Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33083792

Who's Online

We have 607 guests online



Brazil: In Morrinho the War Never Ends PDF Print E-mail
2005 - January 2005
Written by Tom Phillips   
Wednesday, 19 January 2005 14:08

Morrinho, the mother of all Rio's favelas, in BrazilIt’s midmorning in Morrinho. Three figures peer down from a concrete rooftop at the favela’s entrance; one babbles into a walky-talky; either side stand men with rifles strung across their chests, all three wearing flip-flops. None is older than 20.

Morrinho, a sprawling complex of 15 favelas in Rio’s south zone, has been at war since 1998. Soldiers armed with AK-47s and AR-15s stalk its alleys; lookouts scan the urban landscape, waiting for the next invasion.

A police Special Forces truck rattles past on the motorway – BOPE (Batalhão de Operações Especiais – Special Operation Batallion), its feared and detested initial, painted onto the side alongside the image of a skull.

“You get it all here,” says filmmaker, Fábio Gavião who has worked in Morrinho since 2001. “Corruption, police violence. There was even an evangelical pastor killed here recently - he talked too much.”

Morrinho is typical of many Rio favelas. Split between three warring drug factions, its streets are a Far West in the south of Rio. At the entrance to one community, local graffiti artists capture the mood with a single phrase: “Colombia style.”

But Morrinho is no ordinary slum. For a start the houses around here are smaller than most. A three-story shack, for example, measures no more than 10 inches. The average Morrinho dweller is little over three centimetres tall, and made of plastic.

Morrinho (literally ‘little hill’ or ‘favela’) is Rio’s answer to Lego Land. The miniature city was founded in 1998 by a group of local boys and is located in Pereirão, a favela perched high above the upper class Laranjeiras neighbourhood.

“Before there was pretty much nothing to do around here,” remembers Paulo Vitor, 17, one of Morrinho’s founders. “So a few of the guys came up with the idea of turning the land here into somewhere we could play.”

The miniature city, made from a mixture of bricks and Lego, sprung up on what was once a rubbish dump, used by some of Pereirão’s 3,000 residents. It began as just one favela - Cidade de Deus, or City of God, the Rio slum made famous by Fernando Mereilles’ blockbuster film.

Like the real life Cidade de Deus, whose population continues to be bolstered by immigrants from the northeast, Morrinho quickly grew.

Swiping bricks from construction sites and recycling rubbish, the boys added a further 14 communities to the Morrinho complex.

A donation was even made by Pereirão’s then drug lord, who was apparently impressed by the kids work.

Fame only came to Morrinho in 2001 when a local social worker took filmmaker Fábio Gavião on a tour of the area. Gavião put together a documentary and word quickly spread.

As the favelinha’s reputation grew, visitors started to roll up in Pereirão from as far a field as Venezuela and Italy.

In 2003 Morrinho’s juvenile governors were invited to exhibit their work in a nearby museum – Santa Teresa’s Parque das Ruínas.

Rapper Gabriel, O Pensador and singer Fernanda Abreu have even recorded clips amongst Morrinho’s brick patchwork.

To its creators Morrinho’s is far from being a film set. In fact the muddy slopes are the setting for an ongoing role-playing game (RPG) in which Rio’s notorious drug wars are acted out on a daily basis.

Each participant controls a different favela, and is responsible for that community’s drug trade. It is a kind of South American Monopoly in which the players are cocaine barons not estate agents.

“For four rocks of weed you pay 100 reais,” explains Paulo Vitor, who administers the Formiga favela – in reality one of Rio’s most notorious. “And Coke is 100 reais for three rocks,” he adds, picking up a handful of chalk, used to represent cocaine in the Morrinho.
 
In the fantasy world of Morrinho it’s not a question of not passing ‘Go’ and failing to pick up your $200, but a question of life or death.

“It’s so real that you’ll even find couples getting it on in the motel,” says Gavião.

“When I asked the kids if the models used condoms, they laughed. ‘They’re already made of plastic,’ they said.”

Morrinho is so true-to-life in fact that the police tried to destroy it – mistaking it for a war plan.

“The police told us to take it down,” explains Paulo Vitor. “They thought it was a model being used by the traffickers to plan invasions of other morros (slums).

Fortunately some of them liked it and came here taking photographs. They convinced the others that it was just kids’ stuff.”

Kids stuff it may be, but Morrinho paints a brutal, and very real, portrait of twenty-first century Rio de Janeiro.

“A few weeks before the Tim Lopes murder one of the kids acted out a virtually identical scene here,” remembers Gavião.

In 2002, Lopes was executed in horrific fashion after traffickers caught him filming undercover at a baile funk (funk music ball) in Rio’s Complexo do Alemão.

Having been quartered with a samurai sword, his body was burnt in a so-called micro-onda (microwave) – a makeshift crematorium of car tyres often used to dispose of enemies.

As Gavião puts it: “There are no superheroes here. Here they only represent reality.”

Paradoxically, given the make-believe violence acted out here, Pereirão is one of Rio’s calmest favelas. Its last dono (drug lord), known as ‘Portuguese’, was killed during a police invasion five years ago.

Since then, Pereirão has transformed from a community controlled by the Comando Vermelho (Red Command) drug faction to what Cariocas (Rio residents) refer to as a ‘Comando Azul’ (Blue Command) one - in which police and not traffickers rule the roost.

“Pereirão is tranquillity incarnate. Total Peace,” says Gavião, in between phone calls preparing for the following day’s baile funk, organized on a concrete court at the foot of the community.

“Back in 1998 it was barra pesada (heavy shit), absolute war,” explains Paulo Vitor, whose grandparents arrived in the community over 50 years ago. “But this is all part of the past.”

“Every now and again the police come in here on training exercises, all dressed up in green and with helmets on, but it’s pretty peaceful.”

The sound of car engines below is barely audible and only the occasional plane coming into land at the Santos Dumont airport breaks the silence.

Unlike in the surrounding favelas of Fogueteira, Querosene and Prazeres, it is blood hungry mosquitoes - not drug traffickers - that pose the greatest threat in Pereirão.

Yet Pereirão suffers from other problems common to the poorer parts of Brazilian society.

Though an incongruous block of new houses built by the government’s Favela-Bairro project crown the favela, unemployment here remains as high as schooling levels are low.

The only politician Paulo remembers seeing in the community is Benedita da Silva, a favela resident turned governor of Rio, who was for a time in President Lula’s cabinet, before engulfing herself in a scandal involving use of public money.

“But she doesn’t count,” he explains from the top of the hill, beneath which Rio’s spectacular landscape spreads out before the eye. “She’s got some family who live down at the bottom.”
 
Life like in almost every other way, Morrinho’s local government is apparently not much cop either.

“More or less,” sighs Paulo, when asked how impressed he is by Morrinho’s make-believe prefeitura (City Hall).

Behind him at the entrance to Morrinho a quote from Bob Marley, has been scrawled onto a plaque, welcoming visitors to the embattled community. “My music is in favour of justice and against the set of rules that day a man’s colour should decide his fate.”

Tom Phillips is a British freelance journalist who has lived in Brazil for two years. He writes for the Independent and the Sunday Herald and has had his work published in newspapers around the world. You can contact him on: atphillips@gmail.com



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (31)Add Comment
This makes me sick
written by Guest, January 20, 2005
So this is now acceptable urban culture in Rio. A huge modle city glorifying gun toting drug dealers, couples "getting it on in motels", and a game of monpoly based on drugs and not money. And all this made possible by the local drug lord...my God. So some feel good socialist movie director make a documentory, and this place now has visitors, does Brasil not understand that they world visits this palce to laugh at us. What kind of future is in store for us with this urban culture. "Brasil's Legoland" how pathetic.
Get Real
written by Guest, January 20, 2005
What about all the "mainstream" toys that glorify violence, promote unnatainable physical appearence, feed on our greed? What about Grand Theft Auto, one of the most successful video-games out there? These kids are portraying what they see. What is disgusting for some, is a tremendous outlet of creativity for somebody else. More on them on http://www.clandesign.com.br/morrinho/.
Get Realer
written by Guest, January 20, 2005
Do you really think that that the kids from the favela's of West Rio have an opportunity to play "with mainstream toys"? For them a video game consel and video games, even counterfit ones are a dream. It is sad that they would spend their creative energy building a city that is as desperate as the one they live in, just what hope do they have? None...that is what is displayed in their art. I too am impressed by the talent needed to build Morrinho, but am saddened that it is used to create anguish. I will admit to perhaps an inital lack of perception, if the Director's movie was o bring the attention of Brazil and the world to the plight of these children, then God Bless him, if he did it to exploit these children, without a social conscious as so many do, then God Damn him. These kids should be in school learning to read and write, just imagine what these talented kigs could do if they were eductated. Right now they are just passing some time building models in a drug dealer incubator.
Misunderstanding
written by Guest, January 20, 2005
I didn't mean to imply that the favela kids have the opportunity to play with "mainstream" toys. I just pointed out that there is a lot of stuff retailing for less than 50 bucks at WalMart that show "a huge modle city glorifying gun toting drug dealers, couples "getting it on in motels", and a game of monpoly based on drugs and not money", as you said. Grand Theft Auto, for example. This is from their website: "Five years ago Carl Johnson escaped from the pressures of life in Los Santos, San Andreas... a city tearing itself apart with gang trouble, drugs and corruption. Where filmstars and millionaires do their best to avoid the dealers and gangbangers.

Now, it's the early 90s. Carl's got to go home. His mother has been murdered, his family has fallen apart and his childhood friends are all heading towards disaster.

On his return to the neighborhood, a couple of corrupt cops frame him for homicide. CJ is forced on a journey that takes him across the entire state of San Andreas, to save his family and to take control of the streets."

So, every kid in North America can be a "Gangsta"! This was a big best seller last Xmas. Meanwhile, the game developers are counting the bucks!

I hope these kids find the support they need to develop their art and get out of their dump. You may call me naive, but sometimes one needs to look beyond the "norm", have some vision, to find true greatness and potential where most find none. Remember that many artists portrayed anguish and dispair; Picasso, for example, painted on the Spanish Civil War, and there are more than a handfull of homeless or formeerly homeless plastic artists in North America.

One final point: I DO agree with you, that this is no LegoLand.
Amazed and confused...
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
An outlet, a place, a means, a way... Yes it may be in the form of what these children know, what is within their understanding, their realm of existence, and yes you may not "like it" or agree with it. I thank God for it. They found a means to express themselves. Something also tells me that they are "working together" to build and create.

I have walked through the Racihna and I did not laugh. I have watched the very young children selling anything they could on the street corners of Sao Conrado, I didn't laugh. I also saw the families living in the Favella, playing ball in the alleys, sharing cake and coke at the church and they were (are) beautiful. I wasn't laughing, I was questioning what I knew and what I believed. I was becoming more grateful and appreciative. I was learning...

So maybe you "Get Real" and others may be offended or put off by the expression created by these kids, or maybe we can all learn something about ourselves. Maybe we can open ourselves to their "reality" and know how much credit they deserve. SO many kids have SO much more, yet there are not many that take what they DO have and make, create, build, expand...

Yes, its no LEGOLand, but its theres and well its a lot more than many of us have ever done....
Wonderful thoughts
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
But smoke dreams, these kids are living in an incubator where there is no other option, but to sell drugs, indeed these are Drug Lord incubators, controlled by the ruling gangs, who offer the only real source of employement. These kids built Morrihno with the HELP of the ruling drud lord, do you really think he did it to show he has a big heart...Geez. "It's what they know, what does that mean? So what! The drug kingpins encouraging these kids to glorify the drug lifestyle provides what good? You foriegn liberals cease to amaze me. You "walked through a favela and did not laugh, saw camelos selling on the corners of Sao Cornado and did not laugh", good, it is not a laughing matter. Also, having a gang of armed teenagers stick an assualt weapon through your car window and taking your car is not funny, and the three kids that died yesterday, 5, 14, 16 in Catacumba hit by stray bullets in a drug gang shoot out is not funny either. This Morinho is not some "work of graffiti art in Los Angeles", but a work approved and supported by a killer, whose only goal it is to maintain control of these kids, so they can sell drugs for him when the time is right. This my amigo IS sick and perverted, and not something to be glorified!
Hmmm... foreign liberal? Maybe... Hopefu
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
At least, the very least, the author of "Wonderful thoughts" has passion! Thank you for your thoughts. I really do understand (though at a minimum) that my scope of understanding, my experiences are limited at best. And yes I hear you and your thoughts on how horrendous it really is. I was not trying to paint a Norman Rockwell design based on a situation that is beyond my capacity to comprehend. But from my humble insights, isn't this small "art" something positive in an otherwise no-win situation. Even if it comes from drug money, isn't it something?

I have no doubts that the lure of a few Real to fly a kite, with dreams of moving up in the drug market and more $$ is irresistable. How could it not be when you have nothing. The families of these children may (not always, but may) benefit and provide the children with positive reinforcement due to the "rewards", the glory and status, etc etc. How can these children NOT get involved when there are no other options?

And saying that, I think that because this is "what they know" (never mind the resource), isn't the small and maybe gratutious attention they receive from creating this "art" a better form of positive reinforcement? or at least a different kind of positive? Is it not (maybe) an alternative or a lesson for them or even an opportunity to experience something that is in their realm, but not destructive?

Maybe... is this something they can feel good about that isn't about killing and drugs?

Of course I agree its a "perverted" way to provide a child with options, but at least it is something....

Again, however... thanks for your input and passion. If nothing else maybe you and I can learn something from this!

Um beijo...
Nice and Constructive Dialogue
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
Thank you guys for keeping the debate constructive! So, let me get to it again... I think there is one point that all who have expressed their opinion here agree: in principle, the idea of expressing the reality one lives in through art (in whatever form) is a positive thing. On the negative side, there are arguments that (1) drug money finances these kids endeavours, and (2) that these kids should be at school. As for argument (1), I would use the old saying "ha males que vem para bem". Let me explain, based on Covey’s ideas: for every stimulus we have in life, there is a response. Between stimulus and response, there is a "space"; the size and nature of this "space" determines what the response is going to be (that is, the nature of your choices is proportional to the size of this “space”). In a nurturing environment, this "space" can be greatly developed; if we look at this “toy” beyond what it physically represents (that is, no more than a toy depicting the appalling conditions in which these kids live), you see a conduit through which these kids can let out some creative juices. After all, if you research what they’ve done to create this “world” of theirs, you’ll find that there was a lot of creativity involved. Now, continue looking beyond the toy: how can one support this artistic outlet (that is, starts improving the “space” I talked about) AND use that opportunity to improve the quality of their life (no, I am not talking material goods; I am talking about moral values) and of their community, REGARDLESS of where the initial "funding" came from? Have we all lost our hope? Regarding issue (2), that is, schooling, may be we should think in a “revolutionized” school system: 20% basic skills (reading and math), 80% emphasis on the guy’s demonstrated abilities. Improve someone’s self-esteem, and you trigger a process that can bring out positive leadership. So, yes, they should be at school, but the system that may serve you and I well, may be utterly useless to them. But nurture what they already have while working on the basic skills, and we may see positive change.

I know this is all controversial (and even boring!), but, who knows, these debates may, sometimes start something bigger out there. All the best
To Nice and Constructive
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
Beautifully put... Thank you for taking my sentiments and putting them into words that express the good that can be seen in this. Seeing the light and not the dark. We all can see that dark. That part is easy...

I don't know (yet) how or where I belong in making things better on this planet for even one person, yet with your eloquence you have set forth my thougt process (however much it is yet to be expanded and discovered).

I embrace these people. I can never comprehend their existence but I can cherish their gifts, as I do your gift of words and sentiments; your vision.

Thank you...
OK OK
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
We will have to agree...to disagree. While I will conceed, that perhaps this "art" can build the self esteem of other wise children without hope, I can not view Morrihno as a "breath of fresh air" in an otherwise stagnent enviroment. I know the reality, while the children were building this model with the Big Hearted Drug Dealers support, he had these kids mothers, sisters, and brothers, packing cocaine in the favela alleys. I am sure the "Movie Director" paid the Drug Lord for permission to make the film, and probably much more than he invested. It's just the way things are done here. I see these kids on the streets of Zona Sul, sniffing glue to kill their hunger. And the sad reality is in just a few years, they will be living the model they so accuratly portray. Yes I am jaded, but I thank God I am not one of the millons of Brasilians who just don't care about these kids anymore. I thank you for your comments, your thoughts are appreciated, but this is a Brasilian problem, and it will take a huge Brasilian effort to do something about it, I am one of the optimistic minority who still feels we can. Abracos.
You\'re welcome!
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
But let me give credit to Dr. Covey, who was actually my inspiration and the source of much of the philosophical background in my posting.

Although words alone will not effect change, action (as opposed to reaction) will. I hope you actually embrace the idea that you can choose your response to whatever the world brings on to you and act towards making that choice a reality.

All the best!
Maybe its more than a Brasilian problem.
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
But I understand and also concede that for all my caring and attempts to understand and so forth, I do nothing, in solving even the smallest (tiniest) part of this overwhelmingly insane and (please no...) irreversible issue.

Bringing awareness and understanding doesn't help at all I know... but please know that us foreigners (well hopefully the majority at least) are not laughing or finding this situation an interesting tourist attraction. Some of us feel as stymied as to how to help as you... We just don't have to face it and its horrors daily...

I send you love and hope from Canada.
Definetely: It is a Brazilian problem
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
I will not deny that the issue of how to eradicate the misery and inequality that led to the favelas in the first place is a Brazilian "internal affair". And you are probably making the right assumption, my friend, when you state that the "movie director" had to shell out some money to the drug lord at some point (at least, to guarantee some safety, right?). But the larger issue, the one which, I find, is universal, is what each and every one of us can do to help bring dignity to our fellow brothers and sisters. So, I choose to look at “Morrinho” and say: “You know, I bet I could get some inner city kids to do something similar, where I live. Maybe, we can get these kids to meet. Maybe I can set aside a couple bucks every month to help fund some bona-fide inner city art project – which, I confess, I have not done yet! – if that will help to bring some kids out of their misery.”

I don’t know whether you, or others here, are familiar with the poverty in North America. Everybody talks about the “rich Americans”, but nobody thinks about the fact that, in North America too there is poverty and inequality. So, perhaps, these kids may have something to teach to someone somewhere else in the world.

All the best!
Note from the author
written by Guest, January 21, 2005
"while the children were building this model with the Big Hearted Drug Dealers support, he had these kids mothers, sisters, and brothers, packing cocaine in the favela alleys"

With greatest respect, this is simply not true.
Note from the author?
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
Can you tell me/us more? What DO you know beyond what we all have seen (or at least heard about). A year ago last July an art center was opened in the Racinha favela. Can you tell me what has happened with that? It would be good to hear positive news... or maybe just another way for me to wake up a little more... but I hope not.

Thank you for taking the time to add your thoughts!
Mr Phillips
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
You article has generated a very civil and constructive dialog, something rare on thi site. But your statement that most of these kids, and their familes are not someway employed by the leaders of the drug trades is disengenous at best. You have painted a picture of hope and love in an world where there is very little of either. Yes, there are hard working, honest and simple people, who have fine values living in the favelas. Do you not find it troubeling that these families go to bed each night worried about stray bullets from shootouts with rivals and police killing their families while they sleep? And don't tell me (us) that the women of the favelas are not the ones doing the dirty work of preparing drugs for sale, both cocaine and pot, and now crack...this is simply not true. These women/children also provide the gangs money by selling themselves on the streets of Lapa or the beaches of Zona Sul, most just children still. Why is it that we read almost everyday about a mother using her pre-teen daughter or son to transport or peddle drugs. Or kids the ages of the ones who built Morrinho robbing tourists in packs of 20...or more. You have chosen to romantisize a lifestyle in Brasil that has nothing romantic about it. Parabens! Your article has had the effect you wanted, the foriegners who read it are "oooing and ahhing" over the wonderful little poor kids that have done something so wonderful in the favalas of Rio e Janerio" When in fact, these kids are the ones who will work on Morrinho because the Drug Lord liked it and it made him happy, and then blow your head off after taking your wallet and watch. This is the stark reality, why not write hard hitting articles that provoke Brasilians to get off their asses and do something about the violence that effects our lives everyday, instead of portraying the Drug Lords as modern day Robin Hoods?
Morrinho
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
The article, as the headline I think indicates quite clearly, is about Morrinho, one favela of around 600 in Rio de Janeiro. It is a community with very specific traits and it is a complete distortion of reality to define it as you have done. In answer to your question:

"Do you not find it troubeling that these families go to bed each night worried about stray bullets from shootouts with rivals and police killing their families while they sleep?"

Indeed, I do, but as I point out in the piece, this is not - currently, at least - Pereirao's reality.

As for your statement that... 'the women of the favelas are not the ones doing the dirty work of preparing drugs for sale, both cocaine and pot, and now crack...this is simply not true. These women/children also provide the gangs money by selling themselves on the streets of Lapa or the beaches of Zona Sul, most just children still.'

...this is a hugely simplistic, and if you'll forgive me, pornographic and stereotypical view of Rio's favelas. It denies them any sense of individuality and is, frankly, an utterly shallow, one-dimensional view point that conveys a completely distorted vision of Rio de Janeiro to the readers of Brazzil. Rio de Janeiro is a city with huge problems, as we all know, but to paint them in such primary colours is misleading in the extreme.
OK..I\'ll check it out
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
But to "paint over" Rio's problems does us no good as well. You have peaked my interest though, I travel and work frequently from my office in Engenho Novo, and although I have heard of Morrinho, I have yet to visit. I will do so in the near future. If Pereirao is as you say, well then, we need to find out what they did right, but I am very skeptical of the picture you have painted. Pereirao is surronded by other favelas, ones that we read about in the news everyday. How can one Barrio be so different? Becausee of Morrinho? Hmm...perhaps. There is something very unhealthy about children who play a game where "For four rock of weed you pay 100 reais, and coke is 100 reais for three rocks". I will say again, this is no Legoland, and it should not be portrayed as one. Abracos.
Drugs focus
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
I agree with you that Morrinho's focus on drugs culture is disturbing. The children there are very different to those you will meet in other inner city favelas: they swear less for a start, and seem less affected the cultura of bandidagem that is apparent in some of Rio's poorer areas. In this respect they are far more like the younger generations in Rio's suburbs, Sao Goncalo, Baixada Fluminense etc. It is exactly because of this that their focus on drugs is perplexing. They are portraying an undoubted reality, but it is actually a reality of which they mostly have very little direct experience.

I do think paying the community a visit is well worthwhile. It is, indeed, interesting how Pereirao has managed to avoid some of the problems inherent in other nearby communities.

In answer to the other questions posted: there are, as far as I know, 2 official cultural centres in Rocinha. The one on Rua 1, with which I am most familiar, is a fantastic place, which provides a whole range of cultural/artistic activities. It is run by a man called Soca Fagundes and is also well worth a visit.

And just to clarify one more thing, posted earlier on: "Do you really think that that the kids from the favela's of... Rio have an opportunity to play "with mainstream toys"? For them a video game consel and video games, even counterfit ones are a dream"

This is also not necessarily true. Video games are extremely popular in Rio's poorer areas (as elsewhere) and if you visit many of the favelas you will see games shops packed with under 15s.
Thank you
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
Thank you for updating me regarding the Racinha art centre. While there, I met a man who had been a part of opening it (it had opened the week before my arrival) and he was so full of optimism. I am SO glad that his (and all the other people involved) energy (and hard work) has created something good and something that has endured! Bravo!

I need to voice one not-so-positive statement however....

I am on this site and I am reading and engaging in this dialogoue and yes I am a foreigner, but....

I am not reading this article and "ooohing and ahhhing". I am however (how do I say this...) put off by the patronization of the writer of this sentiment. I wonder if this person realizes that these grandiose (and negative) generalizations/judgements create more negativity and can push us "foreign liberals" away. People that actually do care. (No we are not "laughing")

Are we niave? In a sense yes, we do not live this existence each day. Are we then stupid or uninformed? My resounding answer is no.

I again thank the writer for his/her passion, yet maybe if that energy was used to bring awareness instead of condemnation of both the "foreign liberals" or of the general population of the favelas, then maybe something beneficial CAN be created.

I have friends who live in the Racinha and they too are hard working SOBER people NOT selling drugs or themselves... It is from them that I have learned the positive. THEY taught me to see things in a new light...
Racinha ?
written by Guest, January 22, 2005
It's "Rocinha". Racinha in portuguese means little race, and it's used as a joke Brazilians use to poke fun at themselves (meaning "worthless race").
We're all very concerned about pushing foreign liberals away. They care so much and indeed help SO much in Brazil. What a shame !
Did not post\" Racihna?\"
written by Guest, January 23, 2005
But did post the intial objection to Morrinho, I would like to apoligize for those I have offended, it was not my intention. Perhaps I should reconsider my view on "feel good" articles about the favelas and take them for what they are worth...articles that make us all feel good. The fact is there is no "simplistic view" as the author acuses me of taking, indeed the problems are extremly complex, and have to do with not only Brasil's failed social and economic polices of the past, but also the polices of the developed world within our region. Yes, there are very good people living and working in the favelas trying hard to raise children with courage and charecter, but we can not ignore the fact that the drug trafficers maintain these favelas as their personal kingdoms by exploting the poor and unfortunate. They wield the power, and educated citizens with a heart are not in their best interest. I would hope even the author would conceed that there are many, many more "Red Command" favelas than there are "Blue Command" favelas, perhaps he can even give us the numbers. We are currently attempting to win a war, and make no mistake, it is a war, children are killed often, by stray bullets and brutal police, with corrupt officals and police to fight the war, can you guess who is winning? I do know that the percentage of police killed by the criminals increased this year, while the number of criminals killed by the police declined. If you can help Brasil, then we will gladly take your help, if you can offer moral support, then we will take that too. But most Brasilians have given up any hope, and the favelas, and the crime associated with them continue to grow. Again, forgive me if my passions offend, and I sound defensive, but my family has to live with danger everyday. Everytime my teenage son goes out with his friends, I literally worry sick, If my wife takes a bus to the mall, I call her and check on her saftey numerous times, this takes a toll on all Carioca's. The battle has just begun, we are in for a long bloody summer, the Federal Government is deploying nearly 1,000 Federal soldiers to fight crime in the favelas, at the State's request. But the trafficers are armed with everything from assualt rifes, hand gernades, and yes even land mines. This battle is long overdue, and it is support by the citizens of Rio, but like in all wars, it will be the children who suffer. If you really want to help us...then pray for them.
Again amazed yet not as confused...
written by Guest, January 23, 2005
I wish as well to be able to visualize any safe or possibly a better means to change all this, but I cannot. The Commando Vermehlo ("CV") has such a hold through threats of death, the drug lords hold hope in the form of cash, both strongholds that exceed my comprehension.

1,000 Federal Soldiers to fight many thousands... and what scares me further is the percentage within that 1,000 that receive some type of compensation from the very people they are now employed to fight? (How many work for, or ignore the workings by drug lords? How many are under the control of the CV?)

And you live in the middle, in a place whose natural beauty can be seen as nothing less than paradise. In a place where beautiful children kill other beautiful children, and do not understand what that really means. I cannot imagine your world where all of this becomes second nature, an integral part of your every day existence.

And I know its easy for me (and others like me) to respond to articles such as this from our safe worlds... and I respect your anger and fears.

When I write in this commentary, when I try to keep informed on what is "really" happening in your world, when I try to bring awareness to others, I do pray...

and I learn.

Desejo-o paz...


...
written by Guest, February 06, 2005
"but also the polices of the developed world within our region"

WHAT POLICIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DAMN you liberals/whiny Latinos . BE SPECIFIC!!!!
Another Brazilian
written by Guest, May 03, 2005
A correction towards my countryman´s previous post. The government is no longer supporting us. The military is avoiding intervention again.

I am a federal agent, I have been there and I agree with what was said before, the children have no choice. They are taught to cut the fingers of women in their vehicles to get their watches. They are taught to kill. Their environment is that of war, 90% of them have no access to education in any way. From their birth, they learn that the only way to be visible is by handling an AK-47.

Their brothers die by the hands of other traffickers or the police, and they take their place, willingly.

Aos brasileiros que lerem estas linhas: Muitas vezes temos de combatê-los, mas rezem por eles.
Who has been there?
written by Guest, May 24, 2005
I would really like to know how many of you who seem to know everything better have actually been in a favela (or better THIS favela) to make such comments.

I have lived there for a long time, as a tourist, but welcomed as a friend, by a wonderful project in the same favela, 2 minutes walking distance from "Morrinho". And, as funny as it may seem, the children there actually DO own video consoles, and they do NOT sell drugs, and as a foreigner you CAN walk there very peacefully and the film makes (who i met personally) has most likely NOT paid any drug or war lord,,, oh well, i could go on and on, but there are too many people here who know everything better.

Anyways, whoever wishes to see for himself is advised to stay at the POUSADA FAVELINHA, beautiful views, right there in the favela, in the center of Rio, great, peaceful, wonderful hosts:

visit: http://www.favelinha.com!

...and then post another comment here!
favela Rocinha
written by Guest, October 27, 2005
If the middle and rich class did not buy the drug, the traficantes would not be selling. Most of us in favelas have not the money to buy drugs.

Rocinha is best favela to live because lots of very good groups to help for art, education and creativty.

Not every body in favelas are wanting to do bad things. Many want what others have, just a chance equal to asfaltos!
I never knew...
written by Guest, January 17, 2006
I am only a senior in highschool, and I know I don't know much, but after learning about this whole thing, I realized that there is ALOT that us ( as americans ) are not aware of, we do live COMPLETLEY different lives...from what I know, what "we" veiw as " right and wrong" are based on what our past history has left for us,what our fathers taught us, and their fathers taught them, and so on. So understanding that concept, couldn't another "nation" form their own beliefs and systems of " right and wrong" due to their history or otherwise source of learing?

I only point this out because I hear alot of people talking about " doing the right thing", but to these kids, this is the right thing to do. "All a man has is his family and his pride!", This quote has really made me think about alot of things. I realize that I can never understand their lives comming from the life I do, but I greatley respect WHO they are as human beings.

I am not saying I think it is good for them, but it is their life, atleast while the government is avoiding them, they have no one to help them but themselves, so they do what they can to live, and they are not giving up.

"it's a dog-eat-dog world" ...to the extreme

- I apologize if my ignorance has offended anybody, I mean no disrespect or harm, please give me some feed back
I've seen the Morrinho Project
written by Jason Traeger, May 30, 2007
I was lucky enough to visit the Morrinho project in January 07 and I can tell you all that it's fantastic and the people who built it were as cool as could be. Everyone I met in the favela was beyond friendly. I'm writing to tell everyone the good news that the Morrinho guys are gonna be included in this year's Venice Biennale. Whatever you want to say about the project, these kids have made a whole lot of something from nothing and that should be commended.
I Hope You Understand A Few Things...
written by Bryn Hafemeister, September 07, 2009
I ran across this article and these postings only now as I returned from volunteering with Project Morrinho for 5 weeks a little over a month ago. I spent much time with the now grown up "kids" of Morrinho, and got to know the "next generation" of kids that they are teaching how to build and maintain the model. I am a high school teacher in the Miami, and was very touched and impressed with the "informal" means of education that goes on at Morrinho. Where else would a 26-year old volunteer so much of his spare time to make sure the local youth have a safe after-school retreat.? What this project offers to local youth is invaluable, and a true form of organic community organizing.

I have also been working with Fabio Gaviao in promoting Project Morrinho here in the U.S. I assure all who is reading this that Mr. Gaviao has done much to help these Rio youth. Those that commented above need not fear, the "boys" are doing very well and are great people. The reality that they continue to act out has garnered much national and international attention to communicate both the good and bad of Rios favelas - something very necessary as this culture is the "other half" of Rio. I do hope that there is much well-wishing for the future of Project Morrinho, because I saw nothing but goodness coming from there.
Rocinha
written by Zezinho, October 23, 2009
I live in Rocinha and know of several art programs, the one in Rua 1 run by Soca and a small one in the Valao at the bottom of the hill "Tio Linos" projet. I work with Tio's projet and believe that his program does help to keep kids busy and not going to trouble..myself and several other people in Rocinha are trying to change how people from the outside see we who live in favelas. There are many challenge to live here but I am happy I can try to help others in my work..

tem gente boa na favela tb..

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack