Brazil and US Waiting for the Other to Blink First on WTO Talks

Brazilian Foreign Minister, Celso Amorim Brazil signaled this week it would take a tough stance in talks to save a global trade deal saying last-ditch compromise proposals were too weighted in favor of rich-country interests. Brazilian Foreign Minister Celso Amorim also criticized the US for saying it would not discuss the kind of cuts to US farm subsidies that many poor countries are seeking.

Amorim was speaking after World Trade Organization (WTO) mediators in Geneva floated compromise proposals in a bid to rescue the WTO struggling Doha round of negotiations for a global free trade deal.

"I think the texts have defects," Amorim told reporters in Brussels after meeting EU Trade Commissioner, Peter Mandelson, in his first comments on the compromise proposals. "I think they are more ambitious on (industrial goods) than they are on agriculture."

Brazil and other developing countries are seeking to bring down barriers in rich countries to their farm exports. But they are concerned about opening up their markets to imports of industrial goods such as cars or chemicals.

The compromise texts included detailed ranges of cuts to farm subsidies and import tariffs for countries around the world, including a proposed range of 13/16.4 billion US dollars for a ceiling on US farm subsidies. The plan was worked out by Crawford Falconer, who chairs WTO agriculture negotiations.

Brazil and other developing countries are seeking a ceiling of 12 billion a year. But a US government official said that cutting US farm subsidies to 13 billion a year was "unacceptable".

The US spent approximately 12 billion on farm subsidies in the past few years, but argued that the new framework for world trade talks could rob farmers of a buffer to weather changes in crop prices.

"All it takes is a drop in corn prices, and all of a sudden you're looking at such large outlays" that might push crop supports beyond that kind of limit, said the Bush administration official.

The Bush administration has long said it could make deeper cuts if and only if other countries reduce tariffs sufficiently. While the US position has been that Falconer's latest text laid out encouraging areas of consensus among WTO members, the plan is faulted as having a "balance issue".

Brazil's Amorim anticipated that "if this scenario proves true, there won't be much negotiating", adding that "it's a shame if they (US) said that".

WTO countries are due to discuss the new negotiating proposals next week in Geneva.

Mercopress

Tags:

  • Show Comments (2)

  • forrest Brown

    okay we blink
    then all the farmers in the US would have to grow crops on the land they are paid not to grow crops on .

    after the first harvest the bottom falls out of the corn as we grow more per acher than brasil does per 1/2 kl
    then the rice , wheat , soy bean , mase, hops , barley,

    chicken meat , beef , pork , turkey ,

    and how about the sugar cain ,

    brasil may beat us on bananas , cocnut , and a few tropicals
    but the amercian fruit company has its hands all over the world

    do you want distory your countrys ability to sell food grains all over the world

  • ch.c.

    Your minister is simply….STUPID !!!
    1) “The US spent approximately 12 billion on farm subsidies in the past few years”
    – Therefore why Brazil sent a complaint letter jus a week or so ago, saying the amount the USA subsidizes is at….US$ 19 billions ?????

    2) Brazil is much more closed and has much much higher imports tariffs tha the USA and the EU in regard to Industrial goods and Financial services. It also happens than these 2 industries are much much bigger than agriculture…..EVFN IN BRAZIL !!!!!

    Wihtout an equivalent reciprocity from Brazil and other developing countries…..doubtful there would be a deal….from the developed nations !

    Bear in mind that already 50 % of your trade surplus is done with the USA and EU……ALONE !!!!!!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Amnesty Calls Brazil Friendly But Lax in Solving Human Rights Problems

Amnesty International is submitting this briefing to the United Nations Human Rights Committee (HRC), ...

Brazil’s Lula Races Ahead, But Alckmin Says He Will Keep the Mike Tyson Style

Geraldo Alckmin, the opposition candidate running against President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in ...

Brazil Yanomami Accuse Gold Miners of Bringing Disease and Killing Their Fish

In a letter denouncing the invasion of their land by illegal garimpeiros (gold miners) ...

Brazilian Minister Rushes to Geneva in Effort to Break WTO’s Stalemate

Brazil’s Minister of Foreign Relations, Celso Amorim, will travel to Geneva this weekend in ...

Brazil Wants to Export Eco-Electric Shower

Brazil's KL Telecom, a company located in Santa Rita do Sapucaí­, in the Brazilian ...

Animal Feed Factory from Brazil Expands

BioBase Animal Feed has expanded its factory in Àguas Frias, in the interior of ...

Foot and Mouth Disease Hits Brazil with Close to US$ 2 Billion in Losses

Foot and mouth export losses are estimated to reach US$ 1.7 billion given the ...

Helping Hand

By Brazzil Magazine What is being done to help favela residents in Brazil and ...

Brazil, First to Test in Space Germination of Tropical Plant

Brazilian researchers may better understand the biological processes of plants after the trip that ...