Lula’s Absence and Corruption Dominate Brazil’s Last Presidential Debate

Alckmin, Helena and Buarque on Globo TV. Lula's absence in represented by an empty stand with his name.As he had done in all previous presidential TV debates this election, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva didn’t show up for the last one last night.

He didn’t have to. As expected he became the favorite target of the other three candidates who ended up directing their questions and frustration to an empty stand with a plate with Lula’s name.

Soon after the debate, which ended after midnight, senator Cristovam Buarque, one of the candidates in the encounter called Lula’s absence a disrespect to public opinion, to the other candidates and to the young Workers Party backers.

Why doesn’t Lula come to the debate he asked and immediately answered himself: "He doesn’t come because he has nothing to show and because he wants to hide."

Like Buarque the other two candidates – former São Paulo governor Geraldo Alckmin (PSDB) and senator Heloí­sa Helena (PSOL) – several times addressed the empty stand where Lula was supposed to be and demanded explanations about old and new corruption scandals that occurred to his party and during his government.

In his first intervention Alckmin called Lula’s absence "not a disrespect to me as a candidate, but to the voter." Buarque echoed the same feeling calling it an "aggression against democracy.

The whole day Lula had maintained the suspense if he would participate or not in the debate. Several newspapers even announced that he had decided to go to the TV encounter.

The final word with an official letter turning down Globo’s invitation came around 7 pm, about 3 hours before the start of the debate.

The hope of the other candidates is that the television discussion will force Lula to a runoff. The hope of Lula is that his absence will guarantee that he wins on the first round, Sunday, October 1st, as all polls have been predicting for months.

The scandal theme was explored extensively by the three candidates.  Alckmin stated that scandals had become an everyday scourge in the Workers Party government implicating several close aides to the president.

Heloí­sa Helena was the harshest of the three in her attacks: "I, in my house, teach my kids to not steal. It is a shame that the president is not here to explain how he does exactly the opposite, at his home, his party and his government."

As for programs, Cristovam Buarque, always the dreamer. asked for a "revolution" through education. Alckmin talked about a "management shock," which would make the state more efficient. Helena, on the other hand, preached morality and an immediate cut in interest rates. This would allow the government to invest more in social programs, she reasoned.

The debate was for the most part well mannered verging on boring. Only Heloí­sa Helena showed some passion mainly when attacking the policies of both Lula and his predecessor Fernando Henrique Cardoso. For all this criticism against Lula, Buarque was always the gentleman finding points in common between himself and the other two candidates. 

In one of the few fiery moments, Helena told the audience referring to president Lula: "He had the obligation to get down from his throne of corruption, arrogance and political cowardice to be here to answer to the Brazilian people. But I also know that he is not  here because he does not have the moral authority to face me. I survived his implacable persecution. I was born like him, in a humble family, in the interior of Alagoas, a northeastern like him, but in contrast to what he did,  I haven’t sold out my origin class."

The senator, who was expelled from the PT, went on accusing Lula of heading a gang installed in the presidential office, the Palácio do Planalto. "Inside the PT there are still honest, socialist militants, who are embarrassed by the criminal organization structure headed by the President of the Republic, which is able to annihilate anyone who might threaten his power project."

Cristovam Buarque during the whole debate including the final considerations addressed the electorate asking them to do everything to avoid a first-round victory for Lula.

He had started the debate talking to the empty space where Lula was supposed to be: "You are a candidate under strong suspicions of using public funds and other resources whose origin is a mystery in the electoral process. If you are elected and the suspicions are proved, will you resign from your position?"


  • Show Comments (4)

  • heyhey

    HERE!! they distribute stupid grants

  • heyhey

    How… how…

    Aham, shouldnˢ۪t you be the last ones to give an opinion on this area??

    Tell me how your president was able to manipulate the American electorate.They distribute À¢€œcestas bÀƒ¡sicasÀ¢€Â and government grants to produce a movie, a cultural show. I guess people want bread and show around brazil, not that it is not bad, food for the body, food for the soul. People who are voting him are feeling compensated by this patriarchal and assistentialist muuuuy amigo govern, and they are also dam blind pathetic puppets of the beardy frog, shallowly following him. Hey, these people cannot complain over their pathetic lives, and thatÀ¢€™s a good end for them!!!! Anyways, public employees, the artistic class which receives funds from govt are, in a fair way, the ones to blame for this happening. Forget about the real poorsÀ¢€¦ what they know?

  • Guest

    Can the people of Brazil re-elect such a president. A man that doesn’t even give respect to his electorates and the people that put him into office.

    The only thing I can say, is that if Lula is re-elected, the brazilian population have demonstrated their ignorance and acceptance of the foxes running the henhouse!

  • bitter ex pat

    I hear the military tanks firing up. Lula, take a quick look to Thailand. You day is coming.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

Brazil’s Lula and Bush Should End Their War

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is the most traveled of all Brazilian ...

ILO Praises the Way Brazil Is Dealing with Slave Labor

The “Global Alliance Against Slave Labor” report affirms that measures taken by the Brazilian ...

Amazon Countries Look for Power in Brazil Meeting

The Continental Amazon will be the theme of the VIII Meeting of Foreign Ministers ...

Brazil and Arabs Strengthen Economic Ties Through Fairs

The Arab Brazilian Chamber of Commerce is going to participate in at least 12 ...

A Brazilian Ant With a Christian Message for the Whole World

Smilingüido is an ant that lives with his friends in the anthill of the ...

Brazil: Children’s Rights Are Just a Legal Fiction

Some jurists regard Brazil’s constitutional and statutory protection as a model for the world ...

Brazil’s Embraer Delivered 148 Jets in 2004

Brazilian aircraft manufacturer Embraer delivered last year 148 aircrafts, out of which 134 were ...

US’s Executive AirShare Orders Five Additional Brazilian Phenom Jets

Brazilian aircraft manufacturer Embraer has signed Executive AirShare, of Kansas City, Missouri, to a ...

Venezuela-Brazil Gas Pipeline Is More Like a Pipe Dream

The Pharaonic trans-Amazon natural gas conduit whose concept was approved amid much fanfare by ...


Those women dressed in tight clothes are now sambaing, vigorously. The whole place has ...