Comments for Since When Is Bonapartism Closer to Brazil's Culture than Obama's World View? at http://www.brazzil.com , comment 1 to 48 out of 20 comments http://www.brazzil.com Sun, 21 Mar 2010 07:41:42 +0100 FeedCreator 1.7.3 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-44302 Mr Da Silva... I'm not Christian but i can try to answer to your questions 1) Did you know that our FAB classified their preferences as follows?: That what folha said, but FAB denied. BTW FAB pilots told their preference for Rafale. Even british and american specialists don't understand why FAB prefers Gripen while Rafale is obviously one of the best aircraft in activity. But i agree, it's a very expensive product For exemple listen to this podcast : http://g2globalsolutions.com/review/?p=3248 I don't think FAB really think about Gripen but just want to put pressure on Dassault. 2) Did you know that the French are yet to explain the reason for the Air France 447 disintegrating over the Atlantic and they are yet to find the Black Boxes (in spite of their "moderate,but not overbearing technology")? [i][/i][i][/i] Of course we know, many french died!!! What do you think? Airbus are european maid aircrafts why only the french should be responsible? Please check how many Boeings crashed in the past... What's the link with strategical partnership? 3) Why would Brasil require French Technology to build our airplanes and Armament Industries, when we have very competent engineers? Even if they are not, they could hire engineers from all over the world. [i][/i] Such technologies needs 40 years of R&D with very very competent engineers, that's why you need help despite the very hight quality of brazilian engineers. Why French?... Why not...? Only 3 countries can offer theses technologies : USA, Russia and France 4) Do you really think that we can trust the French? [i][/i] As a french, i would say... yes! ;-) Can you trust the US, the Russian... the Brazilians?? - Kelesis Thu, 11 Feb 2010 06:11:30 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-44301 Why being universalist and multipolar should be link to the question of Turkey and European Union?? Turkey in EU was an american desire, many Turkish people do not agree and 90 per cent of european people are against! It will never happens and the european countries (even the UK) are tired of american pressure on that question. The fact is that US makes all it's possible to face a weak Europe simply because a strong and united UE should be far more rich and powerfull than the US. Regarding your statement about stragical partnership : the "old french Bonapartism" died with WW2 and the end of europeans colonial empires (mainly france and UK). You should better talk about "Gaulism". The main idea is to be indepedent from very powerfull countries and it's possible only in a multipolar world. I think this is also the idea of Brazilian government. The project of the US is to dominate the world : not partners, only submissive vassals... or enemies. The Obama's dream is to rule the world with China (the G2). Is there a place for Brazil or France in this world? This is THE question Regards - Kelesis Thu, 11 Feb 2010 05:23:48 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-44029 one green bottle sitting on the wall. One green bottle sitting on the wall. And if one of those bottles should 'accidentally' fall there will be no green bottles sitting on the wall (anymore). The violent revolution in retaliation for the jews doing 9/11 is already here. Just one shot away from pogroms against jews in America. If I had a million dollars to spare I could fund that spark. But if 1 million dollars is now left to all it would take then you jews better get out of the US super fast and disperse rapidly like a gas bottle. - Jake McCrann Thu, 28 Jan 2010 17:57:21 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43862 Folks, this past week was one of the most hopeful in a while. When Scott Brown won the election it was obvious that America was finally starting to see Obama for what he and his underhanded cronies really are. I posted a couple of very similar posts on our blog this past week please take a moment and stop by our Do Follow Blog. http://www.tulsarealestatemall.com/blog/ America we must continue to rise before its too late! - a rosson Sun, 24 Jan 2010 17:42:45 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43661 [quote]And Brasil just gave every illegal immigrant Amnesty in 2009 in case you weren't paying attention - and lots of illegal Americans enjoyed it.[/quote] What´s the problem in giving amnesty to illegal Americans, Jake? We even gave one to an Ozzie.:D P.S: You don't have to repeat the comments three times to emphasize your point! - João da Silva Fri, 15 Jan 2010 07:00:26 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43652 Actually that is what the US do. They have secret prisons where they torture people and hold them for years without trial. Its not what "the rest of the world does" - its just what the US does. And Brasil just gave every illegal immigrant Amnesty in 2009 in case you weren't paying attention - and lots of illegal Americans enjoyed it. - jake McCrann Thu, 14 Jan 2010 20:54:46 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43651 "US has been invaded by Mexico ,Brazil ,and the rest of the world by illeagles living here .should the US fallow what every other country does and arest them on false charges as spies send them to jail or extort money from there familys" Actually that is what the US do. They have secret prisons where they torture people and hold them for years without trial. Its not what "the rest of the world does" - its just what the US does. And Brasil just gave every illegal immigrant Amnesty in 2009 in case you weren't paying attention - and lots of illegal Americans enjoyed it. - jake McCrann Thu, 14 Jan 2010 20:52:54 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43650 "US has been invaded by Mexico ,Brazil ,and the rest of the world by illeagles living here .should the US fallow what every other country does and arest them on false charges as spies send them to jail or extort money from there familys" Actually that is what the US do. They have secret prisons where they torture people and hold them for years without trial. Its not what "the rest of the world does" - its just what the US does. And Brasil just gave every illegal immigrant Amnesty in 2009 in case you weren't paying attention - and lots of illegal Americans enjoyed it. - jake McCrann Thu, 14 Jan 2010 20:52:42 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43649 Hi Mr.Benesch, [quote]Thanks for the sarcasm. [/quote] You are most welcome. [quote]But who would value comments in a forum like this any higher, anyway. Your own have been quite inflationary. [/quote] People who are serious and capable of doing in-depth analysis of the article written. [quote]Your own have been quite inflationary.[/quote] I generally like to focus on the issues under discussion and if you considered my comments as inflationary, I apologize for having hurt your feelings. Having said that, I just wanted to make some observations. 1) You are an European,but not French. However, I was really taken aback that you are promoting French made products in general and specifically the "Hangar Fighters". 2) In your zeal, you totally forgot to answer the questions of the writer of this article which were reinforced by Captain Carnaval, who probably is an officer of our FAB. The questions put forth by Dr.Alberto Dines and Capt.Carnival are being asked by many,many [i][b]honest[/b][/i] Brasilians: "Why the Rush?" 3) You haven't defined who our "unstable" neighbors are. If by any chance you are referring to that crackpot Chavez, let me remind you that Putin took him for a sucker ride like Sarko is trying to do to us. If you are referring to Cris and Nestor,they are in a bigger mess than Col.Chavez. The rest of the "caudilhos" are of no consequence to us. 4) The rest of your comments reinforce my impression that you really do not know what is going on in this hemisphere and get all your news about it from the European Newspapers. I have the following questions for you: 1) Did you know that our FAB classified their preferences as follows?: a) Gripen b) F-18 c) Rafalle 2) Did you know that the French are yet to explain the reason for the Air France 447 disintegrating over the Atlantic and they are yet to find the Black Boxes (in spite of their "moderate,but not overbearing technology")? 3) Why would Brasil require French Technology to build our airplanes and Armament Industries, when we have very competent engineers? Even if they are not, they could hire engineers from all over the world. 4) Do you really think that we can trust the French? I hope you take some time off to mull over my questions and respond. - João da Silva Thu, 14 Jan 2010 14:23:26 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43646 Thanks for the sarcasm. But who would value comments in a forum like this any higher, anyway. Your own have been quite inflationary. Sorry to not live up to your "superior" intellect, Christian - Christian Benesch Wed, 13 Jan 2010 23:56:40 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43633 Thanks for the thought provoking and [b][i]honest[/i][/b] comments. They are [i][b]just[/b][/i] worth what you said: [b][i]These are only my two (Euro)cents[/i][/b] - João da Silva Wed, 13 Jan 2010 08:16:04 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43631 This is from a European(not French though) standpoint, so forgive me, if I get some things the wrong way. But there are reasons, why France is attractive in terms of strategic cooperation: 1) You want your military capacity to be independent(as much as possible). This is why one big issue is the technology transfer was such a big issue here. The only country in the competition that can provide *full* unrestricted technology transfer is France, which has all these things developed from scratch and owns them. 2) You do not want to purchase from the U.S. who actually calls you their "backyard"(Obama or no Obama). With France you would, if at all, have the reverse power-relation, with their small Guyanian corner. France as a middle power is sufficiently competent but not overbearingly powerful. 3) Once you enter a "strategic partnership", you get better conditions, better understanding, better cooperation. In the end probably a better price. So the fighter plane becomes part of a bigger package. 4) France is willing to share technology, assemble locally etc. So you can build up your own defense industry. Embraer, I believe, will benefit greatly from this. In the long run this might even *earn* money. I believe, there are talks about licensing production for the whole of the South American market. 5) France's products are of high quality. The Rafale is a capable platform. The article questions if there is a threat at all. This is really for the Brazilians to assess, but from what I take from the news there are a few issues that make it important to modernize, build up the military: 1) Resource protection: new oil fields off the coast, etc. 2) Unstable neighbours. 3) Ambitions to be globally relevant and remove the stigma of being a developing country(i.e. access to the UN security council) These are only my two (Euro)cents, Christian Benesch - Christian Benesch Wed, 13 Jan 2010 07:32:00 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43623 Forrest Allen Brown: Ricardo and why with the US in Colombia do you call it an invasion?? if that is so than the US has been invaded by Mexico ,Brazil ,and the rest of the world by illeagles living here .should the US fallow what every other country does and arest them on false charges as spies send them to jail or extort money from there familys ***** Ricardo: You must be kidding with the above argument. You don’t deserve an answer for that one - your argument is too silly for any answer. . - Ricardo C. Amaral Tue, 12 Jan 2010 19:23:18 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43622 [quote]None the less, we are proud to be Goyim slaves of the Jews and will not tolerate dissidents. [/quote] That's good to know because I'll never write on that site. Not until you people recognize that Hamas is a legitimate representative of the population of the Gaza Strip.Covardes! - São Paulo!! Tue, 12 Jan 2010 16:05:06 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43615 [quote]Jake McCrann has been repeatedly warned AND knows that Hate Speech is not tolerated at Gingoes.com[/quote] Jake é um rapaz sem juizo. ;) - João da Silva Tue, 12 Jan 2010 13:48:45 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43613 Jake McCrann has been repeatedly warned AND knows that Hate Speech is not tolerated at Gingoes.com We are a peaceful website and do not persecute any minorities, yes, even if they have a majority of all the money and have been printing trillions of Goyim dollars out and giving them all to the Jews. None the less, we are proud to be Goyim slaves of the Jews and will not tolerate dissidents. - Gringoes Tue, 12 Jan 2010 13:28:14 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43612 [quote]Democracy my ass. We are all living now under some form of neo-feudalism.[/quote] Finally it dawned on you, eh?;D - João da Silva Tue, 12 Jan 2010 13:04:12 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43611 [quote] You sound like one of those kook conspiracy theorists. Bad pills day was it John? [/quote] No,Mr.Impostor. Blame it on the hot weather which certainly must have affected you also. BTW, you will never make a good Moossad agent.;):D - João da Silva Tue, 12 Jan 2010 13:00:53 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43610 Well I bloody hope so John because I know they were not in my country. They were sucking so much old cheese Rabbi cocks that I couldn't walk in the streets anymore without vomiting. So I left and came to Brasil. - Jake McCrann Tue, 12 Jan 2010 12:51:51 +0100 http://www.brazzil.com/home-mainmenu-1/212-january-2010/10326-since-when-is-bonapartism-closer-to-brazils-culture-than-obamas-world-view.html#comment-43609 I dont know what you are talking about. You sound like one of those kook conspiracy theorists. Bad pills day was it John? Lols. Thats the kind of insults abound in this delinquint filthy excuse of a society we have been reduced to. Democracy my ass. We are all living now under some form of neo-feudalism. The Copenhagen convention would have ratified it full bono. - Jake McCrann Tue, 12 Jan 2010 12:38:36 +0100