Between a Saint and a Sinner in Laguna, Brazil

 Between a Saint and a Sinner in   Laguna, Brazil

Brazil never felt more like Spain or Italy. At the present time in Brazil, evangelical Protestantism is making deep inroads into Catholicism. Everybody seems excited and amused. A local man tells a miraculous story about a sixty year-old retired teacher who had rather suddenly gotten married. “The real miracle was that she was a virgin.”

By Terry Caesar

"The saint is coming!" This would be Santo Antônio, whose
image was being returned to the church where it resides 364 days of the year.
Only on his feast day, June 13, does the saint leave his home, to be kept
at another church (it varies each year) until nightfall.

I yelled when I glimpsed
a staff, wobbling off in the distance, over the heads of the hundreds of people
crowded into Laguna’s town square. The staff got closer. It turned out to
be pink, fluffy cotton candy. Everybody laughed, and renewed shuffling their
feet to keep warm.

Laguna is in Brazil, a
small city of some 70,000 on the coast of the southern state of Santa Catarina,
100 kilometers south of the state capital, Florianópolis. The whole
state is far enough south to get quite cold during winter; by June each year,
there is usually a report of snow somewhere.

Snow in Brazil? The surprise
only reveals how limited is our imagination of the huge country, which is
more typically defined by a Laguna rather than a Rio de Janeiro, and whose
rituals partake far more of Catholicism than samba or soccer.

History only happened
in Laguna once, in 1839. Brazil was still a Portuguese monarchy. But republican
sentiment was widespread. Of all people, Guiseppe Garibaldi appeared in Laguna,
among a group of secessionists from Rio Grande do Sul who had made their way
into Santa Catarina.

Their plan was to surprise
imperial forces by landing in Laguna’s harbor. In fact, an encounter failed
to take place, the insurgents declared a republic, and Garibaldi laid eyes
on Anita, the town beauty, who was married to a shoemaker.

She abandoned her husband,
joined Garibaldi, fought with him elsewhere in South America, continued the
fight when Garibaldi returned to Italy, and was pregnant with their fifth
child when she was killed during the Retreat from Rome in 1849.

But already we are far
afield from Laguna, where by some accounts Anita was not in fact even living
and her husband was actually a fisherman, not a shoemaker. No matter. The
story as it is told in Laguna is a good one. There is a statue of Anita—arm
upraised—at one end of the town square, entitled, "Heroine of Two

The Museum is named in
her honor, and her house is featured in tourist brochures. However, locals
may finally care no more about the historical Anita than they do the historical
St. Anthony, who is known throughout Brazil as the patron saint for those
who want to get married.

His feast day is recognized
during June along with St. Paul and St. John as part of the "Festa Junina"
festivities, where children dress up in straw hats and dirt-stained faces
and everybody celebrates the nation’s rural roots.

Excitement in the Air

Back to the saint’s immanent
reappearance. Distant firecrackers could be heard. More people milled about.
The chill in the air was sharp and deep. There were booths featuring saint’s
medals, others offering special vinhão, "big wine" (made
with water, sugar, ginger and cinnamon) or cakes made with corn.

Everybody seemed excited
and amused. A local man in our party told a miraculous story about a sixty
year-old retired teacher who had rather suddenly gotten married. "The
real miracle was that she was a virgin."

Two of my stepchildren
took digital pictures of themselves holding coins; each was in his or her
early 20s, unmarried, and therefore happy to conform to the legend that you
will marry the one you love if you deposit thirteen coins at the feet of the
saint on this night.

Brazil never felt more
like Spain or Italy. My Brazilian wife assured me that hundreds of Brazilian
towns and cities are similarly organized around feast days, enduring religious
rituals, and the entire liturgical year of the Church.

At the present time in
Brazil, evangelical Protestantism is making deep inroads into Catholicism
(which has developed an extensive "charismatic" movement in order
to counter it). Yet such a conflict felt as distant as Garibaldi’s this night
in Laguna, which, once again this year, simply is Laguna because of
its devotion to Santo Antônio.

A large statue of Nossa
Senhora da Glória stands on a hill above the town, rather like the
far more famous and immense statue of Christ atop Corcovado towers over Rio.
Only in Laguna, unlike Rio, everybody is pleased to be in some way comprehended
by the statue.

Time for Prayers

At last the saint appeared,
holding a baby Jesus in one hand and a cross in the other, bourne on a wooden
platform by a dozen men. Members of the saint’s fellowship, they were attired
in scarlet robes. Another group of men, similarly attired, preceded them.

Among these was the Governor
of Santa Catarina, no less, as well as his opponent. The Governor is reportedly
on his last legs, politically. Somebody joked about what the saint might be
being asked by him, while also being asked the same thing by the opponent.

Fireworks were going off
everywhere around us. The church bells were louder than the fireworks. The
air even began to feel warm. There was a small band-drums, trombones, flutes-behind
the saint.

They played a march by
John Phillip Sousa. How for an American not to think of the 4th
of July? Or at least some sort of American festival at some time during the
year, staged in thousands of towns and cities, based on some seasonal or historical
theme? This June 13th in Laguna was different, though, and demonstrated
the sheer power of religion to absorb all manner of social, cultural, and
political categories.

An effigy of Anita Garibaldi
would not have seemed out of place. Religion in Brazil is remarkably syncretistic,
even this far south. As for up north (where in fact the statue of the saint
was made, 250 years ago), I remembered a guide in the famous Church of São
Francisco in Salvador, Bahia, who once remarked, "We Brazilians are so
Catholic we don’t have to go to Church."

No Room to Move

Brazilians in Laguna are
perhaps less "Catholic," at least on the biggest night of the year.
The saint passed, we surged forward toward the entrance of the Church of Santo
Antônio. Then it was impossible to proceed farther.

It was barely possible
to get into a large building next door to the church, where special booths
had been set up across the ground floor, mostly offering food, drink, and
games. Off to the left I noticed a cute little contraption, consisting of
a tiny circling airplane, attached to a thin wire.

What could the exact game
have been? As well ask what the Church looked like inside, or even what music
would be played later in the square. Everything was too crowded. Our hostess
was eager for us to visit her home, have a drink, and watch a video of the
saint’s days past.

She had arranged for us
to stay at a hotel along the beach. Laguna has a nice one. Its historical
central area is lovely—a facade of colorful colonial buildings along
the waterfront with high windows and tile roofs, a warren of cobbled streets
in the center with old stone buildings in various states of preservation.

But if the town flourishes
it will be because of its beach, as clean, ample, and shapely as any in Brazil.
The trouble with the Santo Antônio festival is that it takes place during
the wrong season.

During winter, hotels
are empty and the beach is barren. In effect, Laguna is divided between its
major event, which is religious, and takes place almost exclusively for locals,
and its major source of income, which is touristic, and exists almost exclusively
for others.

The Church vs. the Beach.
The figure of Anita Garibaldi sits rather awkwardly in the middle. She was
no saint. There was some opposition thirty years ago to the erection of her
statue and there remains, it seems, plenty of sentiment in Laguna that denounces
her as a whore.

Yet a town does what it
can with its history, and it is invariably significant insofar as the history
participates in larger historical currents. (Hence, the loss of the railroad,
which limited Laguna’s economic development, is judged to be of no interest
to anybody else and receives no public representation.)

The trouble is, this history
in the case of Laguna has nothing to do with religion or tourism. And so the
story of Anita Garibaldi is fated to be "romantic" in a purely antiquarian

Meanwhile, the festival
of Santo Antônio continues to be an occasion for widespread devotion
in the strongest popular sense. The worst thing about the timing of the festival
may also be seen as the best thing, because it gives Laguna an annual reason
for being that has nothing to do with the tourism that takes place, several
kilometers away from the central square, later in spring and summer.

In this respect, the festival
of Santo Antônio reveals that, no matter how willing to trade on the
sun of its geographic favor or to exploit its modicum of historical accident,
a town does not have to sell its soul in order to remain spiritually alive.

Terry Caesar is the author of, most recently, a collection of essays on
academic life, Traveling Through the Boondocks. He has been traveling
to Brazil for some nineteen years, ever since he first arrived in Rio de
Janeiro on a Fulbright. He welcomes your comments at

You May Also Like

Brazil Criticizes US for Postponing Piracy Verdict

In a press release, April 4, Brazil’s Ministry of Foreign Relations made a comment ...

Brazilian Volunteers Teaching to Read Win UNESCO Award

A Brazilian educational project carried out in Curitiba, capital of the southern Brazilian state ...

Brazil Wants Free Trade Agreement with Japan and South Korea

More than 400 entrepreneurs will accompany Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on ...

Amnesty Urges Impartial and Prompt Inquiry on Brazilian Killing in London

Amnesty International is concerned about the incident on 22 July 2005 in which plainclothes ...

US Sends Trade Representative Schwab to Brazil to Revive Doha Talks

U.S. Trade Representative Susan C. Schwab will be in Brazil from July 27 to ...

Russia Approves All Experiments from First Brazilian Astronaut

The Brazilian Space Agency’s (AEB) manager of the Centennial Mission, Raimundo Nonato Mussi, reported ...

Brazil: Rio’s Drug Lords Knock Down Military Chopper and Kill Two Policemen

Rio de Janeiro's drug traffickers knocked down a police helicopter that was after them, ...

Brazil’s Varig Expands International Cargo Service with New Planes and Routes

Varig Log is expanding its fleet of aircraft and also its routes. The company ...

Brazil’s Child Labor: a Tradition Passed from Generation to Generation

“To force a child to work is to steal the future of that child.” ...

Brazil’s Petrobras Shares Grew 45% in New York in 2006

Brazil's mostly government owned oil corporation Petrobras celebrated this week its entry to the ...