Lula Washes Hands on Cuban Dissident’s Death and Is Called Accomplice of Torture

Raul Castro and LulaBrazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva denied on Wednesday, in Havana, that he had received a letter from Cuban dissidents asking him to intervene in the case of plumber Orlando Zapata, who died in prison on Tuesday after 85 days on hunger strike.

“If they are dissidents of Cuba and now want to be dissidents of Lula I see no problem. People need to stop writing letters, keep them to themselves and then saying they sent them to other,” said Lula after meeting with his Cuban counterpart Raúl Castro and his brother, Fidel.

“Someone would only be able to say that he sent a letter to the president if the letter was filed and recorded. Actually I didn’t get any letter. If someone had asked me to talk I would have talked. We do not refuse to talk,” the president added.

Lula said he regretted Zapata’s death: “We have to regret, as a human being, someone who has died, who decided to go on a hunger strike, which you know I’m against because I’ve done it myself,” he stated in a reference to his own hunger strike when in prison during the military dictatorship (1964-1985).

Cuban dissidents talked about their disappointment with Lula. The leader of the Christian Liberation Movement Said Payá, leader of Christian Liberation Movement called Lula complicit in human rights violations in Cuba:

“We respect and love the Brazilian people, but the Lula government had no word of solidarity to human rights in Cuba. He has been a real accomplice of human rights violations in Cuba,” Payá said adding: “We do not expect and do not want to expect anything from him.”

Payá, one of the main voices of the Cuban dissident movement. He was awarded the Sajarov prize from the European Parliament in 2002.

As in the three previous official visits to Cuba, Lula did not meet with the opposition during this trip. In January 2008, Payá also criticized Lula for meeting only with members of the government. At the time, he said that Lula, by supporting the former dictator Fidel Castro, denies the Cuban people the democratic values he defends in Brazil.

A little earlier and in the presence of Lula, Raúl Castro like the Brazilian president lamented the death of Zapata. The Cuban leader said Zapata’s death is “the result of the relationship with the United States” and said there’s no torture in the island. Torture, he stated, is practiced in Guantanamo by the Americans.

“We are very sorry,” said Raúl. “He was sentenced to three years and had problems in prison. He was taken to our best hospitals, but died. We are very sorry” he said. “This is due to the confrontation we have with the US, we have lost thousands of Cubans.”

Security agents from Cuba detained dissidents across the country to prevent protests at the funeral of Zapata, a leading dissident whose death has sparked international indignation. Zapata, 42, was buried in his hometown of Banes, 830 kilometers east of Havana.

Mr Zapata’s mother, Reina Luisa Tamayo, says her son’s death was a “premeditated murder. My son was tortured the whole time he was in prison,” she said.

“I call on the international community to demand the release of the rest of the [political] prisoners … so that what happened to my boy does not happen again,” Ms Tamayo said.

Mr Zapata’s death 85 days into a hunger strike over prison conditions drew international condemnation and calls for an investigation and the release of all political prisoners.

The Cuban Commission for Human Rights and National Reconciliation spokesman Elizardo Sanchez said security agents detained about 30 activists Tuesday and Wednesday.

“Some also have been held in their houses, without a judicial warrant, to prevent people from going to the wake,” he said.

“[Mr Zapata’s death] is bad news for the human rights movement and for the government as well,” Mr Sanchez said.

A Havana Hermanos Ameijeiras hospital spokesman says Mr Zapata died at 1:00 pm (local time) on Tuesday after a nearly three-month protest against prison conditions.

He had been in jail since 2003 and blamed his already deteriorating health on harsh conditions inside Cuba’s jails. Zapata was transferred from a local clinic in the eastern province of Camaguey, near his prison, to Havana’s largest hospital on Monday.

Amnesty International urged President Castro to immediately and unconditionally release all prisoners of conscience.

“The tragic death of Orlando Zapata Tamayo is a terrible illustration of the despair facing prisoners of conscience who see no hope of being freed from their unfair and prolonged incarceration,” said Gerardo Ducos, Amnesty International’s Caribbean researcher. “A full investigation must be carried out to establish whether ill-treatment may have played a part in his death.”

According to AI, Zapata Tamayo was arrested in March 2003 and in May 2004 he was sentenced to three years in prison for “disrespect”, “public disorder” and “resistance”. He was subsequently tried several times on further charges of “disobedience” and “disorder in a penal establishment”, the last time in May 2009, and was serving a total sentence of 36 years at the time of his death.

“Faced with a prolonged prison sentence, the fact that Orlando Zapata Tamayo felt he had no other avenue available to him but to starve himself in protest is a terrible indictment of the continuing repression of political dissidents in Cuba,” said Gerardo Ducos

“The death of Orlando Zapata also underlines the urgent need for Cuba to invite international human rights experts to visit the country to verify respect for human rights, in particular obligations in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.”

Orlando Zapata Tamayo was one of 55 prisoners of conscience who have been adopted by Amnesty International in Cuba.



  • Show Comments (5)

  • Lloyd Cata

    João da Silva
    [b]Don´t forget to send an e-mail to your buddies Castro & Co , congratulating them for reducing the population of Cuba by 1 through “peaceful means”.[/b]

    I’m sure Mr. Lula conveyed that message personally to Mr. Castro’s.:sad:

  • João da Silva

    Llyod Cata
    [quote]The Death Of A Patriot[/quote]

    [quote]Mr. Zapata is a victim of just such injustice, and that does not advance the cause of justice for anyone. [/quote]

    Mr.Zapata was not a victim of injustice, but..but..but.. one of “Collateral” damages.

    [quote]My apology, best regards, and condolences to Mr. Zapata’s family. [/quote]

    Don´t forget to send an e-mail to your buddies Castro & Co , congratulating them for reducing the population of Cuba by 1 through “peaceful means”.:sad:

  • Lloyd Cata

    ….Error – The Death Of A Patriot
    Too often [s]tyranny[/s] of one type is advocated as an alternative to [s]tyranny[/s] of another. Mr. Zapata is a victim of just such [s]tyranny[/s], and that does not advance the cause of justice for anyone.

    The stricken word should be injustice, i.e.;

    [b]Too often injustice of one type is advocated as an alternative to injustice of another. Mr. Zapata is a victim of just such injustice, and that does not advance the cause of justice for anyone.[/b]

    My apology, best regards, and condolences to Mr. Zapata’s family.

  • Lloyd Cata

    The Death Of A Patriot
    What is sometimes lost in the struggle for human freedom and dignity in Cuba is that there are patriots on both sides. There is no question that the Cuban people are inherently deserving of rights, both political and economic, that they are being denied under the present ‘revolutionary’ regime. That regime is ‘responsible’ for the death of Mr Zapata. Any death, while in custody of the state, should be condemned. That Mr Zapata chose to end his life, rather than suffer the continued denial of his human rights, was a choice being made in many parts of the world today. Patriots willing to give their lives have nourished the growth of freedom around the world, and Mr Zapata certainly qualifies in that definition.

    Having said that, I am not unmindful that the Cuban regime is ‘still’, after 50 years of economic oppression, a ‘revolutionary’ regime. That revolution is not a fiction of someones imagination or some scheme to simply defraud the Cuban people of their rights. IMHO, it is an expression of the ‘constant’ need for vigilance in the face of an economic and military threat by ‘external’ forces who are intent on turning Cuba into a ‘ownership’ society with privatization as the core economic principle. Well, you say, “what’s wrong with that?”. What is wrong is that in too many places on the planet that ideology has left the ‘people’ of many countries destitute and trapped in the cycle of poverty and despair, as those with ‘money’ buy the inheritance of the people. Those ‘people’ will respond accordingly and sometimes in extremely violent manner. So let’s be very clear that ‘ownership’ and ‘privatization’ are not about the rights of the ‘people’. They are simply code words and labels which are used to legitimize the theft of the peoples inheritance by foreigners and their cadre of local elites.

    The Cuban ‘people’ own Cuba. There is, and should be, be a framework for Cubans to ‘partner’ with both foreigners and citizens. Right now that framework is not beneficial to either the ‘people’ or those wishing to invest in Cuba. However, given the framework of what has been a constant economic threat, the revolution ‘must’ continue until that threat has passed. The agenda of the Empire, can not and will not, leave Cuba in the state of abject misery that we find in so many places around the world that have sworn allegiance to that agenda. For 50 years the people of Cuba have suffered, but they have also shown tremendous courage and tremendous compassion for those, around the world, who are even more unfortunate than themselves. The Cuban relief effort in Haiti being only the most recent(unreported by MSM), together with their provision of doctors and teachers, where the Empire operated for centuries without the least provision of humane living conditions. In fact, destroying eco-systems that for centuries provided for the livelihoods and health of the people.

    Recently the OAS has rebuked Venezuela on human rights;

    “The commission emphasizes that observance of ‘other fundamental rights’ cannot be sacrificed for the sake of realizing economic, social and cultural rights in Venezuela,” the report states.

    In a perfect world, this would be absolutely true. That is not the world we live in, where dominant economic and military forces are used to subjugate ‘people’ under the most inhumane conditions. Revolution in defense of the inherent ‘ownership’ rights of ‘people’ is legitimate, patriotic, and necessary! Isn’t that the premise of the founding of American freedom from the tyranny of economic oppression by the original founders of the Empire?
    Too often tyranny of one type is advocated as an alternative to tyranny of another. Mr. Zapata is a victim of just such tyranny, and that does not advance the cause of justice for anyone.

  • João da Silva

    I am standing by to read the comments of our learned friend Dr.Lloyd Cata who is [i][b]the[/b][/i] expert on Cuban affairs as well as an ardent defender of Castro dynasty.:D

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

Brazil Pledges US$ 1 Million to Help Rebuild Lebanon

Celso Amorim, Brazil's minister of Foreign Relations, will participate this Thursday, January 25, in ...

Brazil Led Agrofuel Revolution Is Anything But Revolutionary

Agrofuel development has arrived on the global stage. Just this year, the number of ...

Thanks to Mining Industry Leads Brazilian Growth

Industry was the Brazilian sector that grew the most between January and June of ...

Interest Rates Are Hurting Brazil, Says Industries Federation

The president of Brazil’s Federation of Industries of the State of São Paulo (Fiesp), ...

Dollar Sinks to 13-month Low Against Brazilian Real. US Currency Down 32%

The real, Brazil's currency, rose to the strongest level in more than a year ...

Brazil Industry Falls 1.7%, Car Sales Drop 26%

Industrial production in Brazil fell in October as the global financial meltdown sent shock ...

Brazil Shares With World Experiences on Dealing with Racism

For the Minister of the Special Secretariat of Policies to Promote Racial Equality (Seppir), ...

Brazil Earmarks US$ 53 Billion for Agriculture for When the US Bear Wakes Up

Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, the president of Brazil, announced Brazil's 2009/2010 Agriculture and ...

Fearing Foreign Invasion Brazil Tightens Rules for Alien Land Buyers

Worldwide prosperity in recent years has led to a boom – and speculation – ...

Brazil Joins Organic Bandwagon

The Brazilian market for organic food has been steadily growing at 30% a year. ...