African Union Rains on Brazil’s UN Parade

African leaders at special summit Thursday in the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa, sent a strong message to the United Nations that they want veto-wielding permanent seats on its security council.

After a day of debate and deal-making, the African Union rejected a compromise by Brazil, Germany, Japan and India, the G4, that would have given Africa two permanent seats without veto power on the U.N. security council.


Africa has long sought more representation on the world body.


Currently, the U.N. security council has 15 seats. Five are set aside for permanent members, the United States, Russia, China, France and Britain. The remaining 10 seats are reserved for other member-countries and rotate in two-year terms.


Brazil, Germany, Japan and India, countries that aspire to be permanent members of the security council, have sent delegates to the summit to urge African support for their proposal, which includes expanding the council to 25 members. That means adding 10 new members, six of them permanent seats without veto power: four for themselves and two for Africa.


The African Union’s plan is more ambitious. It calls for 11 new members, and would give veto power to the new permanent seats. Egypt, Nigeria and South Africa are being proposed for the two permanent seats for Africa.


Ross Herbert is the senior Africa analyst for the South African Institute for International Policy. He says it’s doubtful the often-fractious 53-nation African Union would ever give up its demand for permanent seats with veto power.


“The problem with the African plan is that they can’t choose [among] their three main contenders, Nigeria, South Africa and Egypt. So that’s partly why they wanted to have their compromise. That would be to two permanent members plus two other African members, which would leave whoever the odd-man-out of that trio would be, they would potentially be bought off with a rotating non-permanent seat,” he said.


Still, some Western nations have resisted expanding the Security Council to include permanent seats for African countries, especially if those seats include veto power.


Mr. Herbert says at issue is the risk of having on the Security Council countries that may become unstable or that cannot contribute either funds or troops to UN missions on the Council.


“That’s an argument that some people will make. Nigeria, if anything, is teetering on the brink and some day may end up collapsing. You put it on the Security Council and give it veto power, you kind of ensure eventually that when it does get into trouble, the U.N. will be unable to do anything about it.”


For the Group of Four nations to have any hope of getting permanent seats on the security council, they will need the approval of two-thirds of the 191 countries that make up the U.N. General Assembly. To do that, they are going to need massive support from the African Union.


VoA

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazilian Consumers Have Never Been So Confident

Brazilian consumers’ confidence in the economy and their own personal finances is on the ...

Pope Meets Brazilian Indians and Vows to Help Protect Their Land

Brazilian Indians Jacir José de Souza and Pierângela Nascimento da Cunha from the Makuxi ...

Richest Man in Africa Wants a Piece of Brazil

The chairman of the board of Wind Telecomunicazioni SpA and Orascom Telecom Holding SAE, ...

US Explains Brazil’s Record Corn Production: Second Harvests

The US Department of Agriculture says that Brazil’s increased success in second crops is ...

Stock Market Investors Grow But Investment Shrinks in Brazil

From July to August, the number of natural people investing in the São Paulo ...

Brazil: Ten Years After Landless Massacre Gunmen Still Have the Last Word

On 17 April 1996, military police began clearing landless protesters from the PA-150 highway ...

Brazil-Argentina-Paraguay Triple Border Fears Yellow Fever Epidemics

Since the confirmed yellow fever deaths of two jungle workers in the neighboring province ...

Despite Low GDP Brazil’s Economy Jumps from 15 to 11th Place in the World

Brazil became the leading Latinamerican economy in 2005, ahead of Mexico, and ranked eleventh ...

Brazilian Surplus Tumbles Due to Strong Import Growth

Brazilian exports totaled US$ 2.325 billion last week, 3.47% more than in the previous ...

Brazil Accuses US of Lying to the WTO on Amount of Farm Subsidies It Grants

The price of suspending the negotiations of the Doha Round in the World Trade ...