How Brazil’s and LatAm’s Banks Weathered the Global Meltdown

Banco do Brasil Brazil's and Latin America's financial systems have passed the Financial Times magazine test. In an article under the headline of "Latin America sidesteps the worst of crisis," FT correspondents in Sao Paulo and Mexico City elaborate on the region's banking industry and how "by accident and design" in spite of a long history of turbulence, it is weathering the global crisis.

Maybe because of the relatively small size of the system, but definitively because regulations and close monitoring have helped Latin American banks stay away "from all those toxic products" that damaged US banks.

Latin American economies are still paying the price for past home-grown banking crises. But these crises have, by accident and design, allowed the region's banks to weather the global financial storms in relative comfort.

Some banks, particularly smaller ones, have suffered from reduced access to funds. But bankers, financial analysts and government officials say domestic funding markets have for the most part continued to function, in spite of the dislocation in industrialized country markets.

Nonetheless, the result is likely to be leaner times for banks and, as a result, more mergers among the region's lenders. While executives said the merger between Brazilian banks Itaú and Unibanco did not come about as a direct result of the crisis, analysts say smaller banks are likely to be taken over by their larger counterparts in Brazil and elsewhere.

In general, however, Latin America's banks are proving very resilient. This is in part because, although credit growth has accelerated in recent years, the region's banking systems are relatively small.

Only in Chile, which suffered its last banking crisis a quarter of a century ago, does bank lending to the private sector exceed 75% of gross domestic product.

In Brazil and Mexico, which both suffered banking crises in the mid-1990s, it is about 40% and 20% respectively. In Argentina, whose latest bank trauma dates to earlier this decade, it is barely above 10%.

Mindful of past crises, central banks have curbed bank borrowing in dollars and insisted that banks are well capitalized.

In Brazil, close to 30% of bank deposits have been held with the central bank as reserve requirements, giving it a tool, when necessary, to supplement bank liquidity.

Brazil's central bank has also authorized state-owned banks, including Banco do Brasil, to take equity stakes in private banks and to buy loan portfolios. Meanwhile, under Brazilian law, controlling shareholders in banks face unlimited liability in the event of a bank collapse.

In Mexico, foreign banks provide more than 70% of credit to the private sector. Banorte, the fourth- largest, is the only Mexican-owned bank to survive among the top five institutions which also comprise subsidiaries of BBVA and Santander of Spain, Citibank and HSBC.

Some companies have complained as banks cut off credit to repatriate funds to head office. But Guillermo Ortiz, Banco de México governor, told the Financial Times that the central bank had ensured Mexican lenders "stayed away from all those toxic products" that damaged US banks.

He said: "In the domestic banking system, we have had little problem compared to other countries. Of course we have some specific concerns regarding the growth of overdue obligations in credit cards and so on. But this is really not posing a systemic risk."

According to the CNBV, Mexico's banking regulator, banks' capital is more than 15% of risk-weighted assets – almost twice the required amount. A CNBV official said: "The banking system is very strong. It has a sturdy asset base, it continues to issue credit, it is well capitalized and it has plenty of reserves."

In Brazil, nine banks – soon to become eight – account for almost 90% of cash deposits and three are state-owned. But this means more than 150 smaller institutions are heavily dependent on wholesale funding.

Over the past month, the central bank has taken a series of measures aimed at improving liquidity for smaller banks. It has released more than 100 billion (US$ 46 billion) from reserve requirements, freeing smaller banks from holding the reserve.

Last week, it said it would cease to pay interest on reserve requirements for an indefinite period.

"Now the banks have a real incentive to lend," a senior government official told the FT. "There are a lot of small and medium-sized banks that want to borrow, especially ones owned by car companies."

Subsidiaries of car companies such as GM, Ford, Fiat and Volkswagen opened banks in Brazil to lend to customers wanting to finance car purchases.

The government official said the move to stop paying interest would be welcomed by smaller banks but would upset bigger ones.

Márcio Cypriano, head of Bradesco, described the move as a "punishment" and said the bank was likely to raise interest rates to its customers to compensate for the lost interest.



  • Show Comments (1)

  • ch.c.

    More cheap and incorrect….there is not !
    – If Argentina is on the verge of going bankrupt a second time, it is not because they are doing well ! Better yet, if they do relatively ok then why do they want to seize their pension funds ? Why is their Credit Default Swap at well over 20 % ?????

    – Brazil is not doing that well ! Otherwise WHY the U-S. FED LENT US$ 30 billion to the Brazilian Government if lending continued near normal ??????? Come on….cheap journalism, cheap reporters, article written by idiots. The same idiots who a year ago said…..the U.S- subprime is a local problem….over the pond….not in the EU ! the same idiots also wrote that the UK real estate market was strong anf had no reason to go down. What a lie it was or what a wrong analysis they had. These same idiots wrote the British Pound is strong….but it depreciated the most ! MORE WRONG…hard to find…..except with Bin The Crook !

    – Concerning the derivatives in Brazil, that apparently are very low, let me say…MY EYE !
    Yesterday Votorantim took US DOLLARS 2,2 BILLION CHARGE on currency losses ! How many Us$ were they short to produce such a loss ?????? Even assuming they took the WHOLE position at the TOP of the Brl, the MINIMUM EXPOSURE was US$ 7 BILLION !!!!! Since this is unlikely, their probable BET was US$ 10-12 BILLION….the wrong way ! But total silence…so far ! Hiding the truth remains the norm ! Strange that an industrial company BETS US$ 10 BILLION…IN CURRENCIES !
    THE CASINO IS IN BRAZIL….not in EU or USA !!!!!!!! No large NON financial companies in the US or the EU has announced such a large currencys loss…even by companies FAR FAR FAR larger than Votorantim !!!!!!!
    The only exception is in Asia, with CITIC. They had an Australian Dollars 10 Billion exposure and took also around a US DOLLARS 2 billion loss. And such a BET (not hedge) because they had a plan to invest A$ 1,8 billion in Australia. Smiles ! They expected to cover this investment with a CURRENCY BET !!!!!! Great idea ! Laugh

    – Furthermore on Toxic Debts that apparently are not in Brazil, here is a much well informed source comment :
    “The so-called À¢€˜shadow banking systemÀ¢€™ is smaller than the one in the US and does not carry MBS, RMBS type of synthetics. This does not mean that the portfolio of commercial banks and corporations doesnÀ¢€™t carry the so-called À¢€˜toxic assetsÀ¢€™. The fact is that these toxic assets are everywhere and in Brazil they are called À¢€˜structured notesÀ¢€™. The securitization process and the overall structure of these notes are extremely similar to the collateralized debt obligations, the so-called CDOs.”

    And the sources are not from FT idiots UK reporters !
    Near the top of the commodities, they too were BULLISH ! Oil WILL go to US$ 200.-, grains UP UP UP and more UP due to the China/India theory, and of course the US$ had only one way….DOWN !!!!!!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

Brazil’s Mining Co. Vale Seems to Have Bought Overpriced Rio Tinto

Brazilian mining company Vale do Rio Doce may have paid too much for its ...

Mercosur Needs a Parliament, Says Brazil’s Lula

During today’s visit by the President of Uruguay, Tabaré Vázquez, Brazilian President, Luiz Inácio ...

Leprosy Still a Plague in Brazil

Brazil is second, after India, for the total number of cases of leprosy in ...

Number of Brazilians Unemployed Jumps to 9% or 2.1 Million People

Unemployment in Brazil remained steady at 9% with a growing tendency in March, having ...

Brazil Ready to Tap Amazon for Drugs and the Land for Fuel

Ahead of US President George Bush's visit, Brazil announced plans to invest almost US$ ...

Fall of Brazil’s Chief of Staff Is Black Day for Lula

{mosimage}The South African President, Thabo Mbeki, sacked his deputy Jacob Zuma on 14 June ...

Like Our Parents

Students and their parents have rock as their first musical choice. Leonardo da Vinci ...

In Surprise Move, Brazil Decides to Pay Off Its US$ 15 Billion IMF Debt

Brazil announced its intention to make an early repayment of its entire outstanding obligations ...

Brazilian Industry Says It Won’t Accept Increases in Bolivia’s Gas Prices

The president of the São Paulo Manufacturers Federation (Federação das Indústrias do Estado de ...