Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33083349

Who's Online

We have 649 guests online



Let's Nationalize Teachers and Make a Federal Case Out of Education in Brazil PDF Print E-mail
2005 - October 2005
Written by Cristovam Buarque   
Wednesday, 26 October 2005 09:40

Brazilian teacher in the classroomThe week of October 9 to 15 should have been called the "Week of the Future." On October 12 we commemorated the Day of the Child and on October 15, the Day of the Teacher. These two days are interconnected and linked to the future, and they have in common their abandonment by the federal government. The teacher and the child are the pillars of the future. But in Brazilian public life they have never been a priority.

The Brazilian nation abandoned its children and its teachers to the care of the states and the municipalities. The destiny of the Brazilian child depends upon luck - the city in which the child happens to be born and whoever happens to be the mayor the year in which the child enters school.

The municipalities are unequal and do not have the resources necessary to guarantee good education to their children. There are cities with an annual per capita income of almost 20,000 reais (US$ 9,000), and others with one of 600 reais (US$ 265).

As long as K-12 education is a municipal responsibility, it will be impossible to guarantee the same quality of education to all Brazilian children.

Since the Day of the Child is national, why then is the education children receive municipal? Brazilian children need an education that is Brazilian, national, federal, and not only municipal. The unification of K-12 education, its nationalization, is a condition for the educational revolution that Brazil needs. And that revolution begins with the teacher.

Education depends upon the teaching profession. And the teacher is the head, the heart and the pocketbook, the Holy Trinity of education. If the teacher is not well trained and dedicated, good education is nonexistent.

Without good remuneration, there will be no dedication or training. Today, the municipality is responsible for the selection and remuneration of the teacher - the person who cares for our children and, therefore, for Brazil's future.

If we want a national education, therefore, we need to nationalize the teacher. In many countries, the primary and secondary teachers are employees remunerated by the federal government. That, however, would be too great a step for Brazil to take.

Nationalizing the teacher's salary would at least be an advance. This would mean adopting a national salary floor - not a unified salary, although this may happen in the universities and technical schools.

This is the case, for example, in the Federal District (DF). There, the teacher's salary (on average 1,475 reais (US$ 653) per month) is paid by the federal government. And the DF government complements - or at least it used to do so when I was governor - this salary with its own resources.

Meanwhile, the teacher-salary floor must be linked to unified criteria of selection. The teacher would continue to be employed by his or her municipality but would pass through a federal selection process, after which the federal government would pay the teacher's salary, and the municipalities would continue paying their part.

My proposal is that the federal government double the average salary - from 530 reais (US$ 235) to 1,000 reais (US$ 443) - of the municipal and state teachers who have passed a federal competitive exam.

Or that it begin with first through fourth grade teachers, as the Ministry of Education Certification Program anticipated in 2003. Or that it choose, at first, those who earn up to 250 reais (US$ 111). Whichever method is selected, head, heart and pocketbook, together, will change the present reality.

Today, even while viewing the future sadly, we can still commemorate these dates hopefully. The days of October 12th and 15th are still not dates equal to May 13th, the date of the Abolition of Slavery, because in spite of remaining incomplete, at least Abolition was proclaimed. But we still have not proclaimed the liberation of the children and the teachers.

Brazil still has time to save its future. The future that belongs to the children, the future constructed by the teachers. We have the resources to do it. We are conscious of the need. We must wake up.

Cristovam Buarque has a Ph.D. in economics. He is a PT senator for the Federal District and was Governor of the Federal District (1995-98) and Minister of Education (2003-04). You can visit his homepage - www.cristovam.com.br - and write to him at cristovam@senador.gov.br.

Translated from the Portuguese by Linda Jerome - LinJerome@cs.com.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (5)Add Comment
Is this guy serious?
written by Guest, October 26, 2005
I'm utterly shocked I didn't see "permanent revolution" in this article, not even once. I can simpatize with your need for intelectual masturbation, but surely a Ph.D. in economics can visualize the system and undestand the implausibility and limitations of it. Why do I always feel there's not enough qualified people to create the critical mass needed to educate Brazil? Or am I just misinformed? The only thing that could help saving world education is electronic ink, but I doubt that will ever be more than ink on celulose.
Mr Buarque........
written by Guest, October 27, 2005

...why have you not implemented what you say now...when you were Minister of Education ???????

...you are criticizing the disparity of teachers salaries. But you recognize openly....that while teachers salaries were already high in DF, and fully paid by the federal government, YOU as Governor complemented even further their already high salaries !!!!!
THIS MEANS THAT YOU INCREASED....THE DISPARITIES !!!!!!!.
THIS MEANS THAT YOU SPENT UNECESSARY STATE MONEY....TO ALREADY HIGH SALARIES... ALREADY PAID BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ¨!!!!!

IS THAT NOT THROWING MONEY ???????

ARE YOU THEN SURPRISED OF FEDERAL AND STATE DEFICITS !!!!!!!

AS GOVERNOR, THE MONEY YOU SPENT IN ADDITION TO THE FEDERAL MONEY PAID TO TEACHERS COULD HAVE GONE TO OTHER SOCIAL PROGRAMS EVEN IN YOUR STATE....WHERE POVERTY ALSO EXISTS !!!!!!!! OR...THAT MONEY COULD HAVE GONE TO ANOTHER MORE NEEDY STATE !!!!!!!
BUT YOUR PREFERRED TO INCREASE THE INEQUALITIES INSTEAD OF REDUCING THEM !!!!

Now as a simple EX EX EX you are giving lessons....of exactly the opposite of what you did !!!!!!

Mr Buarque...shame on you ! No one should be surprised of how badly your country is mismanaged !!!!!!
...
written by Guest, October 27, 2005
Please don't tell me you're an American mocking another country's stagnation when it relates to education.
....no....
written by Guest, October 27, 2005


...I am a European who find strange that in all Brazil, teachers salaries must be paid py states except in DF where salaries are paid by the federal government. What a democracy !!!!!!!!!

...I am also highly critical that DF teachers have such a high salary...compared to other states....and that on top of that the Governor complement still further with his own budget...these same high salaries !!!!
This simply demonstrates that inequalities are voluntarily made by brazilian politicians and no one else !!!!!!

They do this all the time....while in power....and later want to teach and give lessons...as how things should be done.
But they did the exact opposite....while in power !!!!!


So...again and again...shame on this Buarque who is EX senator, EX governor and EX Minister of Education.¨

He is exactly the type of guy...responsible to the roots of your problems...of the last centuries !!!!!!

Doing what he did...is a Brazilian lifestyle that clearly explain why Brazil has the worst wealth inequalities in the world.....after Sierra Leone !!!


Truly....nothing to be proud of !!!!!


Cheers
Government not going to solve the proble
written by Guest, October 28, 2005
The author is a bit naive to think nationalizing education is the answer. Having everyone receive the same nationalized education with teachers receiving a nationalized wage-level-- will only nationalize poverty. That said, it's great that municipalities are in charge of education. Now there will be some competition between them and good teachers and flock to the places they're valued most. And parents who value their kids' education can flock to the muncipalities which provide the best education. Competition between the municpalities will raise the standard of education around the country. A free-market competitive solution is best.

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack