Brazzil

Since 1989 Trying to Understand Brazil

Home

----------

Brazilian Eyelash Enhancer & Conditioner Makeup

----------

Get Me Earrings

----------

Buy Me Handbags

----------

Find Me Diamond

----------

Wholesale Clothing On Sammydress.com

----------

Brautkleider 2013

----------

Online shopping at Tmart.com and Free Shipping

----------

Wholesale Brazilian Hair Extensions on DHgate.com

----------

Global Online shopping with free shipping at Handgiftbox

----------

Search

Custom Search
Members : 22767
Content : 3832
Content View Hits : 33088166

Who's Online

We have 688 guests online



Brazil's Military Dictatorship: 21 Years of Interrupted Democracy PDF Print E-mail
2011 - April 2011
Written by Marcos Chagas   
Monday, 18 April 2011 13:25

General Castelo BrancoThe period of the military dictatorship in Brazil often referred to as "Brazil's years of lead," which lasted from 1964 to 1985, was a somber time when Brazilian politicians lost their mandates for political reasons (the generals decreed forfeiture of office), the media was censured and public demonstrations of opposition were repressed violently.

There was also an ugly underground where opponents of the military were tortured and killed.

Professor Octaviano Nogueira, who teaches history and political science at the University of Brasília, says the roughest period of military intervention was between 1964 and the beginning of the 1970s. "The repression was harsh at that time," he says.

Nogueira points out that the problems that led to the 1964 coup actually began in 1961 when a right-wing president, Jânio Quadros, suddenly resigned after only six months in office and was succeeded by a left-wing vice president, João Goulart, who was distrusted by the military.

The distrust was so deep that he only took office after an institutional crisis was averted by a populist movement led by his firebrand brother-in-law, Leonel Brizola, the governor of the state of Rio Grande do Sul.

"The truth is that Goulart was a stopgap president. Besides, in reality, he was a big landowner and a conservative politician who found himself in a political party (PTB) with a leftist inheritance from Getúlio Vargas.

"The contradiction made him an ineffectual president, under pressure from all sides and unable to implement policy," explains professor Nogueira.

The Goulart administration faced constant worker strikes, fierce opposition in the press and had little support in most of the population.

The Army marched on Rio de Janeiro on March 31, 1964. Goulart and Brizola fled the country and the military ruled for the next 21 years.

Under the second military "president," marshal Artur da Costa e Silva, the regime undertook a radical crackdown on any opposition. So-called "institutional acts," were issued.

The most infamous was Ato Institutional #5 - AI-5, which gave the executive (the general-president) the power to close Congress, decree forfeiture of office for politicians and legalized the harsh repression of any social movements or public demonstrations contrary to the dictatorship.

By the late 1970s, the fourth general-president, Ernest Geisel, began what came to be known as the "slow and gradual political opening" process.

On October 13, 1978, Congress approved a constitutional amendment (#11), which revoked all the institutional acts and reinstated parliamentary immunity. Members of congress were once again protected from having forfeiture of office decreed arbitrarily by the general-president.

In 1979, the last of the general-presidents, João Figueiredo, sanctioned the Amnesty Law that restored the political rights of those who opposed the military, but also exempted military agents who arrested, killed and/or tortured during the dictatorship from prosecution.

Right-wing hardliners in the military were not happy with the Figueiredo administration "opening," or the Amnesty Law. There were bomb attacks on newsstands and the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB). There was also an attempt to explode a bomb at a show in Rio de Janeiro commemorating Labor Day in 1981.

By 1984, even the military was weary of military rule. Massive demonstrations were taking place all over the country in favor of direct elections for president. But Congress refused to bow to the popular will and instead obeyed the military and voted for an indirect election.

Tancredo Neves was elected in an indirect election in 1985, but died of natural causes before taking office. His vice president, José Sarney, served for five years and was succeeded, in 1989, by the first really popularly elected president since 1964, Fernando Collar.

Ironically, Collor was impeached for corruption. He was succeeded by his vice president, Itamar Franco. In 1994, Fernando Henrique was elected and then reelected. In 2002, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva began his two-term presidency.

Professor Nogueira says that with the election of a person like Lula - a worker from a low-income family with little formal education - democracy has really been consolidated in Brazil.

ABr


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
Comments (39)Add Comment
Was Democracy Just a Moment?
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 18, 2011

Ricardo: I know that Americans like to make the connection between democracy, a free market economy, and capitalism – and if you adopt this formula the result is economic growth and prosperity.

But I have a problem with these simplistic generalizations, since there are too many variables affecting the economy of most countries. And when people inject religion to the mix, then the problem becomes almost impossible for people to even discuss it in an intelligent manner.

But regarding the subject of democracy - Robert Kaplan wrote an interesting article for “The Atlantic Monthly” published in December 1997 that is very relevant today mainly when there is someone who has the crazy idea that he has to spread "Democracy" all over the world.

I did read this article a number of times over the years, and I recommend that other people also read it. I hope you will get as much from this article as I did.

Was Democracy Just a Moment?
http://www.theatlantic.com/mag...ment/6022/

The global triumph of democracy was to be the glorious climax of the American Century. But democracy may not be the system that will best serve the world or even the one that will prevail in places that now consider themselves bastions of freedom.
By: Robert D. Kaplan

.


Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 18, 2011

But I have a problem with these simplistic generalizations, since there are too many variables affecting the economy of most countries. And when people inject religion to the mix, then the problem becomes almost impossible for people to even discuss it in an intelligent manner.


Great comment, Ricardo! I wouldn't say the same about the article!!!!!!

The global triumph of democracy was to be the glorious climax of the American Century. But democracy may not be the system that will best serve the world or even the one that will prevail in places that now consider themselves bastions of freedom.


I still remember a quote from a Chinese blogger under one of your articles:

He said:

The democracy and human rights were invented by the "haves" to leave behind the "have nots"

The article and the "conclusion" of "Professor. Nogueira" are both questionable, to say the least.smilies/wink.gif
Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 19, 2011

Joao, I also don't agree with the conclusions of Professor Nogueira.

Not only the the dictatorship years planted the seeds for a future prosperous Brazil, but we also need to give credit for what has been happening in China which indirectly helped lift the boats in Brazil during the years that president Lula was president of Brazil.

By the way, China is not a democracy.

.
Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 19, 2011

Joao, I also don't agree with the conclusions of Professor Nogueira.


As you rightly said it was "simplistic generalization"!

BTW,I finished reading the 3 page long article of Robert Kaplan in the link you posted. A must read article. He wrote it in December 1997 and even mentioned about the Brasilian democracy and how it was faring 12 years after the military left. I wonder if we have "consolidated" and "bettered" it during the 14 years since he published the article. According to Prof.Nogueira, yes, by electing "a worker from a low-income family with little formal education"!!
...
written by João da Silva, April 20, 2011

Qué merda. The comments of "U.S.Male", me & Ricardo about Democracy & Republic disappeared.
An Important Distinction: Democracy versus Republic
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 20, 2011

Ricardo: Joao here is that posting again:

An Important Distinction: Democracy versus Republic
http://www.lexrex.com/enlighte...emrep.html

.
Salvaged messages
written by BrazzilMag, April 21, 2011
The messages below were retrieved from our latest server after our latest move. Sorry for other messages that might have been lost.

...
written by João da Silva, April 19, 2011

Simpleton/Ricardo

Talking about being negative...

Has it occurred to you both the Sen.Buarque is as sarcastic as we are all? He is "chopping and chopping and no chips are flying".

Many of my friends that have known him personally in DF say he is honest in his crusade to strengthen the basic education. He got himself reelected easily last year as a Senator based on his willingness to address key issues and not by just patting his own back for his past performance.

+0


Applaud
written by Simpleton, April 19, 2011
And so why aren't your friends that have known him personally helping our esteemed Cristovam in ensuring those in the DF get at least a basic education Joao? That would no doubt help more than any other crusade, a top down solution if you will.

+0


Simpleton
written by João da Silva, April 19, 2011

And so why aren't your friends that have known him personally helping our esteemed Cristovam in ensuring those in the DF get at least a basic education Joao?

Because they are no longer in the field of education.

+0


Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 19, 2011

Ricardo: You guys are going to enjoy the following lecture:


Thanks. I did enjoy the lectures.

+1


Lame but not Dead!
written by Simpleton, April 20, 2011
If your friends are no longer in the field of education which field did they get buried in and did that help restore the natural resources they consumed in their lifetime?

After watching the lecture (starting at the middle of the series as it is already 1 minute before 12, plus or minus two decades), I think I've concluded that ch.c is wrong. To be the most forward looking and proactive in forestalling the end, Brasil needs to cancel all the mechanical harvestor orders and put it's present and growing manpower reserves back into the cane. Entropy must change.
Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 22, 2011

Ricardo: Joao here is that posting again:


For some unknown reasons, I bookmarked the link before the site was hacked and pulverized.smilies/cheesy.gif In spite of being busy, I have read it. My comments later.
Thank you !
written by Krista Giang, April 23, 2011
Getting VISA to Vietnam is the first task to be completed when you prepare to visit or spend your trip in Vietnam. It is said by some travelers that it is a bit complicated and take them a lot of time to get a Vietnam entry VISA. In fact, Vietnam is now open and warmly welcoming you to Vietnam. You can get a visa to Vietnam by applying at Vietnam Embassy or Vietnam Consulate in your country or ordering a visa service at a Travel Agent.
Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 25, 2011

Ricardo: Joao, you will enjoy watching this video:

Republic vs Democracy
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFXuGIpsdE0

.


Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 25, 2011

Ricardo: Joao, In the case of Brazil, Jose Bonifacio de Andrada e Silva was in favor of a Republic type of government, and he was against Democracy.

I need to find the quote where he mentioned this subject.

I read about this subject more than twelve years ago when I was doing research for my book about Jose Bonifacio de Andrada e Silva and Brazilian independence.

If I remember it correctly his argument against Democracy: he believed that it was a major mistake to give the power of the vote to illiterate and to ignorant people – which made up a very large part of the population in Brazil in the early 1800's.

.
Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 25, 2011

Ricardo: By the way, Brazilian law is based on “Roman Law” and the “Napoleonic Code.”

.
Truth
written by Iracema, April 25, 2011
Latin America history is pretty complex and absolutely different of U.S.A., Canada or India history. Is hard to the world understand this complexity and the details called religion, races and local culture. Sorry, but this site don´t accept critics about it and have an U.S.A. view, that´s totally wrong.
Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 25, 2011

Joao, In the case of Brazil, Jose Bonifacio de Andrada e Silva was in favor of a Republic type of government, and he was against Democracy.


Hi Ricardo,

The whole discussion started with the question posted (and subsequently vanished) by "U.S. Male":

Is Brasil a Democracy or Republic?

The previous link you posted and especially the latest youtube video were quite interesting. IMHO, the original intention of the founding fathers of both the U.S. and Brasil were to found republics similar to that of Rome. You are right about Jose Bonifacio, he was in favor of a Republic and against democracy which is the rule of the majority. The video you posted makes a very clear distinction between a Republic and Democracy by giving some interesting examples.

Based on my limited knowledge of history, I would say Brasil has been a democracy every now and then but not a real "REPÚBLICA FEDERATIVA " as the official name implies.

If I remember it correctly his argument against Democracy: he believed that it was a major mistake to give the power of the vote to illiterate and to ignorant people – which made up a very large part of the population in Brazil in the early 1800's.


José Bonifácio had more than arguments than just the question of illiteracy against "Democracy", if my memory serves me right.However, he was in favor of a "Republic" and shared the "vision" of the founding fathers of the good ole U.S. of A. I don't remember his quote and when I find time, I ´ll research about it.

BTW, the video you posted says that a large majority of the Americans don't know that the U.S. is supposed to be a Republic. That applies to the the Brasilians too. smilies/sad.gif
Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 26, 2011

An interesting article in the link below:

http://www.estadao.com.br/esta...0692,0.php

Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 26, 2011

Ricardo: Joao, when I wrote the article about the military taking power in Brazil - exactly one year ago - if you remember my article that had nothing to do with politics right or left, economic system, or any hidden agenda - it had all to do with getting rid off the drug traffickers, and the criminal gangs.

.
Reply to Joao da Silva
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 26, 2011

Ricardo: Joao, you will enjoy what Pepe Escobar have to say:

Today the New American Dream is made in Brazil...

Is Brazil the New United States? By Pepe Escobar – The Huffington Post
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/...43343.html


***


Libya Proxy Cold War between China & West? - April 20, 2011
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Gf3VYR2YO4

.
IMF: Age of America nears end
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 26, 2011

Brett Arends' ROI
Market Watch - April 25, 2011, 7:20 p.m. EDT

IMF bombshell: Age of America nears end

Commentary: China’s economy will surpass the U.S. in 2016
http://www.marketwatch.com/sto...2011-04-25

.
One giant step closer to 3rd world chaos
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 26, 2011


One giant step closer to 3rd world chaos – April 25, 2011
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...ideo_title

.
Libya Proxy Cold War
written by Ederson, April 27, 2011
Excellent video, Ricky. If anyone has lacked the opportunity to read many of the previous comments concerning Africa and the Middle East on Brazzil.com, they will certainly learn a great deal if they watch your link. The interview was very worthy. Watch it twice or three times if you have the time. However, regular readers of Brazzil.com already know what the interview reveals.smilies/wink.gif
Ederson
written by João da Silva, April 27, 2011

However, regular readers of Brazzil.com already know what the interview reveals.


Thanks to you.smilies/cheesy.gif

Its interesting that in Pepe Escobar "mentions" about the Saudis.

Bit busy. Will be back later on to hear more of your words of wisdom.smilies/cheesy.gif
chaotic opinions
written by asp, April 27, 2011
i see more chaotic opinions than anything.

africa gets called a "country" in one exchange

no, i dont think this is about "the west versus china". quite a few of the troubled situations in africa are based on islamic fundamentalism rubbing against non islamic peoples there.

the things in north africa came out of nowhere and have nothing to do with china or islamic fundamentalism. the west didnt know it was coming and they are trying to figure it out as we speak.

the usa isnt leading the charge in libya. and, the real reason the west is going after kadafi is because of his past involvement in terrorist activities. the west will never forget about the locherbee air crash.lots of people all over the world dont like kadafi , including the arab world

the huffington post article (my god, lolyd cata is in the commentaries, so polite and un revolutionary sounding, unlike his posts here) has some good points about brazil and i sure hope brazil will be in good shape in the next few years. unlike amoral, i dont base it on brazil being succesful means the usa has to go down.

i dont even care if the usa goes to number two against china. the problem with china is the lack of freedom for the people who live there. i dont care if someone paid for my air fare, apartment and food to live in china, i just wouldnt do it. they got their finger up the peoples asses. that counts more for me than economic number one or two.

im really happy to live in a free country that doesnt tell women what to wear on the beach, who let you say what you want on the internet, that lets me take my business somewhere else if a business person treats me badly, or to be free to go to the doctor of my choice.

what worries me about brazil right now is what is happening on the groud. inflation is constant. i thought if the money was firmer than the dollar thetr wouldnt be inflation. the dollar is weak but they dont have that kind of inflation in the usa yet. but they are trying to fool you here and say prices are going up everywhere in the world to justify the strange way prices just keep going up. i think some business people are price gouging out of preportion and have no concience about it.

violence is also a huge factor that has just grown and grown in the last 9 years or so. but, im rooting for brazil to realise all the potential that it can. its a great country
asp
written by João da Silva, April 27, 2011

the huffington post article (my god, lolyd cata is in the commentaries, so polite and un revolutionary sounding, unlike his posts here)


Unfortunately, the articles was closed for further comments. Otherwise, I would challenged Dr.L.C. for a verbal duel.smilies/cool.gif

what worries me about brazil right now is what is happening on the groud. inflation is constant. i thought if the money was firmer than the dollar thetr wouldnt be inflation. the dollar is weak but they dont have that kind of inflation in the usa yet. but they are trying to fool you here and say prices are going up everywhere in the world to justify the strange way prices just keep going up. i think some business people are price gouging out of preportion and have no concience about it.


Ha,ha. You finally noticed that the inflation is on the rise, eh ? I always said people would notice it only after the Carnival and Easter.smilies/cheesy.gif

The party is over.smilies/cry.gif
if you live here , you have to notice inflation
written by asp, April 27, 2011
joao

i think anyone living in brazil would have noticed the inflation in the last 8 months or more. how could they not notice it ?

and, in talking to regular everyday people i come into contact with, they are saying that too many people are buying on credit.

its the same mistake many made in the states. at some point it may come to a head, and, either brazil will skirt its way around it or it will burst a buble some where.

brazil and brazilians have demonstrated wonderful tendancies on how to improvise and wiggle around obstacles that would ensare another country.maybe they will do it this time
asp
written by João da Silva, April 27, 2011

its the same mistake many made in the states. at some point it may come to a head, and, either brazil will skirt its way around it or it will burst a buble some where.


I am afraid Brasil is not going to skirt its way around, asp. You ´ve been saying that the Yanks are paying the price for the recklessness of the "previous administrations" prior to that of PBO. Unfortunately we are doing the same and it is no fault of Madame.Rousseff.

brazil and brazilians have demonstrated wonderful tendancies on how to improvise and wiggle around obstacles that would ensare another country.maybe they will do it this time


I don't think we are going to "relaxar e gozar" this time if "Plano Collor" is reenacted again. smilies/angry.gif
danger ahead!
written by demonio do espaço, April 28, 2011
lula was just a puppet for external interest and foreign capital, everyone who ain´t from the workers party(PT) know that. what dilma(?) will be time will answer. but democracy will only be realy consolidated in brasil with the political reforms with (MAY) take out the COLONELS(not a military rank) from the politcs for once...
...
written by João da Silva, April 28, 2011

but democracy will only be realy consolidated in brasil with the political reforms with (MAY) take out the COLONELS(not a military rank) from the politcs for once...


Good point. But...but...but..., it was easier to "take out" the Military COLONELS than to get rid of the real "Coronéis". smilies/sad.gif

Political Reforms and Tax reforms? Para inglês ver.smilies/grin.gif

Yeah, you are right. Many dangers ahead and it is yet to be seen if Dilma will be able to cope. But I am willing to give her more grace period before starting to judge. One thing I like about her is her low key profile-so far at least.
The implosion of the US economy...
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 29, 2011

Ricardo: I have been documenting it for many years:

Keiser Report: Blind Cult of America – April 28, 2011
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...ure=relmfu

US vs. China: Winner Takes It All? - April 28, 2011
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...ure=relmfu

.
blah blah blah, amoral...chinas has its own problems to watch out for
written by asp, April 29, 2011
people better look out for their own ass
written by asp, April 29, 2011
it really isnt about who is going to be the big number one anymore, its about people better look out for their own asses just to make sure they dont get bowled over in the next bubble burst

amoral, you are getting really boring
asp
written by João da Silva, April 29, 2011

people better look out for their own ass


Short but sweet advice,ASP.smilies/cheesy.gif

I read the article in the link you posted about the food prices rising fast in the PRC. As we have discussed before, the scenario is no different here.

What´s the point in exporting food to build up the country´s foreign exchange reserve when its own citizens can not afford to buy it?
Brazil at war 1943
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 30, 2011
Creedence Clearwater
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 30, 2011

Creedence Clearwater - Born On The Bayou
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...re=related


Creedence Clearwater - Keep On Chooglin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...re=related


Creedence Clearwater - Fortunate Son
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBfjU3_XOaA


*****


April 29, 2011
Show de John Fogerty muda de dia em SP; data em Curitiba é cancelada
Folha de SÃO PAULO

O show que o cantor John Fogerty, do Creedence Clearwater Revival, faria em São Paulo no dia 11 de maio, mudou de data.

Agora, ele se apresenta na cidade nos dias 8 e 10 de maio. Os ingressos para o show que teve alteração de data continuam valendo.

http://www1.folha.uol.com.br/i...lada.shtml

.


i hate rock and roll
written by asp, April 30, 2011
i hate rock and roll

im going to rio to catch paulo russo, the phenominal acoustic bass player, play at triboz in the lapa , on may 14th
Ricardo does it again!
written by Ederson, April 30, 2011
Thanks Ricky! Great video. I enjoy collecting info on Brasilian history and its military. I've been fortunate in saving a number of great books from out-of-the-way shops and the like, but for the life of me, I never once thought of accessing YOUTUBE's archives for such historical films. I guess I've been too busy. Thanks again, Ricardo!

By the way, lately I've been reading about the Yankee Civil War. Incredible. Who would ever have believed it possible that such uncommon courage could have been so easily found in such abundance in so many common men. I don't think I'll ever think of the Yanks the same ever again. The new Yanks would do well to study their own history.
Reply to Ederson
written by Ricardo C. Amaral, April 30, 2011

Ederson, you are welcome.

By the way, I was searching for "American propaganda" on YouTube, when this video about "Brazil war 1943" came up.

I wasn't not searching for Brazil military.

I am a very good researcher, since I have been doing research on the net for about 20 years - I have been using the internet even before they invented the www.

.
.
Ricardo Amaral
written by João da Silva, April 30, 2011

By the way, I was searching for "American propaganda" on YouTube, when this video about "Brazil war 1943" came up.


Ricardo, this video is very interesting and the comments made both in Portuguese and English are equally so.smilies/cheesy.gif
Ederson
written by João da Silva, May 01, 2011

Hi Eddie,

What´s going on in Libya, mate? IYHO, what´s going to be the end scenario?

If you get to read my comment and are not too busy, would appreciate your analysis.smilies/wink.gifsmilies/cool.gifsmilies/smiley.gif

BTW, PBO doesn't seem to be as blood thirsty as his European counterparts, especially Sarko. Therefore, he goes up one more notch in my esteem. ASP & Dr.L.C would surely agree with me.smilies/cool.gif
Interrupted democracy
written by Augustus, May 21, 2011
RATHER I WOULD CALL IT 21 YEARS OF IDEOLOGICAL CLEAN-UP
The only problem being that, unlike Chile, the mild Brazilian Military regime FAILED to EXTERMINATE the entirety of the Communist vermin, the bulk of which came back to the country and now, trying to look like "moderate socialists", are gradually taking over from within and STEALING resources for personal gain (referring the 95% of the corrupt PT)

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Joomla 1.5 Templates by Joomlashack