|
"These guys don't play with their hearts. They only play for money," was the comment made by one disappointed fan on TV Bandeirantes news after Brazil was knocked out of the World Cup by France. The Brazilians were a disgrace. The players brought shame to themselves and let their country down.
This highly-paid line-up of stars - Ronaldinho Gaúcho, Ronaldo, Kaká, Roberto Carlos, Adriano, Robinho, Cafu, Cicinho - played with no heart, no guts, no pride and no sense that they represented the hopes of everyone back in Brazil. They were leaderless and aimless and did not have the individual and collective character to recover from an early goal in the second half. They had 35 minutes to equalize and take the game into an extra period but failed to meet the challenge. The dream of winning the World Cup for a sixth time ended with the final whistle and Brazil has now entered a period akin to mourning. Since virtually the entire team lives abroad they will not appreciate just how deeply felt this blow has been. It is too early to make any comment on the future of the team and that of manager Carlos Alberto Parreira. It is also probably too much to expect some apologies, particularly from someone like Brazil's veteran captain, Cafu. Not only did he play badly but he showed no leadership qualities. Nor did Kaká who is being groomed to replace him. Neither made any effort to encourage the team when it was struggling and demoralized. When Cafu was finally taken off, the captain's armband went to the goalkeeper Dida who was in no position to rally the team. Parreira delayed too long before making substitutions and showed no remorse in his post-match comments. Unlike the Argentinean manager, Jose Pekerman, who resigned immediately after his team's defeat against Germany, Parreira gave no indication that he would take the honorable way out. Instead, he made a lame excuse, saying that when a team was playing well the players got the applause but when it was playing badly the manager got the blame. Whether or not Parreira saves his face by resigning, his days are surely numbered. As for the team, it is surely time to get rid of Cafu, Roberto Carlos and even, in my opinion, Ronaldo. They have all given great service but it is time to move on. Players like Ronaldinho Gaúcho, Kaká, Cicinho and, perhaps, Adriano should be the new base on which the team is formed even though none of them performed consistently in this championship. There is bound to be a campaign to bring back Luiz Felipe Scolari, who guided Brazil to the championship four years ago and has taken Portugal through to the semi finals this time. It is almost a relief that the World Cup is now over. Life can return to normal and people can try and forget this episode in which Brazil struggled against lowly teams like Croatia, Australia, Japan and Ghana. Despite the victories against these teams, most fans were not impressed and I doubt if the defeat by France really came as a surprise. Companies would be wise to scrap all the advertising campaign involving the players and manager immediately as they are in danger of backfiring. Would you buy a cellular just because Parreira urges you to do so? Would you open an account with a bank just because Ronaldo and Kaká have accounts there? Would you buy a bubble gum because Ronaldinho Gaúcho claims to like it? Perhaps if the players had devoted more time to football and less to advertising campaigns and frolicking in front of the cameras during the "training" periods in Switzerland and Germany we might be now looking forward to a semi-final against Portugal rather than seeing Portugal as a proxy for Brazil. John Fitzpatrick is a Scottish writer and consultant with long experience of Brazil. He is based in São Paulo and runs his own company Celtic Comunicações. You can read more by him at his site www.brazilpoliticalcomment.com.br. He can be contacted at
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
. © John Fitzpatrick 2006
 |