Brazil Fines Left and Right But Collects Less than 4%

Brazil's Ibama It’s election season in Brazil. General elections are on October 3 and with its strict, rigid and detailed election laws, the country has seen fines for election law violations flying left and right.

A good moment for the Brazilian equivalent of the GAO (Tribunal de Contas da União – TCU) to release a report on just how much money the government collects from the fines it levies.

According to the TCU, between 2005 and 2009, federal inspection  agencies handed out over 518,000 fines with a nominal amount totaling almost 25 billion reais. But only 900 million reais effectively made it into the Treasury.

According to the author of the report, Raimundo Carreiro, a member of the TCU, that works out to a grand total of 3.7%.

Carreiro cites the case of the Environmental Protection Agency (Ibama) where the fines flew thick during the five-year period – a total of 14.7 billion reais – the highest in the government, but only 1% of the fines were actually collected.

Fraud in Financing

In a report on government finances, the Brazilian GAO (Tribunal de Contas da União – TCU) says that besides collecting little from the many fines it levies, the government has not been monitoring NGOs that have contracts for governmental services.

The TCU says it has discovered that this is a growing problem that is getting worse. Basically, NGOs receive public money but do not account for it in timely fashion.

According to the TCU, this was a problem with 5,546 contracts in 2006 involving a sum of around 2.8 billion reais. In 2009, the problem had spread to 6,132 contracts worth 4.5 billion reais..

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Bioclone, a Brazilian Company Cloning Fruit Trees

Have you ever considered the possibility of buying pineapples, bananas and sugarcane produced in ...

Brazil Cannot Agree on What Is Unproductive Land

One of the pillars of Brazil’s land reform program is the expropriation of unproductive ...

Brazilian Flood: 116 Dead and No Place to Rebuild

"This is the worst climatic tragedy of Santa Catarina's history," said governor Luiz Henrique ...

Super Cautious, Brazil’s Chancellor Says Ball Is at EU’s Court

Progress in trade talks at the 6th Ministerial Meeting of the World Trade Organization ...

The Pronoun Craftsman

One month later, solemnly, the youngster was married to the leftover sister. Eleven months ...

Brazilian Armed Forces Complain of Obsolete and Broken Equipment and Low Wages

Brazil's armed forces, the largest military in Latin America, are badly equipped, demoralized over ...

Another Social Leader Murdered in Brazil

Brazilian Daniel Soares da Costa Silva, a union leader member of the Rural Workers ...

Brazil’s 2006 Account Surplus Reaches US$ 2.5 Bi, 37% Less Than Last Year

Brazil’s foreign accounts continue on the upswing, and the country’s balance of payments, which ...

Brazilian Indians Avoid Amazon Dam, But There Are Other Threats

As the Rio Olympics get underway, Brazil has blocked the construction of a controversial ...