• Categories
  • Archives

In Brazil, Courts Are Way Out of Line Censoring and Punishing Journalists

Carlos Santos Brazilian freelance journalist and blogger Carlos Santos based in Mossoró, a town in Brazil’s northeastern state of Rio Grande do Norte, was ordered to pay 6,000 reais (3,600 euros) to charities for posting three allegedly defamatory comments about the town’s mayor, Fátima Rosado, on his blog ( http://www.blogdocarlossantos.com.br/ ).  

This sentence replaced the one originally imposed: a month and four days in prison for each of a total of four comments.
 
“I am under attack but I am all right,” Santos said, referring to the 27 or so prosecutions and nine arrest orders still pending against him as a result of defamation suits by local politicians and officials.

So far he has been convicted three times of criminal insult although in each case the sentence was reduced to a fine. He was acquitted in three other cases.

International freedom of information organization Reporters Without Borders says that it is disturbed by the way some courts in Brazil permit the use of multiple lawsuits and other abusive judicial procedures to censor journalists.
 
“The comments Santos posted on his blog could rightly be regarded as vehement even if two of them accused the mayor of being unfit for her job and the third one did not name anyone,” Reporters Without Borders said and added:

“The problem has firstly to do with the excessive number of lawsuits in response to each allegedly defamatory comment. Abusing the possibility of bringing defamation actions is a form of censorship. Secondly, imposing a jail sentence for a media offence violates the 1988 democratic constitution, which guarantees free expression in all forms.

“The federal supreme court’s repeal of the military dictatorship’s 1967 press law in May 2009 was a major step in ensuring respect for this right. It is baffling that some courts still issue jail sentences in defamation cases or impose preventive censorship on media. The federal constitution and jurisprudence should apply everywhere.”
 
Also in February, a judge in the northern state of Pará, Antônio Carlos Almeida Campelo, issued an injunction against Lúcio Flávio Pinto, the editor of the online and byweekly newspaper Jornal Pessoal, forbidding him to publish any information about a fax fraud case that the federal authorities have brought against O Liberal, a company that owns several regional newspapers.
 
If he disobeys the injunction, he could be jailed or fined up to 200,000 reais (US$ 120,000) on a charge of violating the confidentiality of a judicial investigation. Yet, according to Pinto, the injunction was not requested by the defendants.
 
Pinto is another example of a journalist who has been swamped by lawsuits. Around 30 legal actions have been brought against him over his articles about environmental abuses and trafficking in raw materials in the Amazon.
 
His case is similar to that of José Huerta, a documentary filmmaker who is the target of eight lawsuits – one of them a criminal prosecution – in connection with his latest documentary, which is about the perverse effects of tourism in the state of Ceará.

Tags:

  • Show Comments (1)

  • demonio do espaço

    yes indeed a shame on our contry, this is called “ditadura de toga”(don´t know how translate) and there are movements whith are aganist it, with “reforma judiciaria” reforms in laws, that will cease to exist, but since the ones who make laws are the ones who use it for own benefit…it´s gonna be hard…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil Never Saw Such Promising Economy, Says Lula

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva praised the government’s economic policy. In a ...

Brazil Expects Foreigners to Spend US$ 3.5 Billion During the World Cup

Brazil is expecting to receive 600,000 foreign tourists for the 2014 World Cup, an ...

70% of Brazil’s Capital Abroad Are in Fiscal Havens

Brazilian holdings overseas increased 14,6% in 2004 totalling 94,7 billion US dollars according to ...

In Brazil, Only 40% of Court Cases Are Judged in One Year or Less

The large number of legal appeals and the lack of organization and communication among ...

Brazil: Unions Pass the Hat to Pay Lula’s Fine for Violating Electoral Law

The Superior Electoral Tribunal of Brazil, the TSE, again fined Brazilian president Luiz Inácio ...

Floating Exchange Rate Is Here to Stay, Says Brazilian President

Nelson Barbosa, the executive secretary of Brazil’s Ministry of Finances, speaking at a seminar ...

Lula’s Popularity and Interests Fall, But Brazil Stock Hits Record High

Latin America collectively moved higher on the day, with Brazilian and Mexican markets hitting ...

Brazil’s 2006 Account Surplus Reaches US$ 2.5 Bi, 37% Less Than Last Year

Brazil’s foreign accounts continue on the upswing, and the country’s balance of payments, which ...

Rio, Brazil, on the Top of the Oil

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, is acting as the world petroleum capital from October 4-7. ...

Brazil: Lessons for Living

At the Maanaim Center, in São Paulo, children are expected to maintain personal and ...