Signing International Treaties Does Not Guarantee Social Rights for Brazilians

Brazilian sugarcane cutterEvery year some two million labor disputes wind their way through the Brazilian labor justice system which is parallel to the regular legal system and consists of 1,200 labor courts around the country.

According to Luciano Athayde, president of the National Association of Labor Justice Judges (“Magistrados”), there is a relation between the high number of cases and non-compliance with the laws that regulate relations between employer and employee.

Precarious situations exist in spite of Brazil being a signatory to over a dozen international labor conventions under the ILO (International Labor Organization), observes Athayde.

“This is not a lack of principles. The problem is that international norms are just not enough. The challenge is to make the law effective,” declared Athayde, speaking at the International Forum on Social Rights at the Superior Labor Court (“Tribunal Superior do Trabalho – TST”).

“The country just does not comply with the law. Brazil still struggles to make social rights a reality,” says Luciano Chaves, a labor court judge in Rio Grande do Norte, as he recalls a recent case involving a cowhand who herded cattle but was not paid – not any money.

Living with his grandfather and father in a “regime of servitude,” his “salary” consisted of one-sixth of the calves that were born in the herd – and nothing else.

An example of an ineffective law, says Luciano Athayde, is Convention 111 of the ILO, which was ratified by Brazil in 1964. It deals with discrimination in the workplace.

Data from the 2008 Household Survey (“Pesquisa Nacional de Amostra Domiciliar – PNAD/2008”) show that the Brazilian labor market treats different groups differently; for example, men and women, blacks and whites, and other groups.

Thus, the PNAD/2008 found that women earned 70,3% of what men made to do the same job; blacks got only 55.2% of what whites doing similar tasks received. The survey also found that black workers with the same educational level as white colleagues got 33% less pay.

Even at the highest levels discrimination was found. For example, black women with post graduate studies got 40% less pay than white women with similar educational levels.
Otávio Brito Lopes, a chief labor court prosecutor, says that “Brazil specializes in indirect discrimination.” The labor market strives to be politically correct, he says, while the statistics show that there is discrimination across the board, from hiring to promoting to firing, in all categories: gender and race.

Prejudice based on stereotypes is rampant. As the discrimination is undeclared, it is hard to prove in court. Another problem is cultural: the widespread and deeply rooted belief that Brazil is a racially harmonious nation. “Facing up to discrimination is not easy. We have to journey deep inside ourselves and confront our demons,” says the prosecutor.

Last year the Labor Prosecutor Office (“Procuradoria Geral do Trabalho”) lost five cases against big domestic banks in spite of proving empirically through data furnished by the banks themselves that there was discrimination.

“On one hand,” explains an exasperated Brito Lopes, “salaries paid to women and blacks were less than those paid to white doing the same work. On the other hand, white men got more promotions.”

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil Doesn’t Know the Arabs and Vice-Versa

The South American – Arab Countries Summit, which gets underway tomorrow, May 10, will ...

Brazilian Indians Granted Land on Indigenous People’s Day

Five indigenous lands had their bounds officially confirmed April 19, when the "Day of ...

In Brazil 85% of Internet Users Do Social Networking. Google’s Orkut Is King

Marketing research company comScore with headquarters in Reston, Virginia, a leader in measuring the ...

RAPIDINHAS

Brazilian Indians who learned the Portuguese and received some schooling are being expelled from ...

Brazil Tourism and Real Estate Look Overseas for Big and Small Investors

Companies from Brazil are seeking investment abroad for tourist and real estate projects in ...

US and China Skip Meeting of Soy Producing Brazil & Friends

Big soybean farmers from Brazil, neighbors and India, meeting in Paraguay agreed to create ...

Brazil: 3000 March on Brasí­lia Demanding Better Wages

About three thousand Brazilian workers are participating in the National Minimum Wage March.organized by ...

Elin, Swedish Voice & Brazilian Soul

This versatile multilingual vocalist was born in Sweden, but you would never know it ...

Brazil Earmarks US$ 420,000 for Drug Users’ Syringe Exchange

This week, Brazil’s Ministry of Health released norms on what is known as harm ...

Brazilian Trailer Maker Wants to Export US$ 170 Million in 2006

Randon, the Brazilian maker of highway implements, should end the year with growth of ...