Brazilians and IMF: Dialogue of Deafs

The Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), Rodrigo Rato, met Setpember 3 with 14 representatives of Brazil’s civil society. Members of the landless rural workers movement, NGO’s, university professors, journalists, students and the Vice-President of the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB) attended the encounter.

They were unanimous in their positions. They demanded an end to foreign debt payments.

During the 45 minutes the meeting lasted, Rato accepted all the criticisms of the Fund’s activities in Brazil, but he stressed that the IMF’s positive acts outweigh the negative ones.


The main point in favor, according to him, is that the Fund is the only institution available to run to for help in times of crisis.

He affirmed that Brazil’s present situation is stable. For Rato, this is the first time in 30 years that the country has attained this status. This is the most important aspect, because, in his view, economic stability is more important than social stability.


“Only a stable economic situation is capable of transforming society,” he summed up.

Rato began the meeting by recalling that the IMF is controlled by governments, which founded it and direct it.


“The legitimate governments of each country are the ones that draw up the policies. And the weight of each government is determined by its shares of participation in the capital,” he explained.

Although insisting on the independence of nations, Rato underscored that Brazil is in need of structural reforms, such as untying budget resources and reorganizing labor relations. “These reforms have a greater weight in trade agreements.”

According to Rato, the Fund has already assisted various countries. IMF support restored nearly bankrupt economies.


“For example, the IMF revived Brazil in 2002, England in ’78, Canada in the ’80’s, and Spain in the decade of the ’60’s.”

The Director claimed that the IMF is not to blame for the increase in poverty. According to him, the countries that took on debts they are unable to pay are the true villains, since they shift the burden to future generations.


“No country emerged from poverty in the last 15 years with an increase in extreme poverty, inflation, or government debt. Macroeconomic stability is the friend, not the enemy, of poverty.”

Questions Unanswered


The Vice-President of the OAB, Aristóteles Atheniense, considered the meeting useful. But he commented that Rato failed to reply to various questions. The main one, in his view, was a question concerning an item in the Brazilian Constitution.


The law requires Congress to conduct annual audits on payment of the debt. “The Brazilian population needs to know how much it owes and where this debt comes from. I did not obtain this response from the Director.”

Atheniense also remarked that the creation of a new credit line for future cases of financial instability is a contradiction.


“If revenue collection in Brazil has been so successful, and economic policy has achieved so many victories, why do we need a reserve fund?” he queried.

For her part, Sandra Quintela, representative of the NGO Brazil Network, considered the meeting a “conversation between deaf people.”


According to her, the representatives of society presented their viewpoints, and Rodrigo Rato spoke in favor of the IMF.


“We were not given the chance to respond to Mr. Rato’s comments. It was a conversation between deaf people,” she concluded.

Agência Brasil
Reporter: Lilian Macedo
Translator: David Silberstein

Tags:

Ads

You May Also Like

A Brazilian Frontier State Learns How to Make Ecologically Correct Furniture

The northern Brazilian state of Acre definitely isn’t a state symbol of furniture making ...

PMDB Party Gets 3 Cabinet Posts in Exchange for Good Will in Brazil

Brazil’s presidential spokesman, André Singer, announced Wednesday, July 6, that Brazilian President Luiz Inácio ...

Juruena river in the Amazon

Brazil Amazon Indians Seek International Help to Prevent Dam Building

As Brazil celebrates its national Day of the Indian on April 19, a new ...

10 Brazilians Make the List of Latin America’s 25 Global Star Entrepreneurs

The CEO of AB InBev, the world’s largest brewer, Brazilian Carlos Brito,  is among ...

Communist Aldo Rebelo is Brazil's House speaker

Brazil’s Strange Idea of Democracy

Brazil had a new president for a day on November 13, 2006, a communist ...

Brazil Waiting for House Speaker’s Resignation Speech

The president of Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies Ethics Council, Ricardo Izar, postponed until today ...

Brazil’s Lula Signs Law to Bar Chinese Goods

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva signed into law regulations for the use ...

65 Million Now Have Fluor in Their Water in Brazil. 120 Million Don’t.

By adding another 787 teams consisting of a dentist, an office assistant and a ...

POR AÍ

Slam-bang Guga Gustavo Kuerten, who every Brazilian is calling Guga these days, is tennis’ ...

Chinese currency

Here Is Why Brazil Should Adopt the New Asian Currency

Here we are at a very exciting time – a turning point in world ...