Diplomats and Jurists, in Brazil, Debate the WTO

Commercial disputes between member countries of the World Trade Organization are replacing the political tone by the juridical one. Attorneys are becoming equally or even more important than diplomats in the conduction of cases that get to the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Body.

And the Appellate Body, responsible for the final word, is seen almost as a tribunal. These are the main conclusions of the conference “WTO at 10 – A Perspective of the Appellate Body,” which gathered yesterday and today (17-18), in São Paulo, diplomats, jurists, and scholars of all Latin America.


The subject worries international trading experts, especially now that even more disputes involve issues such as services, industrial property, sanitary and phytosanitary measures.


In the analysis of Ambassador Luiz Felipe Seixas Corrêa, head of the Brazilian permanent delegation at the WTO, the reform of the Dispute Settlement Body is inevitable.


“The Doha Round, when creating new areas of negotiation, such as agriculture, and insisting on deepening other subjects such as non-agricultural goods and services, will considerably expand its area of operation and the intensification of WTO norms. And for this expanded WTO, obviously, there will be necessary a renovated, agile body for the settlement of disputes,” he said.


Some believe that bringing these disputes to a legal arena, instead of to an essentially diplomatic one, must be reinforced with the adoption of juridical procedures, such as the consolidation of similar decisions for the creation of Jurisprudence, and the implementation of penalties for countries that lose commercial disputes.


The current Dispute Settlement system analyzes each case and does not apply sanctions. The Appellate Body, when giving the final word, recommends to the country that loses the dispute to modify its policies to comply with the decision, otherwise, the winning country can adopt compensatory measures, such as rising tariffs in other sectors, for example.


During the panel “Problems and Improvements proposed for the WTO’s Settlement Dispute System: a market economic outlook,” attorney Tito Amaral de Andrade said that retaliations go against the trade liberalization system.


“The SPS (agreement about the application of sanitary and phytosanitary measures) and the TBT (agreement about Technical Barriers to Trade) are going to become the greatest problems of the future, and it will be necessary to discuss the celerity of procedures and the implementation of decisions,” he believes. Andrade suggests, for example, a financial compensation for winning countries.


Agência Brasil

Tags:

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil to Leave Inprint on World’s Largest Hydroelectric

Eletrobrás (Brazilian Electric Holding, S.A.) informed that it signed a technical cooperation agreement this ...

Pressured by the US, Mexico Imposes Visas on Brazilians

Beginning on October 23, all Brazilians travelling to Mexico will have to have a ...

Brazil Starts Push to End Hoof and Mouth Disease in Three Years

Brazil’s national vaccination campaign against hoof and mouth disease got underway yesterday, September 1st, ...

Favelas Growing 4.5% a Year in Brazil

What grew 4.5% a year in Brazil between 1991 and 2000? Unfortunately it was ...

For a True Connoisseur Vodka in Brazilian Caipirinha Is Blasphemy

While living in Brazil, I remember ordering caipirinhas, the famous national cocktail made with ...

Brazil Is the Star of 2009 Franchise Expo Paris

Brazil will get special treatment from the Franchise Expo Paris, the major international event ...

The Ghosts of Rio

I did as the Cariocas and stepped right over the bodies. They shopped for ...

Brazilian Court’s Latest Decision: Amazon’s Belo Monte Dam Is Off

In the latest chapter of a decades-long dramatic battle between environmentalists and the government ...

Jeitinho Land

In cases where regulations have to be confronted, Brazilians pride themselves on being especially ...

Brazil Has Already Slaughtered 34,000 Cattle Due to Foot and Mouth Disease

Starting yesterday, May 1st, cattle breeders in 14 states and the Federal District (DF) ...