Clinton’s Visit Shows Brazil’s Foreign Minister Less Flexible on Iran than His Boss Lula

Hillary Clinton, Lula and Celso Amorim in BrasíliaUS Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton’s one-day visit to Brazil was dominated by one issue: the Iranian nuclear program. In the three meetings she had with Brazilian authorities the subject was discussed.

At the Congress, with the leaders of the two houses, Michel Temer (PMDB, São Paulo) president of the Chamber of Deputies, and José Sarney (PMDB, Amapá), president of the Senate; at Itamaraty with Foreign Minister, Celso Amorim; and with Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.

Speaking to the media before an Amorim-Hillary press conference, Lula adopted a flexible position with regard to the issue. “I just don’t think it is prudent to push Iran up against the wall. What I want for Iran is what I want for Brazil: the use and development of nuclear energy for peaceful ends. If Iran is in agreement with that, it can count on Brazilian support. If it wants to go beyond that, Iran will be doing something that is expressly prohibited in the Brazilian constitution. And that is something we cannot agree with,” declared Lula. The Brazilian constitution prohibits the development of nuclear arms.

At the joint press conference, standing next to Secretary Hillary, Celso Amorim declared that Brazil will not bow to pressure from the Unites States on the matter of the Iranian nuclear program. “We intend to think this out for ourselves. What we want is a world without nuclear weapons, certainly without proliferation of these arms. But we are not about to be pushed along by others. We will use our own heads and come to our own conclusions,” said the minister.

He then added that it is the position of the Brazilian government that there is a possibility of a negotiated agreement with the government of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. “The question is what is the best way to get to that goal. Are all the chances to negotiate exhausted? We believe there is still an opportunity to reach an agreement, maybe with a little more flexibility on the part of all those concerned,” concluded Amorim.

In her comments at the press conference, standing next to Amorim, Hillary declared the Ahmadinejad government has lied about the production of nuclear weapons. She stated that Iran tells a different story about what it is doing in each different place it goes, for example, in Brazil and at the International Atomic Energy Agency.

“What we have seen is that Iran goes to Brazil, China and Turkey and in each place tells a different story in order to escape sanctions. This matter continues to be examined by the United States,” said the Secretary. “President Obama has made gestures to Iran for more than a year and there has been no reciprocal signal.”

Hillary declared that the US was willing to negotiate with Iran but that the possibilities were limited because of a lack of interest on the part of Iran.

“An effort in favor of negotiations, in good faith, by Iran will be eagerly accepted. We desire a positive diplomatic outcome and with that goal in mind will continue to discuss this issue with Brazil.”

She said that it seemed that Iran would only negotiate in good faith when pressured by sanctions to do so, without going into detail as to exactly what the sanctions would be.

“I repeat that the US prefers negotiations to sanctions. Our door is always open. But when the international community as a whole gets behind a resolution for sanctions, we believe that only then will they negotiate.”

In her visit to the Brazilian Congress and meetings with the presidents of the two legislative houses, Clinton said the United States would like help from Brazil in dealing with the nuclear proliferation, the Iranian nuclear program and the new situation in Honduras.

As for Iran, Hillary pointed out to Temer and Sarney that Russia, China, England, France and Germany are all in favor of new sanctions because they are all convinced that the recent decision by Tehran to enrich uranium to 20% is part of a plan to build nuclear weapons. Iran denies this.

Hillary warned that Iran wants nuclear weapons not only to attack Israel, but to exert political pressure over the whole Middle East and especially the Arab nations. Hillary called on Brazil to join the effort to halt the proliferation of nuclear arms, according to José Sarney.

Hillary also spoke to the leaders of the Congress about Latin America and the need to overcome the conflict in Honduras by bringing an end to its domestic problems, an effort Brazil can and hopefully will be a part of, she told Temer and Sarney.



  • Show Comments (3)

  • hunh?

    Starker: thanks for that interesting info about A. Anyone who denies the holocaust and vows to wipe Israel off the map is a clearly a loose canon and a bit of a wakco, and capable of believing all the other wakcy things you mention. Green mist! More like a trail of blood follows this man. Mind you, I am not an apologist for the Israeli oppression of Palestinians as everyone assumes of anyone critical of Iran.
    If Lula is simply ignorant, then why is he always boasting about Brazil needs to take its place as a global leader. Before Brazil does this, will someone show your president how to access the BBC online in Portuguese so he can the obvious truth about this brutal regime that most sane people in the world easily grasp.

  • Starker

    I think you nailed it hunh, the Petrobras connection is clear, I hate to think though, to believe that Lula is not ignorant of the internal struggles of Iran. Ahmadimajad stated that ‘we once ruled the world and we will again’, the question is did he mean the ‘we’ as Persians or the ‘we’ as Mohammedans. When he was mayor of Tehran he widened the streets in anticipation of the return of Maghi and after his first UN speech he claimed to have been surrounded by a glowing green mist, even the mullahs were taken aback a bit when he related this experience to them, but it is clear he meant as ‘Mohammadans’. Students and others are trying desparately to free themselves from this madness, though many believe they will again be a world power as Persians, shedding the Arab ideology of Islam altogether. If Lula has any clue what is going on inside Iran, he is a hypocrit as you said, but I’m leaning toward him simply as being ignorant.

  • hunh?

    Ha-Ha! The ambassador claims that the other countries that are calling for sanctions against Iran if they don’t begin negotiating in good faith, reminds him of the smoke and mirrors about WMD in Iraq. What hogwash! This claim is smoke and mirrors aiming to deflect criticism from Brazil for trading with this regime that is not attempting to move towards developing nuclear weapons, but it really covers the true motives of Brazil in courting this repressive regime: Petrobras has millions of dollars in business in oil exploration in Iran. Brazilians were fond of criticizing the US for the Iraq war which was seemingly a blood for oil deal. While anyone criticizing this idiotic war was right, I would like to hear some of the same Brazilians now speak out against the blood for oil deals their own government is engaged in with Iran. The blood is that of the Iranians who are presently being beaten, tortured, executed and murdered for non-violently protesting the rigged elections of this illegitimate regime. Petrobras is making millions on this deal:

    Lula is a hypocrite and a coward for not condemning the atrocities of this regime, and instead he hugs and welcomes the dictator. Perhaps Brazilians have become so accustomed to corruption that they don’t see the hypocrisy in Lula’s alliance with regime for a business deal.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *


You May Also Like

Portugal Company Has Energy Plans for Brazil Including Wind Power

Portuguese energy sector company Energias de Portugal (EDP), is discussing with the Algerian Sonatrach ...

Brazil and the Jeitinho: A Cultural Lesson in Bahia

I couldn’t help to think about that word jeito. What sort of magical thing ...

On the Dunes Waiting for 2000

The pick-up truck I traveled in was held together with the requisite number of ...

Brazil President Opens UN General Assembly Warning Against Military Intervention

Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff arrived in New York, Sunday, September 23. According to the ...

Brazil Confesses Impotence Via-í -Vis Haiti

On 1 February 2005, nearly one year after the de-facto coup against Haiti’s democratically ...

World’s Best Player Is Brazilian Ronaldinho, Again

Brazilian soccer ace Ronaldinho Gaúcho won his second straight FIFA World Player of the ...

The Message Is Out: In Brazil, Sex Tourism Is a Crime

The non-governmental organization (NGO) "World Vision" launched, this week, a campaign with the objective ...

Brazil Takes Best Horses and Riders to Dubai

Brazil is going to participate in the Equestrian World Endurance Championship, to take place ...

British Government Promises Quick Compensation for Brazilian Killed in London

British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw promised compensation to the family of Jean Charles Menezes, ...

Lula Still Hopeful Brazil Will Grow 4% in 2009

The government of Brazil, despite the global economic crisis, is going to work for ...