Brazil Supreme Rules that Civil Servant’s Salaries May Be Shown in Internet

São Paulo mayor, Gilberto Kassab
Brazil's Supreme Court held on July 8 that the mayor of the municipality of São Paulo could order the salary of all municipal civil servants to be put online. The Superior Court of São Paulo had previously suspended the mayor's decision to do this, on grounds of personal security.

On 16 June 2009, the Mayor of São Paulo, Gilberto Kassab, decided that the new website, Keeping an Eye on Public Costs (De Olho nas Contas) – http://deolhonascontas.prefeitura.sp.gov.br – should include a nominal list of all civil servants attached to the municipality – including 147,000 employees of the central administration and another 15,000 employed indirectly – with their posts, salaries and place of work.

Two associations of civil servants (representing professors, engineers and architects) filed lawsuits against this decision. They were granted an urgent provisional decision by the Superior Court of São Paulo, and the information was taken off-line. The Municipality appealed to the Supreme Court, which canceled the provisional decision and held that the information could be disseminated.

The two associations argued that the disclosures would, among other things, breach their constitutional rights to privacy and security of person. The Municipality argued that to refuse to disclose the data would be a violation of the constitutional right to information and principles of publicity of all administrative acts.

The São Paulo Superior Court held that the information could put people at risk, and also accepted some procedural arguments. The Supreme Court judge who ruled on the case, Justice Gilmar Mendes, referred to the fact that the Internet has transformed the citizen-State relationship, particularly in relation to social control over public expenditure.

The judge recognized that in some cases, openness could legitimately be limited. However, in this case, the public interest in having the information was stronger than the rights of civil servants, and "public order" would be violated by enforcing a judicial decision that undermined the Municipality's policy of transparency, in favor of individual rights.

The press freedom organization Article 19 has released a note welcoming the decision of the Brazilian Supreme Court and calling on the Brazilian judiciary to apply such standards in all right to information cases.

Genuine acceptance of the right to information will sometimes require balancing with other rights, reason Article 19, and the forward-looking stance of the Supreme Court in undertaking this balancing, rather than simply falling back on accepted notions of privacy and security, which are more established in the jurisprudence, is very welcome.

The international organization has also praised what it called the progressive position of the mayor of São Paulo and asked other public bodies also to adopt strong measures on openness of information.

"This is particularly pertinent and important in light of the new bill on the right to information presented by President Lula to Congress in May 2009," they argue.

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazilian Astronaut Will Use Space Trip to Advance Brazil’s Space Program

Brazilian astronaut Marcos Pontes, speaking to reporters as he recovers from his eight-day sojourn ...

Opposition Chooses Who They Hope Will Be Brazil’s Next President

The opposition in Brazil unified over the weekend behind Aécio Neves who was elected ...

Brazil’s New Definition of Foreign Aggression Bullies Neighbor Countries

The Brazilian government has sent a strong message to those (restless) neighbors that could ...

Comparing Education Between US, France, Argentina and Brazil

In Brazil the basic education system consists of eight years of elementary school, plus ...

Brazil Pays Homage to Kyoto Accord

In homage to the Kyoto Protocol, which went into effect on Wednesday, February 16, ...

Lula and Bush Vow to End World’s Farm Subsidies

President Bush and Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva have pledged to seek ...

Brazil School Decides to Take Back Student Expelled for “Indecent Exposure”

One day after announcing through ads in the press that it had expelled a ...

Sorry, Brazil’s Carnaval Is Not a Free for All, All Out Orgy

It’s Carnaval in Rio and I am honestly not that excited about it. I ...

Brazilian Music Gets Heard at Berlin’s Popkomm

The city of Rio de Janeiro, in Southeast Brazil, is amongst the representatives of ...

How My Beautiful and Brazen Friend Became a Goddess of Global Buddhism in Brazil

In 1978, one of the most beautiful and compelling friends I’ve ever had was ...