Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33083419

Who's Online

We have 642 guests online



Brazil Can't Answer This Question: Where Did the Corruption Money Come From? PDF Print E-mail
2005 - September 2005
Written by Carlos Chagas   
Sunday, 25 September 2005 19:36

Senator Heloísa Helena, a possible presidential candidate to next year's electionWhile the Brazilian Lower House bickers about who will be the successor of House Speaker Severino Cavalcanti, the leaderships of the main parties are already discussing on another level: they are interested in knowing who will be the presidential candidate for next year's election, which will also depend on the election of the Speaker of the House.

The connection is simple: if the PT is able to get Arlindo Chinaglia or anybody else, it will mean the beginning of a slow but possible recovery of the party, ready to launch itself in the campaign for the re-election of president Lula. In case José Thomaz Nonô becomes the new Speaker of the House, however, the opposition alliance PSDB-PFL will have been quite reinforced, benefiting São Paulo mayor José Serra or São Paulo governor Geraldo Alckmin, from the toucans (the PSDB party), or César Maia, from the liberal side (PFL).

In a third hypothesis, if Michel Temer is the winner, the PMDB will get the role of succession wild card, meaning that whoever the party supports will have a good chance of winning the presidency whether they present their own candidate or not.

What is also being debated is the possibility of a third way working out: in this case, the chosen wouldn't be either a toucan or President Lula, but someone able to become an option between six and the half-dozen represented by the Workers Party and the former president Cardoso's party, the PSDB.

In such a scenario, those on the left will be the first focus of attention: who would be that candidate with proposals opposing neoliberalism? Roberto Freire, already launched by the PPS? Ciro Gomes, from the PSB? Heloísa Helena, from the P-SOL? Or someone from the PMDB, where Anthony Garotinho, Germano Rigotto and Roberto Requião dispute without the leftist label?

Translating all of this: the selection of the new Speaker of the House brings into play next year's presidential elections.

Where the Money Came From

It is undeniable the assistance that the CPIs (Congressional Inquiries) are providing the institutions, investigating, hearing and even showing part of the great festival of scandals fostered by the government, by the PT and their allies. Except for the sometimes grotesque show of congressmen who do not know how to ask a question, but just wish to promote themselves, the truth is that the Post Office, the Mensalão (Big Monthly Allowance) and the Bingos CPIs are contributing to the fight against corruption.

The problem is that no CPI managed to get an answer to the main question: where did the money to pay mensalões, buy votes, deputies and parties come from? There is no certainty about the main source, that is, whether the resources came from publicity contracts and overbilled services of public companies with private companies; whether they resulted from loans that were never going to be paid, made by private banks in exchange for illicit favors like huge pension funds being deposited in their safes, or whether the money came from donations of groups and even governments like Taiwan, Farc or Muammar Gadafi.

The most probable is that that mud river has been fed by all the aforementioned tributaries and a few more that we are not aware of. PT treasurer Delúbio Soares, adman Marcos Valério and, without any doubt, former Chief of Staff José Dirceu know very well where this money came from. It came? It is good to watch out the tense of the verb, being important to discover the source, with all the consequences.

In Free Fall

The public opinion is usually slow in their reactions and judgments, much more than the published opinion. Anyway, it is unforgiving. The masses, especially, take time to notice any phenomenon. This represents a valuable quality since it does neither keep oscillating like an airport windsock nor does it allow itself to be led by the last heard comment.

The polls conducted since the mensalão scandal surfaced leave no doubt about the President's situation. Week after week Lula's and the government's popularity keeps going down. What once seemed unquestionable has become a question mark. I'm talking about the re-election of the President. Reduced to smithereens the PT, which used to be Mister Ethics, has 91 House representatives, but this number will hardly reach 40 come the elections.

The government's image keeps fading away day after day, worn out due to the continue use of neoliberal politics and to the false propaganda that unemployment is going down. Because it is not. Unless you're talking about the Silva family.

For all of this, the tenants of Palácio do Planalto suffer at each new poll. If things keep going the way they are soon we will get mad men suggesting that Lula ban the release of new numbers. How? Cutting the recalcitrant publications who insist on publishing bad news from the government's ad budget.

Carlos Chagas writes for the Rio’s daily Tribuna da Imprensa and is a representative of the Brazilian Press Association, in Brasília. He welcomes your comments at carloschagas@hotmail.com.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (14)Add Comment
from where the money came from.....
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
...Valerio made loans...tens of loans...from contracts he got and will get from state agencies !This was clearly demonstrated over and over again !!!!!

For the remaining amounts, no one will ever know as long as your "justice" give a habeus corpus to the pollticians investigated !!!

That protect them to give the truth to the investigators !!!!

BUT AGAIN, WHO CARES AS NOBODY WILL BE PUNISHED, FINED OR EXPULSED ANYWAY ????

SOME SAID IT ALL :IT WILL ALL END UP IN THE PIZZA...AS USUAL...WELL COOKED !!!!
Mensalao?
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
The mensalao was claimed to be a $12,000 monthly payment to non-PT legislators for votes. I have read of Valerio's money laundering and his loans to politicians. I've read of illegal campaign funding involving Valerio. I've read of corruption by many politicians of many of Brazil's parties (though conspicuously absent from articles is the party affliation mentioned when a non-PT politician is involved, see, e.g. above "House Speaker Severino Cavalcanti" never identified by his party affiliation). I have never read of evidence that $12,000 per month was paid to anyone in exchange for votes, i.e., I've not seen any evidence of the so-called mensalao. Yet, articles like this one assume its existence. Pardon me if this is so, but have I missed news proving that anyone was paid $12,000 per month by the PT in exchange for support of PT legislation? Thanks.
Please read carefully.....
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
...today article, in the same Brazzil.com referring to Dirceu that said sunday :

Mr. Dirceu added that President Lula took part in PT discussions to craft a political alliance policy whereby it could rule, as it did not have a majority in Congress. These were allegedly the internal negotiations that gave rise to the scheme to buy votes of non-PT congressmen to support Lula's largely socialist agenda.

There is even more evidences should you read his statement...carefully !!!!!

Furthermore why do you believe that the CPI, after their investigations, want 20 members of the Congress...to be expulsed ?????

Because they found them....innocent ?????

So.please stop closing your eyes and put your hands into the holes of your ears !!!!!
This is exactly what your politicians are expecting from you.....to hide their true tricks and dirty games !!!!!

Also why do these politicians get the habeus corpus...which effectively means that they are not obliged to answer questions...if their answers would incriminate themselves ???????? Come...on ! No need to be very smart...to understand this protection given to them !
Wake up, stand up...unless you are part of one of the political gangs.... !!!!!!

And for Valerio and his loans.....why were loans given.... WELL AFTER...the elections ??? Smile............

You have not missed news...if you dont read the many ones published... everywhere ...including in this site...not later than today..and so many earlier !!!!
Foreign Money??
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
Could be that the money is coming from a foreign interest (country, group or organization) willing to destabilize the leftist Brazilian government? Could it be also that Robert Jefferson is actually acting in their behalf by blowing the whistle and cause all the political crises?

What would be best way a foreign group or another government could use to destabilize such a politically fragile country like Brazil?

Just wondering!
foreign money.....
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
accepted by the PT party....to destabilize the country ???????

Come on ! Be smarter !

Just read what nobody else but.... Dirceu himself said !!!!!!!!



Please just read the brazilian news. Money did not come from Jefferson....he got money...he did not pay money ! dont confuse who paid and who got money !

Some of the money came from Valerio...through loans to the PT party...BEFORE AND AFTER the presidential
elections !!!!! Why...after ???? smile......

Dont put your head in the sand...and see/hear/read/smell....nothing !!!!
Conspiracy hypothesis
written by Guest, September 26, 2005
…accepted by the PT party....

No, accepted by some criminal members of the PT Party. They would not care where the money is coming from, really.

I am not saying that Jefferson is the one paying the money. What I am saying is that they used him to blow the whistle and he is collaborating directly or indirectly with the plot.

Consider the possibility for a moment that someone out there wants Brazil to sink pretty deeply and how would that be possible without promoting a military coup d'état? By using the Brazil’s traitors (AKA, politicians) to corrupt and therefore destabilize the political systems. Obviously, Lula popularity is dropping.

Sounds farfetched? Go and read books on History. They have plenty of examples about political evil plots.

The scheme could be well organized and would not be so simply evident that some international corruptors are acting behind the curtains.

As you see, I am not denying the corruption scandal. I am not blaming the foreigners. I am blaming our corrupting politicians.

They may be so corrupt that they would accept money from a foreign organization or country; they would not care at all. They are evil doers.

Just wondering.
YOU ARE EXACLY RIGHT!!!
written by Guest, September 27, 2005
First of all, I am an American that loves Brasil. I am married to a Brasilian and we hope to move there in 2 more years.
I am delighted about this "scandal"
Not because I want to see 'bad' in Brasil, but I see this as "good".
Democracy does not mean that "only" everyone votes. Brasil must hold it's politicians accountable and this is a "sign". American politics are far from perfect, as are everone else's, but to hold politicians accounatable is the only way to 'true" Democracy". Here in the US we have Congerssmen in jail that have done wrong. I hope Brasil will use this opportunity to DEMAND accountability from politicians and achieve the greatness they are capable of.
With the human and natural resources that Brasil holds, they are completely capable of being just as rich and a "Superpower" just as the US.
RE: YOU ARE EXACLY RIGHT!!!
written by Guest, September 27, 2005
And I agree with you. The scandal I see in Brazil is actually good in many senses. They serve the purpose of teaching some necessary lessons to our people. We need to become stronger politically, socially and as a nation however our path to achieve that status looks too painful and troubled sometimes.

Most Brazilians wish we could send all those politicians to a long term in jail, believe me. Brasilia would not dare to run a universal referendum for that matter.
The money comes from OUR SINDICATE PAYME
written by Guest, September 27, 2005
Hi, I am another Brasilian worker who slaves away in a corporation and pays his annual sindicate fees as a union member and receive absolutely nothing in return that I can see of in terms of tangible service from the sindicate(not even a newsletter?). Now with 50,000,000+ sindicate members in Brasil, each paying R$100+ per year to there sindicates for very little or no service, you can they have a little surplus left over eh? That would make R$500,000,000 p.a. in sindicate fees less cost of running sindicate union (say 25%), it still leaves R$375,000,000 to throw at politicians to buy votes supporting the PT in parliament. That should cover the mensalação for a few politicians would you not think?
John


Mensalao?
written by Guest, September 27, 2005
I'm sorry, but no one has answered my question, though I think the person who wrote "Please read carefully" thought he/she was doing so.
Read carefully?
written by Guest, September 27, 2005
"Mr. Dirceu added that President Lula took part in PT discussions to craft a political alliance policy whereby it could rule, as it did not have a majority in Congress." Well, I don't find this surprising or damning in any way. Of course Lula needed to form an alliance to get legislation passed!

"These were allegedly the internal negotiations that gave rise to the scheme to buy votes of non-PT congressmen to support Lula's largely socialist agenda." Note the word "allegedly." I think YOU need to read more carefully. Alleged by whom? Are the allegations supported by any evidence? I haven't seen any.

I haven't seen anything about someone being expelled because of the so-called mensalao. I may be wrong, but show me please.
No Mensalão
written by Guest, October 01, 2005
There was no mensalão, right? No one can show me where that was proven.

Even Jefferson's initial allegations have been amended after the fact by the press to say he alleged a mensalão AND campaign financing irregularities. But I don't see in early articles where he made those other allegations. It was always the mensalão.

Now, I'm glad Jefferson was caught being the criminal he is and that he made even false accusations, becuase it cuased people in Brazil to wake up and go after corruption. But it turns out most of the corruption is not in the PT camp.

And, Lula hasn't been implicated in ANY corruption. He's honest, though he's working in the historic pig stye of political corruption that is Brazilia.

Viva Lula!
...
written by Guest, October 06, 2005
the 12,000 per month sounds like lobbying in the usa
Cuba
written by Guest, October 30, 2005
Obvious from today`s news. It was Cuba. And likely Venezuela.

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack