Appeals Court in Brazil Overturns US$ 13 Bi Judgement Against Philip Morris

A cigarette pack in Brazil In Brazil, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Appeals of the State of São Paulo repealed, by unanimous vote, the judgment of the court of 1st instance that had found in favor of the indemnification claim brought by the Association for the Defense of the Health of Smokers (ADESF) against two Brazilian cigarette manufacturers.

The companies involved are Souza Cruz, a subsidiary of British American Tobacco, and Philip Morris Brasil, a subsidiary of Philip Morris International. They were found guilty of misleading advertising and had been ordered to pay 30 billion reais (US$ 13.2 billion) in damages in 2004.

In the first judgment, the judge had determined that every Brazilian smoker should receive 1,000 reais (US$ 439) for every year he or she had smoked. The judge arrived at the US$ 13.2 billion by assuming an average of 10 years of smoking for each smoker.

The Court of Appeals granted the appeals of the manufacturers on grounds that the lower civil court decision had violated the constitutional principle of due process of law since it had failed to extend to the manufacturers the opportunity of producing any evidence, including expert evidence that had already been ordered by the Court of Appeals itself.

This case, which is the first lawsuit of this nature filed in Brazil, began with the filing of a class action at the 19th Civil Court of São Paulo in July of 1995.

The plaintiff is ADESF, an association initially created by three attorneys and a doctor, 14 days prior to the filing of said lawsuit, which seeks to represent all smokers in Brazil. The entity is also linked to several anti-tobacco organizations and maintains a broad network of attorneys throughout the country for the purpose of filing lawsuits against cigarette manufacturers.

The 2004 lower court early judgment, which the Court of Appeals set aside, had found in favor of ADESF's requests, which sought indemnification for "all the consumers of defendant's products" for moral and material damages attributed to tobacco, in addition to having the manufacturers include in the cigarette packages the warning already imposed by the Ministry of Health in 1999.

With the decision of the Court of Appeals, the case returns to the original trial court for production of evidence and new judgment.

All class actions of this type that have already been judged conclusively by Brazilian Courts ended without the intended liability of the manufacturers. The subject matter of these class actions is identical to that of hundreds of individual actions already dismissed throughout the country.

The São Paulo State Court of Appeals alone has already rendered more than 30 rulings rejecting this type of product liability claim.

The main reasoning of the Brazilian Courts for rejecting this type of claim is: consumers have free will to decide (or not) to smoke, since the decision to consume the product or not is a question of free choice, the widespread public knowledge of the diseases associated with cigarette consumption and the absence of defect in the product because it is a product of inherent risk, the manufacture, distribution and sale of which in Brazil is authorized and subject to severe regulations by the state.

Tags:

You May Also Like

An Explanation for the Box-office Flop of Oscar-winner The Artist in Brazil: Ticket Shock

Silent movie The Artist may have won five Oscars last night, including Best Picture, ...

Brazil Creates Sentinel Hospitals to Deal with Bird Flu

The sentinel hospitals for the bird flu virus, that the Brazilian Ministry of Health ...

Chavez & Lula Win. Brazil Senate Votes for Admission of Venezuela into Mercosur

By 35 votes to 27, the Brazilian Senate approved today, December 15, the entry ...

For Brazilian Expert New Members Only Delay Mercosur’s Integration Process

Mercosur runs the risk of collapsing because it keeps adding members without consolidating as ...

One Hundred Years of Inequity

It is disheartening to witness Brazil once again discussing a minimum salary that belongs ...

Lula Is About to Fulfill His Wish of Getting His Good Friend Chavez in Mercosur

On July 4, 2006, representatives of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay met in Caracas ...

Businessmen Excited About Brazí­l’s Arab Summit

Commercial opportunities seem to be one of the main attractions for delegations arriving in ...

Brazil’s Vaccine for Foot and Mouth Disease Is Effective, Says International Lab

The vaccine used in Brazil to immunize cattle against hoof and mouth disease protects ...

Brazil’s Gol Airline Ranks Second in Corporate Governance

Brazilian Airline Gol was ranked second among non-bank companies in "The Best Governed Major ...

Directors and Actors Come to the US for Brazilian Film Week in DC

From Thursday, November 13 through Sunday, November 16, people from Washington, DC and vicinity ...