For Brazil the Paraguayan-Brazilian Row Over Itaipu Is Just Political

Itaipu Dam According to Brazilian president's international affairs advisor, Marco Aurélio Garcia, differences between Brazil and Paraguay over the world's largest operational hydroelectric dam, Itaipu, are a "political problem" and not an energy issue.

Garcia said the Itaipu treaty which regulates the shared dam and Paraguay would like to review, in spite of Brazil's resistance, was born under "specific historical circumstances" and now "we must determine whether it is possible to modify it or not."

Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's advisor pointed out that the Paraguayan leader, Fernando Lugo "was elected with certain promises (such as the review of the Itaipu treaty) and must now deliver something" to his electorate, but he also recalled that the conditions of the document which Paraguay is demanding to modify "were created" by governments quite back in history.

The Itaipu treaty was signed 35 years ago by the two military dictatorships ruling Brazil and Paraguay at the time. Lugo argues some of the clauses contained are "leonine" and harm his country and is requesting a review of prices paid for power generated at Itaipu, as well as the pending debt from the time the dam was constructed. It is also demanding the right to trade its surplus share to third countries at spot market values.

Garcia added that it was his personal view that presidents Lula and Lugo get along very well, and that "makes us believe that it's possible to find a common denominator" to differences. It's a question of time "but I think they will reach common ground."

May 8, Lula and Lugo discussed the Itaipu issue in Brazilian capital Brasí­lia for several hours, but arrived to no accord and walked out of the meeting without signing 15 bilateral cooperation agreements in other areas, leaving the ceremony and staff in blank. The only thing agreed was to hold another round of talks next July, this time in Asuncion, Paraguay.

However, the Brazilian presidency spokesperson Marcelo Baumbach said that another bilateral meeting "could probably take place" next Monday when both presidents meet in San Salvador for the taking office ceremony of El Salvador president Mauricio Funes.

Meantime in São Paulo, local politicians, industry and business representatives listened to the two sides of the Itaipu controversy at a forum hosted by Brazil's all powerful São Paulo Federation of Industries, FIESP.

Delegates Carlos Mateo from Paraguay and Jorge Samek from Brazil set their cases but apparently arrived nowhere and the prevailing opinion following the meeting was that is had been a "non productive" debate.

Samek during a brief press conference said that Paraguay's claim regarding the surplus power is "impracticable" and can only be reviewed in 2023, as established in the treaty.

"Articles XIII and XIV of the treaty are quite clear in so far that any surplus must be sold to the other partner in need," underlined Samek.

Mateo argued that the treaty does not say that only Eletrobrás (government owned power corporation) can sell the surplus energy in Brazil and does not impede other companies from being involved.

Anyhow it was "a positive debate," because only the Itaipu staff talked, "we have to wait to see what the real actors of Brazil's political and business establishments have to say. Meantime prudence and calm," said Mateo.

Mercopress

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Bio Plunderers

The Biodiversity Convention signed by 144 countries, at ECO 92, held in Rio de ...

Brazil’s Furniture Union Puts 2006 Production on Sale

Unimóveis, the Furniture Worker Union of the Brazilian northern state of Amapá is promoting ...

Ahmadinejad Says Brazil and Iran Should Work Together for a More Just World

Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva sent his Foreign minister to Turkey, Rússia ...

Brazil’s Major Bookstore Chain Gobbles Up Competition

Saraiva, a major Brazilian bookstore chain, has bought Siciliano, its competitor, for 60 million ...

How Brazilian “Cats” Make Slavery a Thriving Business in Brazil

Last week the local papers reminded Brazilians of the signing of the Lei Áurea ...

Export and Domestic Growth Go Together, Says Brazil’s Lula

Brazilian President, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, said yesterday that Brazil is about to ...

Brazil Festival Matures: 329 Films from 66 Countries

The 28th annual São Paulo International Film Festival opens today. By choosing the Cine ...

The Stones’s Free Bigger Bang Concert from Rio, Brazil, Comes Live to the Net

After shattering North American box office records, the Rolling Stones are taking their sold-out ...

Group on Earth Observations Holds Meeting in Brazil

Starting today, May 29, representatives of the Group on Earth Observations (GEO), an intergovernmental ...

TAM Adds Italy and NY Red-Eye Flight to Its International Routes

Brazilian airline TAM has received official authorization from ANAC (Agência Nacional de Aviação Civil), ...