazilains legal and illegal from all over Brazil and all after 5 years in the USA live the same as middle class americans while building lives we couldn't image. Agree or disagree if any of us could retire at 40 while living as a middle class american citizen in another country who wouldn't?
I don\'t agree at all!
written by Alessandro, September 01, 2006
I am a Brazilian humanitarian worker in Afghanistan. Our NGO is based in Brazil and the Brazilian people are also helping finance our work here. You guys don't know what poverty you're talking about! I grew up lower middle class in Rio, and know exactly that anything that can happen if you truly want to make it happen! Stop wasting time on this forum! Brazilians in the US live much more poorly than in Brazil! It's ridiculous, sorry but it is! They live like criminals and are so prejudiced. Who wants that crap?! NOT ME!
Brazilian translater!!!!
written by Reggis, October 28, 2006
My name is Reggie..., i been living in United States for 17 years...loving each and every one of those years....Like you...a have not find time to go to school...and learn more than i wish in English...but just about enough to survive in your country.....i do own my business building stone wall.and doing mansonary work.....my company is well stabilish....and very profitable.... I love the oportunity that this country gave-me......and if there is anything that i can do to help you in Brasil... please let me know.
From november to april....i can help you in Brasil....in case you still need....if interested ...just email me at \n This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it '> This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it OR CALL ME AT 508-294-3962 LETS TALK.....!!!!!!

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack
Bankruptcy | Personal Car Finance | Credit Counseling | Buy Anything On eBay | Free Advertising