Brazzil

Since 1989 trying to understand Brazil

Home

Search

Custom Search
Members : 6852
Content : 3575
Content View Hits : 24899355

Who's Online

We have 822 guests online

Login Form






Dumont's and Wright Brothers' Planes to Fly Side by Side in the US PDF Print E-mail
2006 - September 2006
Written by Débora Rubin   
Thursday, 21 September 2006 05:26

Brazilina Santos Dumont flies his La Demoiselle in Paris in 1907This year is the centenary of aviation. But, after all, who invented the aircraft? To the Brazilians it was Santos Dumont. To the Americans, it was the Wright brothers. The dispute, that has been going on for 100 years - and which will never lead anywhere - is going to start changing on Saturday, 30, when Brazilians and Americans will join forces in Dayton, Ohio (USA), at the Flight Fest.

At the occasion, a replica of Santos Dumont's Demoiselle - the second aircraft built by the Brazilian, not as famous as the 14 Bis, his first - will fly beside a replica of the Flyer, the aircraft developed by Orville and Wilbur Wright.

The novel event was only made possible due to the Wright Brothers Foundation, presided by Amanda Wright, great grandniece of the brothers, and of Arruda Botelho Institute (IAB) - which is responsible for the replica of the Demoiselle.

"In the United States, Santos Dumont is not very well known. He does not appear in their history books, in their museum. We are not going to fight about who was the number one, we just want to show the Americans the grandness of the Brazilian," explained Fernando Arruda Botelho, a businessman, president of the IAB and a great Santos Dumont enthusiast.

As the Americans are very good in marketing, the Wright brothers figure as the pioneers in flight in the United States, as is the case with other countries that speak the English language. Nobody saw the flight of the Flyer, in 1903, and the flight in 1905 was not ratified.

The famous experience by Santos Dumont, in turn, in his 14 Bis, in 1906, in Paris, was ratified and registered. Still, in American schools, students learn that the Wright brothers were the first to fly. There, many children have never even heard the name Santos Dumont.

The objective of Fernando Arruda Botelho is to try to follow the same track - although one hundred years late. To make the name of the Brazilian aviator heard abroad, the IAB has built three replicas of the Demoiselle.

Two already have specific destinations. One will be used at the event on September 30. The other will be exhibited at the Smithsonian National Air Space Museum - during an aviation event to take place in Washington, the US capital, between October 16 and 23.

According to professor Fernando Catalano, an aeronautical engineer at the University of São Paulo (USP) who assisted Botelho in the reconstruction of the Demoiselle, there is an intention of making use of the replicas to promote Santos Dumont's projects in Brazilian schools.

"Another idea is to take the replica on a lorry and stop in various cities to make demonstrations," he said. "If the Americans don't know about Santos Dumont, it is because we did not know how to promote him," he explains.

Gadget

To recreate the Demoiselle (which means both "lady" and "dragonfly"), Botelho and his team took little over a year to make the gadget fly. It all began in 2004. The aircraft was built using the same measurements as the original, based on material published in magazine Mecânica Popular, in 1910.

"We made some material adaptations, also due to the different weight of the pilot. Dumont was short and light, and his aircraft was made specifically for him," recalled Catalano.

The first attempt was almost successful. In October 2005, one year later, a second attempt got the Demoiselle off the ground. This time, Botelho improved the replica. Each one of the problems of the first was studied carefully and the parts were made by students at the National Service of Industrial Education (Senai), who spent four days drawing the aircraft.

Botelho, who is going to fly the replica on the 30th, at the event in Ohio, decided to remake the Demoiselle and not the 14 Bis because another Brazilian, pilot Alan Calassa, from Caldas Novas (in the midwestern Brazilian state of Goiás), had already made a replica of the more famous model.

"It made no sense to repeat something that has already been done, but it did make sense to join forces to help rescue this name that had been forgotten in history," says the idealizer of the project.

The president at the IAB is programming other flights with his replica. Next year, to commemorate the centenarian flight of the Demoiselle, he is going to cross the English Channel, the 36 kilometers that separate England from France.

Anba - www.anba.com.br



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (9)Add Comment
Delighted to see Santos Dumont recognised
written by C G Rodliffe NEW zealand, September 25, 2006
.Far away in the Antipodes Ric almost unheard of.hard Pearse amazing exploits flying
...
written by djfdjfdjf, September 25, 2006
Is it necessary for us to view achievements in sports, technology and the arts in nationalistic terms? As an American who loves Brazil, I am concerned that Lula and other misinformed Brazilians embarrass the country when discussing the contribution of Santos Dumont to air travel. I found this response to a radio caller from a representative of the Air and Space Museum clarifying:

Caller: I am from Brazil and my wife is a buckeye from just outside of Dayton (Ohio) so we must settle my question (laughter). The French-Brazilian, Santos Dumont. The French and the Brazilians and several other countries claim that he has the title of “the father of aviation”. My question is . . what is the claim that the French have and why do they claim that and the Brazilians and what is the claim that you guys have that the Wright brothers would be the first ones to fly. I would just try to understand why since as a child we learn that in Brazil and in France that Santos Dumont is the father of aviation. Thank-you.

Air and Space Museum Representative: Santos Dumont was a very important figure in aviation in both heavier than air aviation and in lighter than air aviation. He was Brazilian and he went to France as a young man and was very interested in aeronautics. He made some very famous flights with air ships. He made the first flight around the Eiffel tower in 1901 where he won a very large financial prize so he was a well known aviation figure when the Wright Brothers were experimenting. He went on to heavier than air airplanes and made the first publicly demonstrated flight in Europe. . . . Well, it was the first publicly demonstrated flight in the world took place in Europe in 1906. It was a flight of a little over 700 feet just a straight line top. The reason at the time he was considered the first was that the Wright Brothers did not publicly fly until 1908. They refined their 1903 airplane, 1904, 1905 with two more airplanes which I mentioned a moment ago but in 1905 when they had perfected their design they stopped flying entirely. They set about to secure their patent which was finally granted in 1906 and looking for customers to sell their airplane to. And in this interim period other experimenters in Europe and elsewhere were experimenting and starting to make flights. In 1908, January of 1908, the first one kilometer circular flight was made in France by a pilot named Henri Farn . . . won a 50,000 franc prize. So these flights were gaining a lot of popularity but the Wrights were not flying publicly yet but when they first do in August of 1908, they clearly demonstrate that they were ahead of everyone else. They were flying for an hour at a time making circles and just instantly their claims to having invented the airplane were confirmed. They became instantly world famous with these flights. So what you have today in this debate about Santos Dumont and the Wright Brothers really stems from this earlier period where it appears that Santos Dumont had flown first. Their were rumors about what the Wright Brothers had done and witnesses saying they saw things but they never made any public flights. Once they had done so it was clear what they had done. Santos Dumont’s contribution was certainly important and should not be denied.
...
written by a guest, September 27, 2006
I never found a reason why people claim patriotic achievements. I mean who wants to be part of an amorphous mass?
...
written by alalaomaisquecaloroooor, September 29, 2006
smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif
...
written by C G Rodliffe AMRAeS, October 01, 2006
Very pleased to note recognition of Santos Dumont is taking place. The unknown New Zealander wrote aviation success could not be atributed to any one person.
...
written by C G Rodliffe AMRAeS, October 01, 2006
Congratulations
The "14-Bis versus Wright Flyer" debate is a little more complicated...
written by Bernardo, October 23, 2006
The controversy over whether the Wright Flyer or the 14-Bis deserves to be called "the first practical airplane" is fairly complicated, involving both technical issues (could the Flyer take off unassisted? It did so in 190smilies/cool.gif and historical issues (how certain can we be of the Wrights' 1903 flight? It doesn't matter, since we can be certain of a 1905 flight that still preceded anyone else's). But most of all, it's a matter of how you define "practical" (the 14-Bis needed a large flat space in order to take off, the Flyer needed a launch rail - Which is more, or less, practical?). For an overview of all these issues, I recommend you check out
http://www.airshowfan.com/first-airplane.htm
Smiley...
written by Bernardo, October 23, 2006
And by
"...190smilies/cool.gif..."
I meant
"...1908 )..."
first flight
written by mikem, November 12, 2006

They both worked hard...but it wasn't their idea . Men has been tring to fly before Leonardo da vinci or Icaro...Americans say wright bros Brazilians say Santos Dumont. By efinition of flight of today it would be dumont but...ideas have to be perfected to get the finish product. Wright bros worked a lot for that. Both deserve our respect

Mike smilies/smiley.gif

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack