Brazilian Indians Win This Round. They Can Stay.

The chief justice of the Brazilian Supreme Court, Carlos Ayres Britto, suspended three repossession injunctions granted after possessory actions were filed with a federal court in Roraima. The decision was made at the request of the Federal Prosecution Service (MPF) and the National Indigenous Foundation (Funai).

The preliminary orders were aimed at removing indigenous peoples from the São Francisco, Jawari and Raposa/Serra do Sol communities at the request of rice farmers who invaded the land, and they were supposed to be executed as of October 29. After they were suspended, on October 28, the indigenous people were allowed to stay in the communities. 


The decision of Carlos Ayres Britto is similar to another one made by the chief justice which suspended the proceedings of a class action until a definition is reached as to what jurisdiction of the judiciary branch has the competence to make decisions about the official confirmation of the bounds of the Raposa/ Serra do Sol land.


This Class Action exists since 1999, but it was resumed in 2004, when Senator Mozarildo Cavalcante was included amongst its proponents. The Action is against the official confirmation of the bounds of the land as a continuous strip and it gave rise to the legal hindrances which prevent the official confirmation of the bounds of the Raposa/Serra do Sol land today.


The final decision on the jurisdiction to judge cases involving this indigenous land will only be made after the subject is voted on by the judges of the Supreme Court (STF).


The validity of the decisions made by the federal court of Roraima is being challenged based on a lawsuit filed by the Federal Prosecution Service with the Supreme Court in the form of a Complaint, a proceeding designed to preserve the competence of the Supreme Federal Court.


The Federal Prosecution Service argues that there is conflict of interests between the Federal Administration and the State of Roraima and, for this reason, the Supreme Court should be responsible for making decisions on the subject.


The arguments refer to the class action which was preliminarily accepted by the federal court of Roraima in 2004, according to which the assets of the State of Roraima would be harmed if the indigenous land is demarcated as a continuous strip.


Cimi ”“ Indianist Missionary Council
www.cimi.org.br

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazilian Fashion Gets California Touch for Next Summer

Brazilian stylist Faissal Makhoul is hoping for a hot summer in 2009. To create ...

US Inflation Brings Brazilian Stocks Tumbling Down

Brazilian stocks plummeted, in line with the U.S. market, as investors reacted to disappointing ...

Brazil and Canada Patching Up Old Rivalries

Following the official visit of Russian President Vladimir Putin, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula ...

Brazil Wants Bigger Role for Emerging Nations in Internet’s Management

Egypt has just hosted the 33rd meeting of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names ...

Brazil Demands End to Farm Subsidies at G-3, G-4 and G-6 in London

Brazil’s Minister of Foreign Relations, Celso Amorim, has spoken at the London School of ...

Half of Brazil’s 34 Million Youth Are Out of School

With over 34 million people between the ages of 15 and 24, Brazil has ...

Brazil Urges Prompt Compensation and Return of Brazilian Killed by British Police

The Brazilian Bar Association released a note condemning the assassination of the Brazilian citizen, ...

Brazil Air Tragedy: US Pilots Talk. Where Were the Controllers, They Ask

More than two months and a half after Brazil’s deadliest air accident ever and ...

More than 200 Brazilian Tourists Still Stranded in Machu Picchu, Peru

Among an estimated 2,000 foreign tourists trapped in the area around Machu Picchu in ...

America is bad, Brazil is worse

Since we’ve published in our January issue “America, the Ugly”, an interview with Ana ...