Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33083698

Who's Online

We have 554 guests online



No Job, Low Pay, Slavery: All in a Day's Work in Brazil PDF Print E-mail
2005 - April 2005
Written by Augusto Zimmermann   
Sunday, 17 April 2005 14:40

Slave work, slavery,  in BrazilIn regard to the rights of the working people, Brazil has a Constitution which says that a minimum wage shall guarantee the basic needs of all workers and their families with housing, food, education, health, leisure, clothing, hygiene, transportation, and social security.

This minimal wage needs to be periodically adjusted, so as to keep the workers' purchasing power. The minimum wage fixed by federal law is about US$ 90 per month. It is a ridiculous salary which certainly does not cover the basic needs required by law.

Yet, a research conducted by the IBGE National Household Survey revealed that 40 percent of all workers did not receive even such a miserable payment. The average salary is US$ 54, which is much below what the law determines.(1) As a result, at least 55 million Brazilian workers are surviving on half of a ridiculous minimum wage.

Whereas the Constitution of Brazil explicitly forbids any form of forced labour, the Brazilian Criminal Code punishes its organizers with no less than eight-year jail. However, many cases of forced labour have been reported in Brazil's northern and central-western regions.

In these areas, the use of forced labour has involved, among others, the exploitation of children in activities related to agriculture and the raising of livestock.

Also, illegal immigrants from Bolivia, Peru, and Paraguay, are working in the city of São Paulo under a condition which has been described by the International Labor Organization (ILO) as 'analogous to slavery'.(2)

The abolition of forced labour is hindered by failure to impose effective penalties, the impunity of those responsible, delays in judicial procedure, and the absence of coordination between the various governmental bodies.(3) 

Only in the Amazon region, the ILO estimates that 25,000 people are working as slaves in a range of activities which varies from the clearing of jungle for ranchers to the production of pit iron for charcoal smelters.

According to the ILO, these labourers are treated 'worse than animals', living under plastic sheets with no sanitation, and eating from tin cans used to hold pesticides.

Their workday goes from dawn until dusk and gunmen are hired to ensure order and prevent anyone to escape.(4) It has been reported that politicians, including congressmen, are using this sort of labour on their ranches.(5)

In its Article 170, the Constitution of Brazil states that the economic order of this country will have as its main objective the 'pursuit of full employment'.

In August 2003, more than 13 million workers were unemployed, and millions of others were unable to afford even a decent daily meal for themselves.

The situation was so bad that it seemed that the only available jobs were those offered by the federal government, at public agencies and companies, to members of the Workers' Party (PT). They must give not less than 10 percent of the salary to the coffers of the Party.  

In today's Brazil, real interest rates are the world's highest, the level of taxation is economically recessive, and bureaucratic rules and regulations are overwhelming at all levels of public administration. They have together acted as powerful obstacles to socio-economic development.

However, the PT federal administration is definitively not helping to solve the problem by raising even more the taxes and increasing government expenditures without benefiting the common citizen.

References

(1) Neves, Francesco; Five Million Kids Still Working in Brazil. Brazzil, Los Angeles, October, 2003. http://www.brazzil.com/content/view/1077/27/
(2) Brown, Paul; Shame of Slavery Blights Brazil's Interior. The Guardian, London, 19 July 2004. http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,3604,1264080,00.html
(3) U.S. Department of State; 2004 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices – Brazil.  Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labour, February 25, 2004. http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2003/27888.htm
(4) Kingstone, Steve; Brazil Slavery Damned by Report. BBC News. July 19, 2004. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3908271.stm
(5) Brown, Paul; Shame of Slavery Blights Brazil's Interior. The Guardian, London, 19 July 2004. http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,3604,1264080,00.html

Augusto Zimmermann is a Brazilian Law Professor and PhD candidate for Monash University - Faculty of Law, in Australia. The topic of his research is the (un)rule of law and legal culture in Brazil. He holds a LL.B and a LL.M (Hons.) from the Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro, and is the author of two well-known law books ("Teoria Geral do Federalismo Democrático" and "Curso de Direito Constitucional"). His email is: augustozimmermann@hotmail.com



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (42)Add Comment
Another Neo Socialist
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
The state must give this the state must give that

I'm nobody without the State

I'm always right And the Gvt Wrong


Get a life you Neo Socialist

Ps-

How is the sex trade in Australia lately??
CAn people in Australia control their fornication??

I guess that in Australia if you have money you just pay your way out of jail. Welcome to the First world

Last Updated 10/12/2004, 23:01:44

An Australian man accused of sex slavery offences involving Asian women has been granted bail with stringent conditions.

Our reporter, Melissa Sullivan, says the alleged offences occurred in the southern city of Melbourne.

Kam Tin Ho, 35, is the first person in Australia to be charged with conducting a business and entering into a commercial transaction involving sex slavery.

He is also accused of running a prostitution business without a licence.

The allegations arose after a number of Thai women claimed they were forced to work as sex slaves at two South Melbourne brothels.

Mr Ho's lawyer told the Melbourne Magistrates Court his client is not a flight risk because he has strong ties to Melbourne, including being the sole carer for a three-year-old daughter.

The magistrate agreed and released Mr Ho but ordered he pay a $US75,000 surety and report to police twice a day.


FIRST PERSON?????
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
WHAT A BIG JOKE
Erosion of Human Rights in Brazil
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
.
I congratulate Prof. Zimmermann for his lucidity and courage to regularly write insightful articles that reveal the dramatic erosion of human rights in Brazil, particularly over these last years.

Some balance at least
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
While the "slavery" problem in Brazil is being exaggerated as a propaganda tool against property owners, Mr. Zimmerman at least mentions that the Brazilian PT government is participating in a form of slavery by demanding kickbacks for government jobs.
To: Another neo-Socialist - YOU MUST BE
written by Guest, April 18, 2005

The first person who wrote the first comments in this section needs urgently to be confined into a psychiatric clinic.

To either compare the situation of human rights in Australia with the tragic situation in Brazil, or to say that the author is a neo-socialist just because he condemns slave work, the increase of taxes, and public expenditure, you really need to be completely crazy.

This guy must be totally mad or just writing a bad-taste joke.

...
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
"This guy must be totally mad or just writing a bad-taste joke. "

Nope. Just your typical Brazilian. It's that simple.
Propaganda
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
Another no sense over blow propaganda from Mr Australia.




$ 40 DVD player
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
I guess if we pay cheap for a product but is not build inside or country is ok to buy the product.
What about Wall Mart China cheap labor products??

I guess that in that case Slave labor is ok right???

What a bunch of Hypocrity
Slavery in the World
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
He he he he he he let's to discuss how people become slaver in this beautiful world. Today is not only in Brazil but all around the world. Sex slaver. How many women in the first world lives such existence?
How many Brazilian women, many of them well educated living in other Countries with out documents and being sexual exploited?
What about volunteeers jobs that there are in the USA and Canada even citizens professionals fall in such traps and never get a decent pay job.
Unfortunately, labours are slavers. Try to have a worker look for him a decent house, decent food, decent cloths, safe drugs, dentrist and medical attention. How much are you going to expend? So, it is better to give a miserable salary. Today, in what Country the salary is fair? Europe and North America is not the same anymore.
We should to stop to be patethic and be so scare about human exploitation. It was this way, it has been this way and it will be this way.
Stupid is the man, which looks for a job.
Human Rights
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
To quote the late US President Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1944: "The test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; it is whether we provide enough for those who have too little." To this end he suggested a second Bill of Rghts: Among these rights, he said, are:

"The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the nation.

"The right to earn enough to provide adequate food and clothing and recreation.

"The right of every farmer to raise and sell his products at a return which will give him and his family a decent living.

"The right of every businessman, large and small, to trade in an atmosphere of freedom from unfair competition and domination by monopolies at home or abroad.

"The right of every family to a decent home.

"The right to adequate medical care and the opportunity to achieve and enjoy good health.

"The right to adequate protection from the economic fears of old age, sickness, accident and unemployment.

"The right to a good education."

These are my wishes for Brazil and the world.
RIGHTS
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
SORRY! WHAT THE GLOBALIZATION IS DOING WITH ALL OF US?
THE RIGHT TO WORK FOR LESS
THE RIGHT TO PRODUCE FOR LESS
THE RIGHT TO MAKE LESS

WHO IS THE WINNER?
What rubbish! Neaderthal man
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
I would hate to start comparing Brasil to Australia...but I couldnt help noticing Neaderthal man picking up the Sex slavery article. The glaring difference besides being the 5 % unemployment (but yet similarities between the two countries) is that the sex slaver in Australia will be going to Jail for a few years. In Brasil he wouldnt have been caught in the first place because of his large donation to the local police retirement fund. I would also point out that Brothels are legal in Melbourne where laws govern and control this industry very carefully. Often what does occur with sex slavery in most 1st world countries is that the workers are foreigners from Asia who arrive and work illegally to earn money to send back to their families. Invariably there are unscrupulus pimps who, with their ethnic connections encourage "workers" to arrive and take their passports away. Furthermore requiring the workers to work until they buy their passports back for huge sums.
Protection of the underclass should be the priority of any nation. Obviously Brasil has a long way to go before it can sort out this problem but it doesnt help that the country is riddled with self serving politicians and a huge level of foreign debt. The primary concern i think is education. Educate the masses and they will make better decisions. Educate the masses and they will be more selective who they vote for. Educate the masses and they challenge their position. Educate the masses and corruption would be harder to get away with. Educate the masses and Brasil will be more competitive, efficient and effective.

As one famous Australia Prime Minister once said " Life wasn't meant to be Easy".

Missionary
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
Sounds like what Brazil needs is a REVIVAL from Heaven!
Only having God convict of sin, and the people repenting, and turning from their sin, can Brazil avoid the judgement and destruction which God has inflicted on all nations who continue in rebellion against Him. Righteousness exalteh a nation, but sin is a reproach to any people.
Only when Brazil turns to God can she turn from the darkness that engulfs her. There is no other way. Since all men are corrupt, then no man can do anything to help. And since the governemt is made up of corrupt men, the government can not bring real chang either. John and Charles WEsley preached to the nation of England when they were in a similar condition, "Ye must be born again". The revival that came thru their preaching saved England from Civil war and destruction. Where are God's Holy preachers, stand up, and lift up your voice like a trumpet and show my people their sins.
Marxist Dialectic
written by Guest, April 18, 2005
As usual, Mr. Zimmerman presents us with another interesting review of some aspects of Brazilian reality. Never mind the fact that his analysis is purely academic and aimed at supporting his fundamental doctrine: that the erosion of "western" (i.e., judeo-christian) values is undermining the very basis of "western" society, to which Brazil belongs, and that these -- and only these -- absolute values will prevent further decay. Inasmuch as I agree that moral relativism (i.e., multiculturalism) won't generate a strong society, tolerance will.

Now, back to the topic in hand (in a nutshell: human rights violations). Mr. Zimmerman attempts to demonstrate, in his thesis work, that the Brazilian people, whose values, in his opinion, have been and continue to be eroded, is unable to abide by the Constitution -- and derived laws. We have to be careful here with generalizations: this idea suggests that all Brazilians will sheepshly adhere to the many bad practices of some. This is far from true, as attested by the fact that there are many respected members of Brazilian society who go about their daily business respecting the laws. Nevertheless, for the careful reader of Mr. Zimmerman's articles, it becomes apparent that, after all, the "elite" not only exists, but it is also alive and well above the law. In fact, Mr. Zimmerman, in previous article, indirectly highlights the existance of the "elite" by flashing the light on the MST.

Don't get me wrong, I don't like the MST. But Mr. Zimmerman presents us with one of the best examples of Marxist dialectic: the "elite" exploits people and violates human rights; the "peasants", on the other hand, invade their lands, in search of a better life. So, I guess if I side with the violated, I will be called "marxist"; I wonder what one would be called if siding with the violators.
Righteousness exaltheth a nation
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
I'm with the "Missionary" guy.

The best hope for Brazil comes from the rapidly growing influence of protestant Christian fundamentalism imported from the USA. Look at how the United States' puritanical heritage has helped and blessed it.
USA is a melting pot
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
It was long time ago that Protestant fundamentalist influenced the USA. If you visit the areas where the Protestant fundamentalist lives in the USA, you are going to find a lot guns, bibles and poverty.
Who did the modern america were people from different cultures and backgrounds. Take off from the mind that Religious is a key factor in the USA today.
...
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
If Mr. Zimmermann is so smart why is he not studying in a world-class, highly respected university?
...
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
"If Mr. Zimmermann is so smart why is he not studying in a world-class, highly respected university?"

What the f*** does that have to do with anything? Where does he profess to be "so smart"? Zimmerman writes an interesting acticle and you polk a cheap shot at the University? That's posh.

Take a note from Marxist Dialect, I think he has over analzed the article and is looking for ghosts that don't exist, yet s/he has elquently made a contribution and used what the author has presented to back up her/his ideas. That's constructive! S/he, like the author, gives you something to think about regardless if you agree or not - you however, have added nothing.

Also, would you care to share with us your level of education and the University in which you attended?
...
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
Monash University is a world-class, highly respected university.

A PhD from Monash will get you a job anywhere.
Monash University
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
"Monash University is a world-class, highly respected university.

A PhD from Monash will get you a job anywhere."


At least in my field, Monash University is just another mediocre place. If you do not trust my judgment, take a look at two recent world-rankings of universities. One elaborated by a Chinese university (http://ed.sjtu.edu.cn/ranking.htm) and another one by the TIMES (http://www.thes.co.uk/worldrankings/).
Just to satisfy the curiosity of one of the authors of a previous post, I graduated (doctorate) from a top 20 (in both rankings) university.
...
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
I graduated (doctorate) from a top 20 (in both rankings) university.

Is this how a Phd. answers a simple question? f**k that was vague. Must be a social scientist.

Doctorate in WHAT from WHERE?
Bigoted Lies:
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
Bigoted Lies!
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
Re: If you visit the areas where the Protestant fundamentalist lives in the USA, you are going to find a lot guns, bibles and poverty.

You are a slanderous religious bigot!

Forsyth County, Georgia:
Meidan Family Income (countywide): $74,003
Umemployment Rate (countywide) 1.9% average
Median Home price in zip code 30097: $538,750
Percent college graduate (countywide): 40.6%
Reply to \"Ghosts\"
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
The ghosts are there:
www.endeavourforum.org.au/oct04-06.htm

Nothing personal on Mr. Zimmerman, but you have to try to understand the person behind the "pen" to fully get the meaning of the message.

Sin Is A Reproach To ANY People
written by Guest, April 19, 2005
An integral part of righteousness is compassion for the disadvantaged. Exploitation of others for financial, personal, or social gain is UNJUST. It is EVIL to expect working people to live in tarpaper shack slums so that wealthy employers can enjoy obscene opulence.
Can we stay on topic?
written by Guest, April 20, 2005
So far many of the posts related to this article seem to be unrelated to the topic at hand. I think the author has tried to do a service by raising the awareness of the situation in Brazil. This is not to say that there are not problems in other coutries in the world, but this site _IS_ dedicated to information about Brazil - not to Austrialia, the USA, etc. The first step to solving a problem is recognizing its existence.

Since qualifications seem to be important on this thread for some obscure reason...

...University of California at San Diego, 1981, Economics (and no, I'm not the previous writer, just a person who loves Brazil and wishes the best for it).

...
written by Guest, April 20, 2005
"At least in my field, Monash University is just another mediocre place."

That's a little harsh. Even by The Times survey you yourself linked to above, Monash ranks 33 overall in a list of the top universities in the world.

OK, it's not Harvard, but I'd hardly call it mediocre either.
Author\'s worldview relevant
written by Guest, April 20, 2005
The article cited above is from the Endeavor Forum website, which proclaims:

"Endeavour Forum was set up to counter feminism, defend the unborn and the traditional family. ("A feminist is an evolutionary anachronism, a Darwinian blind alley".) "

Without a doubt, Zimmerman is fringe thinker, a religious zealot and complete throwback…not to mention one strange dude. His articles here are always a list of "facts," selected and sometimes slanted to support an unstated preconceived theory, but stated in a faux disinterested way.
Bulls-eye!
written by Guest, April 20, 2005
Finally! Congrats to poster of "Author's worldview relevant". While Mr. Zimmerman clearly has a "thing" for collecting data, his ultimate analisys of the "information" he presents (if any) will always be tinted with his own fundamenalist views of a perfect society (Brazilian or not), and will be unable to present any practical solution. This inability to provide a practical solution stems from the fact that his whole work has a major stumbling block: to fix the (un)rule of law in Bazil (and the world), one has to bring in the ONE and ONLY true value; but this same (un)rule of law is in itself the source of destruction of this ONE and TRUE value, as it feeds from it. So, his analysis may have academic and spiritual value, from a theological point of view, but lacks practical use. That is: will a thousand missionaries of whatever faith FIX the injustice in Brazilian (and other) societies?

I am sure our economist friend from San Diego could say something about wealth distribution, which is another underlying issue of the facts presented.
Puritanical capital
written by Guest, April 21, 2005
If it's not convincing that the United States' puritanical cultural capital is the cause for its wealth and the reliability of its institutions, then perhaps the situation of the Bahamas might be more convincing.

The Bahamas is the only country where the population is predominantly of African descent and where its people enjoy more or less first-world standards of living. And it's the only country with a population the majority of which if of African descent that has a puritanical heritage.

In stark contrast, Haiti nearby is resplendent in its lacking of any puritanical heritage, its African paganism still widely and openly practiced as if the influence of Christianity had never been felt there. And, needless to say, Haiti is one heck of a poor and messed up country.

Nuff said.
Monash uni
written by Guest, April 21, 2005
As to Monash University, I wasn't aware it was "mediocre". And I also thought it may be the biggest university in the southern hemisphere (I don't know whether it's bigger than USP).

Besides, I'm under the understanding that what makes a university more "presitigious" than another is the amount of papers its faculty staff publish. One plus one equals two in Harvard as well as Alabama State University.

Nuff said again.
Federal University of Parana
written by Guest, April 22, 2005
The Federal University of Parana PhD program will not get job to you in no where. You must satisfy yourself finding a job in a small country side university in Brazil giving mediocre classes.
Mormon Fundamentalist in Brazil
written by Guest, April 22, 2005
Brazil needs Mormon Fundamentalist to help the development of the country. Once, they make strong families bond and family is the cell of a society. Brazil lost its cell through promiscuity. Once Brazil men can not live without more than woman. It is necessary to re-educate the population in Christian, Family values. The Mormon Fundamentalist is a true religion,where a man is in control of his wives.
Monash University
written by Guest, April 22, 2005
Monash is Australia's most internationalised university. It has eight campuses including one in Malaysia and one in South Africa, and centres in London, UK and Prato, Italy. An energetic and dynamic university, Monash is committed to quality education and research.
Missionary Position
written by Guest, April 22, 2005
The Federal Govern in Brazil should open a lot missionary position in Brazil to help Brazilian learn family values and improve skills for life time.
Ph.D. Candidate
written by Guest, April 23, 2005
By the way, a Ph.D. candidate is someone who already finished his coursework, defended his thesis and is just waiting for the degree. Otherwise you are just a Ph.D. STUDENT. I wonder if Mr. Zimmermann knows the difference ...
USP X Monash
written by Guest, April 23, 2005
USP is bigger than Monash ....
Ph.D. Candidate
written by Guest, April 23, 2005
Zimmer is a prolific writer, and has spawned quite a bit of dialogue and debate on this site and I imagine others as well. I'd like to see how widely published he actually is. YOU on the other hand write little more than simple childlike playground taunts on a blog. DO YOU KNOW THE DIFFERENCE?
missionary position
written by Guest, April 24, 2005
I do not like the missionary position .... doggy style is much better ...
...
written by Guest, April 26, 2005
"The Federal Govern in Brazil should open a lot missionary position in Brazil to help Brazilian learn family values and improve skills for life time."

"I do not like the missionary position .... doggy style is much better ..."

Sweet. But I think that dissemination of the Kama Sutra would do more to help brazilians improve skills for life time. It covers many more wonderful and enjoyable positions.
Great
written by Guest, April 26, 2005
That is it! Let's invite Indians to Brazil to teach the Kama Sutra and help us learning family values. Also, we could use sex as a way to improve the living conditions of poor Brazilians laborers. A wonderfum idea!
...
written by Guest, April 27, 2005
many people in the frist world pay good money just to be a sex slaves mabey theres an place for them too

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack