Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33083331

Who's Online

We have 635 guests online



Why Can't Brazil Be More Like Venezuela? PDF Print E-mail
2005 - November 2005
Written by Cristovam Buarque   
Friday, 11 November 2005 13:45

Brazilian woman reading bookCaracas does not have many tourist sights, but were a visitor to write the name of one of them and show it to anyone in the street, that person would be able to read it. Venezuela is a territory free of illiteracy. This is its greatest monument to history today.

Three years ago, Venezuela had 1.5 million illiterate adults. When the government initiated the operation to eliminate illiteracy, few believed in that goal. President Chávez launched Operation Robinson I, under the coordination of Minister Aristóbulo Istúriz.

The Armed Forces launched the pilot program in two cities to demonstrate that the goal was possible. Once its success was confirmed, the operation was carried to the rest of the country by thousands of agents. Each house was visited. The slogan "Yes, I can!" mobilized all the Venezuelans.

Little by little, each city raised a flag proclaiming itself "Territory Free of Illiteracy." On October 28, the entire country declared itself "Territory Free of Illiteracy," verified by UNESCO.

I had the honor of being invited to the celebration. In a touching National Assembly solemnity, I heard a newly literate woman give an emotional speech.

In the presence of a UNESCO representative, the president of the Congress signed a Congressional Act, declaring Venezuela "Territory Free of Illiteracy."

That afternoon this Declaration was turned over to President Chávez before thousands of literacy teachers and newly literate. The people in the street proudly commemorated the event.

After this October 28, Venezuela will never be the same. It is as if a country, which one hundred years ago opened oil wells, were opening the well of a much more powerful energy - the intellectual capacity of its people.

A country is considered free of illiteracy if more than 95% of its adults are literate. In Venezuela this figure is 99%.

The program successfully graduated 1.4 million adults and young people, of all ages, the disabled, prisoners, sick people. Along with a diploma, each newly literate person receives a collection of simple reading books, literary classics, and is enrolled in Phase II of the program until completing fourth grade. The President himself cites books and recommends readings in his speeches.

Witnessing a country declare itself free of illiteracy is like being present for its Declaration of Independence. To see the enormous flag - "Territory Free of Illiteracy" - was like seeing the true flag of Venezuela only now hoisted up the flagpole.

In Brazil, that would be an even more emotional experience because only the literate can recognize our flag. Besides colors, it displays words.

Because of this, for a Brazilian, the happiness of being present for the Venezuelan success is tinged with a bit of sadness. If the Brasil Alfabetizado [Brazil Literate] Program had been maintained at its 2003 level, with a specific Office for the matter (our Operation Robinson) and guaranteed resources, Brazil would be ready to eradicate illiteracy before the end of 2006.

Inexplicably, President Lula has preferred to extinguish the Office for the Eradication of Illiteracy, to reduce Brasil Alfabetizado to a program with neither goals nor ambitions, and as of October 10, 2005, to have applied only 10.5% of the resources anticipated for this year.

In September 2003, President Lula received a UNESCO prize for Brasil Alfabetizado in the Cláudio Santoro Theater in Brasília. At that moment, I imagined him receiving the Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 for eradicating illiteracy in Brazil. During the Teresa Carreño Theater solemnity in Caracas, I perceived that President Chávez has a more likely chance of this honor.

Cristovam Buarque has a Ph.D. in economics. He is a PDT senator for the Federal District and was Governor of the Federal District (1995-98) and Minister of Education (2003-04). You can visit his homepage - www.cristovam.com.br - and write to him at cristovam@senador.gov.br.

Translated from the Portuguese by Linda Jerome - LinJerome@cs.com.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (17)Add Comment
literacy doesn\'t mean that much if.....
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
hopefullly now the venezuelan people can better understand what chavez really is, a socialist. has any socialist country ever risen up the socialist dream? no, socialism doesn't work. i have been to cuba twice and it is a sad place. while an amazing percentage of the population is literate an amazing percentage of the population is living in favela like poverty. havana, i was suprised to see, is very poor and run down. a one week visit into the country side showed even worse poverty than in the city but that's cool because castro can talk about how everyone is schooled and literate. instead of lula getting a nobel peace prize for literacy rates i think he should concentrate on getting the people in the favelas shelter and food, just my thoughts
...
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
oooh, a socialist! boogie-boogie-boogie.

Your "thoughts," poster above, are like so many turds floating by.
Cuba
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Although, socialism has had trouble growing the economy it does create an equal society. And, on top of that, Cuba is very power today partly because the state controls almost everything but you can not ignore that the largest economy and largest market in the world has a strict embargo on an poor island. So the above post can blame Fidel for all of Cuba's problems but on a serious note no country in the world can grow their economy successfully when the US places an embargo and punishes companies that do business in Cuba or invest there. I can even travel to Cuba from the USA, it violates a law and i could go to jail!
Right
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
I'm sure Fidel is living in poverty in solidarity with the common Cubans.
Buarque shows his true face
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Right Buarque, we got your point, you are a socialist admirer of Chavez (and Castro by the way) and want us living like in those Wonderlands. Of course, there was UNO, that almost gets an orgasm when they see some bureaucracy achieve a goal that restricts economic freedom in the name of so-called "social causes". I would just like to ask if all those people got really literate by even UNESCO standards. Are they really able to understand a simple text or do some maths, in those just three years? Who were the officials responsible for that data? Venezuelans? Was that data properly audited? Anyway, those are not big questions. The big question is wether that will be economically successful and will bring better life standards for the people. I guess not, just like happened in all other socialist countries..

To the poster who gave the answer "Cuba", I say that I agree. The embargo is a nonsense. What Cuba has to sell to America? Almost nothing. What can they buy? Almost nothing too, for they have no money. Should the embargo be suspended, Cuba would probably export cheap primary products to America, and Castro would likely transform his island in a huge farm. That would diverse their interest in high tech industries, for the profits would be warranted, and would ruin the country's future even more in the long run, because their economy would be more sticky to commodities (iIn addition, americans are not allowed to buy cheap primary products from the island). That would certainly make Castro have a little bit more money, but his speech would be more void to the rest of the world. Yet as a brazilian living in Brazil, I can say that would just make leftist people find another decoy for their view of world, for the United States and capitalism are rendered guilt for all of our problems while China is a land of cool guys, besides the fact that US are the biggest buyers of brazilian products while selling much less, and that China does just the opposite. Buarque thinks just the same, besides the fact that he has got a PhD from Harvard and instead of giving us what made the US a rich nation, he just throws us to a socialist utopia. Why is Harvard graduating so many leftist people?
...
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
These Marxists/ socialist idiots should be sent to live in North Korea or Cuba for a period. It will be interesting to here their views then
Mr Buarque,
written by Guest, November 12, 2005

you forget that YOU WERE a recent minister of education.

What have you done during your mandate, or better, what have YOU not done that you say now should be done ?

Based on your own words, you are accountable for the failure of education in Brazil.
Anyway litteracy without a good economical environment is worth nothing to reduce poverty.

Just look at Cuba, where they are higly literate but even poorer than Brazil.
Venezuela is the same. They just have oil that account for 80 % of their tax receipts.
Otherwise, empty ! Venezuela is not a country with sustainable growth because they have no diversified and competitive industries. Failure is around the corner.
Population Difference
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Brasil has 175,000,000 + people,
Venezuala 25,000,000 +/-
It is not a simple task because of the weight of the population, and the priorities of the culture, I am not blaming but many can play football, dance and are distracted by many other things (TV) ...but you cannot go into a mall in Brasil and find a kid working who doesn´t use a calculator for the simplest of math 10 % discount on $90. rs .. also the rich are not interested in changing things for the better of all, not socialism ..but how about a functional public school that can get any type of results ...Where? In the Northeast where I live people attend the school to eat and socialize not even understanding that that is not the purpose of the school...and the poor..they have just learned to beg... or shut up and dance and go play football!
Addendum; Population difference
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
One final point ...the prideful stupidity of following a failed system like Fidel or Russia´s ...My wife is from Russia and I have lived there
...Oh Man!! .. Lenin put those countries about sixty years behind just like Fidel´s Cuba ... and letting Chavez (his economic policys seem to be rob from the rich and bribe and flatter the poor)..set the agenda for Latin America...not such a hot idea... and when you can´t blame Bush for all the fatherless children begging in the streets ...or the Favela´s or the crap destined not to work financially unsolvent pension system or huge
national debt or the incredible accepted as a way of life corruption
or the potential riots just like in France...only here the military will be much more brutal in putting a stop to it.. nothing will change unless the people who have the power ...want it too..
What is literacy?
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
I wonder what the definition of litearcy used in Venezuela is. Are people who can only sign their names literate? Brasil had project MOBRAL in the 1970s and claimed to be eradicating illiteracy. The reality is that people were simply taught to sign their names. Once they could sign their names they were considered literate.
Viva Venezuela! Viva Comrade Chavez!
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Venezuela is a beautiful and great nation as is Cuba and soon will be Bolivia.

This is because of the socialist minded humanistic presidents in these nations like Brother and Comrade Hugo Chavez and Fidel Castro.

all you neoliberal right wing racist oligarchic gringo loving nut blancos, who are saying misleading and false statements about Comrade Chavez and Castro - here is the response from the campesions and socialist and people friendly and caring masses - "get lost and go and live in nazi germany" you evil neo-liberal, racist, gringo loving and gringo "lap dogs".

the gringo imperialists and their lackeys and lap dogs in the form of brazil's neo-liberal and blanco oligarchy have done nothing short but exploit the poor, the campesinos, the indigenous, the black, the pardo, and other peoples of color for over 513 years.

all your policy includes is simply cutting taxes for the rich even more and make the rich even more richer and the poor even poorer than they are! and then you bastards support right wing oligarchic and destructive and racist government and counterrevolutionaries in countries against left leaning, people loving, and humane comrades and heroes throughout latin america and the world, where socialists win political victories.

well f**k YOU, you imperialists and the oligarchic lackeys of the imperialist gringos.

we needs a marxist, soclialst and communist revolution in brazil and we need to take over all the fazendas and haciendas of the blanco oligarchy and elite, and then redistribute the land amongst the poor campesinos, as comrade joao stedile is doing now with MST, and comrades hugo chavez and comrade evo morales and comrade danioel ortega has done or will be doing in venezuela, bolivia, and nicaragua respectively,

viva la revolucion! viva fidel castro! viva marxism!

down with right wing racist gringo imperialism! down with the IMF and the racist and exploitary World Bank! down with evil and capitalistic big corporations, which pillage the nature, the people, and the land and the waters and the airs for their own corporate greed and interests!
Population difference ?
written by Guest, November 12, 2005

Does not make any difference. In the USA the population is around 250 millions, far greater than Brazil and they are literate.

As to the forum member who compliments Venezuela and Cuba. Simply ask the population, what they think of their government, of their human rights, social inclusion.

How can Venezuela explains so much poverty when they have so much oil ?
All others oil producing countries, producing as much oil or even less, are far more wealthier and more developed than Venezuela. Where did the money go ?

As to the marxists members, why dont you go to North Korea, or Cuba ?
Poverty is even greater in these countries than in Brazil. Press, media and freedom of thinking have the risk of being jailed when they critize the government. They are not a democracy !
socialism
written by Guest, November 12, 2005

Socialism creates effectively equality.
All citizens live under poverty. Doctors/lawyers having studied for yyears and years earn the same wages as the illiterate farmer. They have no incentive to perform and be competitive, government handles everything but badly.

No government in the world, from left to right countries, are effective in management. This is the reason that developed nations privatize large companies such as electricity, phone companies and many others.

A good government is not supposed to create wealth. They must create a favorable environment for the entrepreneurs. Those who succeed must pay back something to the government, through taxes.
That is how wealth and democracies advance for the better of their citizens.
Re: Viva Venezuela! Viva Comrade Chavez!
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Brazil don't even have capitalism, how could we have neoliberalism? Why do you leftist consider anything that is against your view as "the right", even so different views like nazism and neoliberalism? Someone should teach those people that nazifascism was a state-planned model, with a surrender of the individual to the will of the group, and of course, the führer, just the opposite to what neoliberalists defend.

In addition, the IMF, the UNO, and all sort of those supernational organizations are not really capitalistic organizations, nor neoliberals. Organizations like the IMF borrow money to governments and hence are supporting the leftist corrupt governments that we have in Latin America. At least in one point we agree. Latin american countries should stop immediately to pay their external debts and promote reforms to create a minimal state, that takes care just of security and is forbidden to borrow money to achieve is ends.
Buarque saying crap, as always
written by Guest, November 12, 2005
Buarque is one those persons that make me hate being brazilian, like him. Even if he lives in Venezuela, he will never know that the people who have signed asking for the recall referendum are loosing their jobs in government, or have to wait up to one year to get a passport, not after go though an "interview" with the police to explain why they want leave the country. In Venezuela you can sell dollars but cannot buy. Things are weird here, I cannot wait the day to go home.
Population Difference and other things
written by Guest, November 13, 2005
Let me clarify..comparing the supposed success of Venezuala´s anti-illiteracy program to one in Brasil..I am comparing Venezuala´s problem and the fixing of it (if it was success which remains questionable) to the possiblity of fixing it here in Brasil ...the USA has not had an illiterate majority for at least 50 years probably longer...So to address literacy here in Brasil is a much bigger problem to handle from a popualtion as well as geographic size point of view than say Venezuala.

Now to the admirer of communist systems and revolutions...you, I will bet, have no personal experience at all with what occurs during revolutions... and or the drastic unpredicable and most times violent economic and or social affects. For Brasil to emulate Argentina or Comrade Chavez would be social hell for at least five years... and would again affect the poor the most and maybe take years and years to recover from just like the former countries of the Soviet Union

And from where you sit protected by your computer and internet wall of privacy, and I am sure from your perspective you believe was invented, created and produced by the sweat of some noble brother farmers somewhere and peasants from someplace else are free to spew hatred and whats worse ideas that have already proven to be disasterous for the very people you profess to care about...

Also I have driven by car and lived all over Brasil from Florianopolis to Fortaleza ... I can´t help but notice somehow someway thousands upon thousands luxury High rise apartments have been built in the last five years with a 20 % interest rate, a 18 % inflation rate...but not one public school that works (at least that I have seen if works means that the majority of students can do basic math reading and writing)

And who lives in all these wonderfully modern funtioning apartments
...imperialistic pirate scum foreigners? No, Brazilians... Take a ride my friend get some fresh ideas...the root cause of this (in general) is the rich don´t care about the poor and the poor want to eat the rich ...and the goverment has been corrupted to the maximum degree...by people who don´t know how to actually do anything...how to lead honestly...or accomplish anything other than writing down a strategy or a theory untested from their ivory towers...Find out how Fidel lives and Chavez...you will be dissappointed they live like kings ...and Lenin he did not create the internet the car the airplane modern agriculture or anything in fact useful ..he created havoc and a system that put Russia in worse shape than Brasil because at least here the poor are not cold too...And under Stalin 20 million peoiple were killed in less than 5 years...that would be almost all of Sao Paolo...

What would be useful is to create a bridge betwee the poor and the people here in Brasil that have ability...who can actually do something..other than the politicos and some other imagined save me type organization... but until Carnival has less importance and it isn´t important how many goals Ronaldo has scored this week...

probably nothing can change..but it starts with the people... the poor and uneducated, the rich and the people who know how to do things...

Final thought Brasil is paying its national debt for huge public works projects started in the sixties and mostly a pension plan that cannot continue..ect ect ect...

but better to blame those Gringoes..
Capitalism rules in Venezula, Brazil, USA as well as the corporoativist Statecapitalist Cuba
written by Anti-stalinist marxist, November 22, 2006
Socialism is not the same as state ownership, otherwise would the state of USA be a socialist one. The populist politicians in Latin America, some closesly allied to the Cuban party dictatorship, has nothing to do with a political and economic revolutionary democracy based upon council powers. Chavez socialsit? Nor more than than the statefascist Fidel Castro.

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack