Brazzil

Since 1989 trying to understand Brazil

Search

Custom Search

Cheap Mobile Phones
---------------
Members : 2562
Content : 3357
Content View Hits : 20837973

Who's Online

We have 204 guests and 1 member online

Login Form




Pingo
Breaking News from Brazil
From Brazzil Mag news team
Brazzil Magazine


Lesson Number 1: Brazil Is Not the US. Now, Relax and Enjoy If You Can! PDF Print E-mail
Written by Robert Eugene DiPaolo   
Monday, 16 October 2006 18:12

Cover of Exame talks about Brazil's Bureaucrassaur I've learned a few things from spending time and doing business in Brazil, most importantly that Brazil is not the USA. While this is obvious, I say this because it's easy to forget. If you spend all your time comparing how things are done in Brazil to how things are in your own county, the USA for example, you'll end up feeling frustrated most of the time, rather than enjoying the things that are truly amazing about this country.

So, while dong business in Brazil can at times be difficult, the rewards can be tremendous if you are willing to take the time to understand the culture, how things work, and learn to adapt to a different set of rules.
 
For example, driving in Brazil is nothing like driving in the USA. In fact driving in Brazil can be downright chaotic by comparison. It often seems as if there are no generally accepted rules of the road by which you are expected to drive. It's like playing a video game, an adventure in which you never know what is going to happen next, and which requires your complete attention and absolute vigilance.

But, having learned to accept how things are, and to adapt, rather than being frustrated by the reality that driving in Brazil is not the same as driving in the USA, you can come to appreciate the experience of driving in there, and learn to treat every driving experience as an adventure, which it usually is. 
 
This said, sometimes it's helpful to compare how things are done in one country with how they are done in another, to give you perspective and provide you with a roadmap by which you can anticipate the turns, twists and obstacles you may encounter along the way.

It's like being in line at Disneyland. It's not so much about how long the line is, or even the fact that you have to wait in it. After all, this is what you expected when you decided to participate in one of America's premier cults of consumerism. What you really want to know is how long you're going to have to wait in line.

Well, Disneyland, at least the time I was there, has cleverly dealt with this problem by posting signs along the way telling you how much longer you will need to wait from that point on, thereby managing your expectations.

So, it is with this idea in mind that I've embarked upon our discussion of doing business in Brazil. To help you, the reader, and potential investor in Brazil, manage your expectations, to tell that there is a line in which you will have to wait, suggest how long you may have to wait there, and to let you know that while the line may be long, the ride at the end is, more often than not, worth the wait. 
 
Well, at this point in our discussion of doing business in Brazil, we're ready to discuss some of the steps you will need to take to start a new company through which to operate your business, buy a business or invest in Brazil.

For comparison sake, let's say you wanted to form a company in the USA. Our friends at the World Bank, who have determined that the USA ranks third, right behind Singapore and New Zealand in terms of ease of opening a new business, boil this process down to five rather easy steps, each taking one day, some of which can be performed simultaneously, so that you can be up and running in a week or less.

These steps include registering the business name and filing the certificate of incorporation or formation with the secretary of state in the state in which you are forming your company, and obtaining an employer identification number.

If you plan to have employees, you will need to register for sales tax, unemployment insurance and arrange for workers compensation insurance.

That's pretty much it, unless you need to obtain specific licenses for your business, or you've decided to form a limited liability company, or LLC, in the state of New York, which absurdly requires you to publish notice of the formation of your LLC in two newspapers over a period of six weeks within 120 days of formation. 
 
Now let's say that you've decided to form a Limitada, or Ltda., in Brazil, more or less Brazil's equivalent of an LLC, through which to do business. The World Bank divides this process into 17 steps, which together can take up to 152 days.

As discussed in our previous article, the steps and length of time required to complete each step may differ from state to state, but the process is essentially the same across Brazil. One reason the process can take so long is that the filing requirements are spread out across various governmental agencies.

For instance, to find out if the name you want to use for your company is available, you must go to the State Commercial Registry Office. But to form the company, you need to file what is know as the Contrato Social, or Social Contact, essentially the equivalent of the articles of incorporation and the articles of association, with the Commercial Board of Trade or the Register of Civil Companies, depending on whether the company's activities will be civil or commercial.

To do this you, as one of the two or more quotaholders of your Limitada, must sign the Social Contract to register your equity interest in the company. But you cannot sign on your own behalf. And why is this you ask? Well, your signature cannot be verified in Brazil, since you have no legal status there.

So, you will need to grant a power of attorney, or POA, to the person, generally a lawyer, although an accountant can perform the same function, but for obvious reasons using an accountant to do legal work is generally not recommended, who will draft and file your Social Contact with the appropriate governmental agency.

To complicate things even more, the POA must be signed and notarized in the USA, or your country of origin, and then legalized or consularized by the Brazilian Consulate which has jurisdiction over the state in which you reside.

And to complicate things even further, most Brazilian Consulates, for whatever reason, only accept postal money orders to pay for the fees involved. That's right, no checks (very un-Brazilian), not even bank or certified checks, no credit cards and no cash. In any event, the legalized POA must then be translated by what is know as a sworn translator in Brazil and registered before the public notary there. 
 
Following this you need to register with the Office of Federal Revenue of the Finance Ministry, to obtain a tax identification number, known as a CNPJ number, which also registers employees with the National Institute of Social Security.

You will also need to register with the Tax Authorities of the state in Brazil in which you have formed your Limitada. Needless to say there are several other steps, including getting authorization to print invoices and receipts, obtaining an operational permit and registering employees with in the unemployment insurance program.

You may even be required to obtain a Fire Brigade license from the state in which you have formed your Limitada. But, I will not elaborate on the rest of the steps at this time, since I wouldn't want to lose the few readers who have stuck with me this far.

However, if you would like to review all the steps, and the estimated time required to complete them, you can do so by taking a look at the World Bank's Doing Business Website at www.doingbusiness.org.

Next time we'll introduce you to someone who can help you coordinate and facilitate all the various tasks you'll need to complete to get your business up and running, from obtaining permits and import and export licenses, to simply helping you maneuver through the various levels of governmental bureaucracy in Brazil.

Robert Eugene DiPaolo is the co-founding managing director of Fidelis Group do Brasil Consultoria, Ltda., a legal/business consultancy specializing in assisting non-Brazilians who want to do business or invest in Brazil. He can be reached at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Comments (14)Add Comment
to the post above.
written by Righto, October 17, 2006
What a rubbish and boring note.
By the way stop comparing things with USA, as just because you may be from USA rest of all the gringoes in Brasil are not from USA. And USA is by all standard has lost its respect, and position so that it can be compared as a bench mark, for any thing.

Just being compared to USA is insulting.

Poor chaps, they dont even realise that the whole world is laughing on them.
Coming back to the note above, again comparison wont help to describe, if you are going to compare just 2.

Its apparent, you are targeting your USA origin clients through this note. You should title your note as "Advt"
rubbish
written by Errr, October 17, 2006
If anything we need to FURTHER compare how things in Brazil DON´T work to why things DO work in other countries. Maybe, just MAYBE, if we pound this home enough it will eventually sink in to the masses.

The fact that this author would highlight the piss poor and reckless driving as an “example” of “learning to adapt” after a long weekend where the accident and death toll increased 40% from the last feridão should send up a red flag that this spammer condones irresponsibility. Irresponsibility leads to death, ROBERT. There is no “their” way and “our” way in regard to driving – there is only the RIGHT way and WRONG way. Brazilians continue to jeopardize lives daily because the refuse to drive correctly and obediently, or more simply put; the wrong way. The stats prove this.

Maybe the author cherishes every near mishap on the roads and considers them all part of his great adventure in Brazil, but I think he would be hard pressed to sell that fantasy to the families of the thousands of road victims this country produces each and every year because it cannot teach and enforce even the most basic of laws like STOPPING AT A STOP SIGN.

“Next time we'll introduce you to someone who can help you coordinate and facilitate all the various tasks you'll need to complete to get your business up and running, from obtaining permits and import and export licenses, to simply helping you maneuver through the various levels of governmental bureaucracy in Brazil.”

If you truly believe that newcomers should adapt to “HOW IT WORKS IN BRAZIL” why not cut the crap, and post two or three phone numbers of well positioned “despachantes” who’ll cut through all the legal red tape crap and bribe the correct paper pushers? Easy Peasy.

My own advice would be that if you want to start up a business, DON”T. Brazil is horribly bureaucratic and you’ll begin to be taxed months before you are allowed to legally make your first dime. And that is just the TIP of the iceberg in terms of running a business in Brazil. For foreigners; you’ll also need to consider the “imposto de gringo”.
Thats Brazil !!!
written by Dude, October 17, 2006
Well ... I thought the article above was quit fair and a closer reflexion of the bureaucracy involved in openning a business in Brazil. Not sure if the guy who wrote the comment above understood any of it, tipical brazilian on defensive mode.
smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif
for the poster above
written by Righto, October 17, 2006
Now u know how to do business in Brasil. so go f ur a
I am sure you never knew how to do business in your own country. Probably you are roaming around the world trying to do some bit for yourself, but without success, with loads of negative attitude. Talking about being defensive.
Go search for some prestige and respect in Iraq, Iran, N. Korea, or for that matter brasil, and most of the countries in the world. Shame Shame Shame.
17 x 17
written by a guest, October 17, 2006
17 steps to open a business. 17 steps more to do one thing right!
Once the business is operational then the real bureaucracy for the
consumer begins! Have yet to find any in this country yet, who
can go thru a 2 step process in less than 6. Gravity and competence
remain consistent, so to bureaucracy and incompetence.
Comparison to NY is silly
written by REDNECK, October 17, 2006
Try to compare doing business as a Nevada corporation (you can do business anywhere)! However, comparing Brazil to Disney is interesting. Would you want to spend more than three weeks in Disney??!! Also, if you lose a video game, you lose some pocket change. If you lose at driving in Brazil, it will cost you your life.
doing business in Brazil !!!!
written by ch.c., October 17, 2006
The question is not necessarily comparing to the USA !
Simply stated as the writer of the article wrote correctly, just look at your ranking at www.doingbusiness.org. :
121 out of 182 countries !

Once more you excel.....at the bottom !
...
written by Ken, October 21, 2006
When the USA was in the cold war with Russia, we were taught to hate the Russians. When the cold war was over, we were amazed that we could ever hate those people. I felt like I had been deceived my entire life. The USA only has a few enemies now. Iran amd North Korea are the main focus. Chavez hates us, but we could care less about him. He is only using his hatred for the USA to hise his countries many problems. We do not hate the people in NK or Iran. These are good people, that have evil governments. We do not hate the people of Iraq.

Stop the hatred for the USA. We do not want to invade your country. We are not evil people. We are just as good or evil as any other country in the world. We have much in common. We can all get along.
Real issues
written by Oc, October 21, 2006
Born in Brazil and a Naturalized US citizian after 20 year of study and wait about a naturalizing decision, I have come to the personal conclusion that Bazil is not the perfect Country but US is far from being perfect as well. Burocracy is here and burocracy is there, and corruption is evrywhere... Drugs here & there bla bla bla...
The real issue ? ... There is none.
Both Nations are alike and need more of the same thing " God" / Moral values, better leaders, less human use and abuse."
Brazil will be wealthier and stronger when the Country and it's people decide to STOP giving it all away for free. When Brasil starts following the exemple US on Food for Oil, arms and other trades, and when the people finally learn to stop selling themsleves short servicing as mades, nannies or working for pure simpathy of foreigners. things will get better there.
Baziians are learning to follow the Leader (: & that is still the USA. Eventually it will be " As Monkeys see monkeys do"
OC
...
written by John, October 23, 2006
After living in both countries, it seems to me that it all depends on class (NOT INCOME, CLASS) There are low life Americans and Brazilians as well as great Americans and Brazilians. The people who try to compare the two countries usually have not live in eather place, except maybe as a tourist.

I met a European tourist in Rio who said that all Brazilian woman were "p**as". I asked him why he thought that. He said that every one he met was a hooker. When I asked him where he has been in Brazil, he said, "Oh, only here in Copacabana".

This reminds me of some of the people who write about the USA or Brazil.
MR.
written by EC, October 27, 2006
Rubbish indeed. I have the experience of living in my country of origin after living in the USA for 30 years. I find that cooruprion, no regard for the other, lawlessness, etc give the country a really bad taste plus anarchy. Shall I be content with anarchy. No way and never.
LMAO!
written by Bo, November 17, 2006
Well, Disneyland, at least the time I was there, has cleverly dealt with this problem by posting signs along the way telling you how much longer you will need to wait from that point on, thereby managing your expectations.



After doing in business in brazil for close to a decade I guess they need to put up road signs saying, "CAUTION, people absolutely do not respect any driving laws, nor are they enforced, the main objective is to get where you're going as fast as you can, endangering others is fair game!"

They need to put up signs at the police checkpoints saying, "If all of your documents are not in the proper order, don't worry, as long as you're prepared to bribe, uh-hum, buy a cerveja, for the policemen, all's good."

When doing business with the local or state gov't. agencies in brazil, and need their approvals for anything, they need to put signs out in front of their buildings saying, "If you've received a telephone call saying, "We have a probleminha, but it can be resolved", please bring cash, more cerveja is needed."

When needing to acquire documents for anything from local, state, or fed. gov't. agencies and you wait in line and finally make it to the front after hours, they need to have a sign stating, "We're more than likely going to send you to a different locale as you're not in the right place, and they're going to do the same, and so on, and so on, as we have no f**king clue as to what we're doing."

When receiving a bill from whatever utility company that is incorrect, they need to have a warning on the front of the bill, "If you're going to dispute this bill, it's going to take at least 3-4 months to resolve, and at the end of the day, it's going to cost you more to resolve in time and telephone calls that it would if you just paid it, SO PAY UP SUCKER!"

In the northeast of Brazil, the nordestinos need to be made to wear shirts saying, "I have no awareness of neither where I am, distance, nor space, if I bump into you, don't expect an excuse me, sorry, or kiss my ass!" smilies/wink.gif

When entering the banks in brazil they need to have a sign that says, "If you don't want us to take your blood, your first born, and leave you homeless and naked in the streets, don't even think about borrowing money or using credit here!!!"

When encountering a local, state, or federal politician in brazil, their bodyguards(lol), need to carry signs saying, "He is God, treat him as such!!!"

I could go on all day, but you get the drift.
Business in Brazil
written by DavidB, November 24, 2006
I'd give the article a C-. It was informative, but there wasn't much depth.
I'd rather see a more complete article that discribed the entire business setup in Brazil rather than just a piece of the pie.
Doing business in any country is difficult.
Let's not narrow it to just the US or Brazil.
Overall, good stab at the topic, but not enough information to really start up a business in Brazil.
Comments that take pot shots at either country appear to be uneducated opinions.
Stopping at stop signs would be a good first step.
written by Tommy, March 18, 2007
After ten visits to Brazil and driving on several of those trips I would say the best first good step would be make drivers there stop at stop signs.

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack
Hen Nights | Bad Credit Mortgages | Bankruptcy | Ford Cars | Personal Finance