Brazil: Verdict Against Award-Winning Journalist May Break His Newspaper

Lúcio Flávio Pinto Brazilian journalist Lúcio Flávio Pinto, a journalist who has received several prizes in Brazil and abroad for his work in defense of the Amazon, was ordered by the Justice to pay approximately US$ 15,000 for defaming Rômulo Maiorana, a deceased businessman, The ruling came courtesy of the Superior Court of the State of Pará, in the north of Brazil.

In the case, Rômulo Maiorana Jr. and Ronaldo Maiorana accused Pinto of offending the honor and reputation of their father, a businessman who built the main media group in the region, Grupo Liberal for an article published in Jornal Pessoal, which Pinto runs, in 2005 which claimed that Rômulo Maiorana was involved in smuggling activities in the 1950s and 1970s.

Pinto argued before the court that he was not the first to make these allegations, and presented copies of documents he believes prove that his allegations are general knowledge and also accurate. According to Pinto, such activities were commonplace in the isolated state of Pará at that time.

According to Pinto's calculations, the damage award, which together with legal fees may amount to US$ 20,000, is equivalent to more than a year of the newspaper's gross income. Such payment would probably force him to close his newspaper.

The Court also ordered Jornal Pessoal – a one-man publication – to publish a note drafted by the Maiorana brothers in full, and forbade Jornal Pessoal from again publishing any statement that could be considered aggressive, defamatory, calumnious or slanderous in relation to Rômulo Maiorana and his two sons, or face a further US$ 15,000 penalty.

Pinto, who has 42 years of experience in reporting on environmental devastation and corruption in the Amazon, has in the past been the victim of death threats, physical attacks and dozens of civil and criminal defamation lawsuits. He currently faces 14 other lawsuits filed by the Maiorana brothers.

The international press organization Article 19 says that it is concerned about this decision, which involves allegations of high public interest. The decision fails to elaborate on the basis for finding Pinto's allegations to be false and does not address the documents presented by Pinto in his defense.

The organization argues that in cases involving matters of public interest, the plaintiff should be required to prove the falsity of their allegations.

Research indicates, Article 19 adds, that the civil defamation provisions is open to abuse and that they have previously expressed concern about the lack of clear standards for civil defamation in Brazil, including as to the size of damage awards.

The international body calls on the Brazilian authorities to amend the rules on civil defamation so that they are clear and respect international standards, including as to the burden of proof in cases involving matters of public interest. We also call on the authorities to decriminalize defamation and related crimes.



You May Also Like

We Need the Bomb

The Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty, in force since 1970, became obsolete overnight in 2002. It’s ...

41 Brazilians Still Missing in Tsunami Area

The most recent information released by Brazil’s Ministry of Foreign Relations (MRE) indicates that ...

3.5 Dead for 1 Injured: Bonus for Cops in Brazil Doubles Number of Killed Suspects

The growing number of police killings of suspected criminals in Rio de Janeiro's war ...

Brazil Spends 16% of Its GDP in Social Programs

The Social Direct Budget of the Brazilian federal government in 2004 was US$ 98.98 ...

Certification Is the Way to Internationalization, Brazil Concludes

More than 3,500 men and approximately 400 machines are already at work in the ...

Brazil’s Thor Has 20 Mines to Supply Overseas Marble Market

Brazilian company Thor Granitos main aim for 2009 is to guarantee the maintenance of ...

US Delegation for Inauguration of Brazil’s New President to Be Headed by Hillary Clinton

Hillary Clinton, the US secretary of State will head the United States delegation to ...

Pure Samba

In movies, plays, music, art, and literature, the Brazilian culture continues more alive than ...

The Amazon Conundrum

She might have lost her cool and might have told him that it was ...

Brazil Gives Australia a Hand on Biofuel Prospects

The Australian government will create a study group to examine the impacts of ethanol ...