Brazil May Appeal to WTO to Overturn European Ban on Its Beef

Brazil is the world's largest beef exporter The Brazilian government on Tuesday, February 5, sharply criticized the European Union's decision to temporarily ban Brazil's beef imports and warned it could file a complaint with the World Trade Organization.

The criticism and warning are contained in a letter delivered Tuesday to the WTO's General Council by Clodoaldo Hugueney, Brazil's ambassador to that body. The letter was posted on the Brazilian foreign ministry' Web site.

On Jan. 30, the European Union said it would stop importing Brazilian beef because it does not accept Brazilian cattle health checks for foot-and-mouth disease and because Brazil had supposedly failed to create a new livestock tracking system.

Foot-and-mouth disease, which also strikes other cloven-hoofed animals like sheep, pigs and goats, is a viral illness that can be spread through even minimal contact with infected animals, farm equipment or meat. It can be fatal to animals, but does not harm humans.

"The Brazilian government regrets the decision of the European Commission to temporarily suspend exports of beef to the European market," Hugueney said in his letter. "The decision is, in our view, unjustified, arbitrary and disproportionate."

He hinted that the decision was taken to serve the interests of European producers.

He said he hoped Brazilian and European authorities would work out some kind of agreement that would end the ban, but added: "We reserve, however, our right to defend our interests in the SPS Committee (that monitors health and food safety standards) and in other bodies of the World Trade Organization.

Brazil is the world's leading beef exporter and the EU is the country's leading market. According to the Agência Brasil, the government's news service, Brazil exports 2.3 million tons of beef per year.

In 2006, the EU imported 327,000 tons of Brazilian beef worth US$ 1.4 million.



  • Show Comments (1)

  • ch.c.

    “and the EU is the country’s leading market”
    Better yet……
    “Europeans already pay well over US$5,000 (À¢‚¬3,385) per metric ton for Brazilian beef, far higher than the average US$2,000 (À¢‚¬1,354) paid by Brazil’s leading markets, Egypt and Russia, according to the Brazilian Beef Exporters Association, or Abiec.”

    And of course Brazil was not happy and continued to cheat, hide and lie :

    “Brazilian farms would be added to an EU-approved list once European health safety inspectors were sure that they met strict standards. In some case EU officials will have to check the farms themselves.
    He said the EU was worried about the “very large number” of disease-free farms Brazil had put forward because officials did not think “all these have been individually inspected and certified.”
    In some case EU officials will have to check the farms themselves.
    From Jan. 31, only beef from a list of approved farms in Brazil that meet EU animal health standards can be exported to Europe, the world’s richest consumer market. Beef shipped before Thursday will be accepted until March 15.
    The EU demands cattle must be disease-free and located in a foot-and-mouth-free state 90 days prior to slaughter if the meat is to be exported to the EU.
    The slaughter must be in an facility approved by the EU, and only matured and de-boned meat is allowed for export.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

For the First Time, Brazilian Indians Have Chance to Shape Own Policy

Brazilian Indians themselves will show the way to a better Indianist policy. According to ...

Pssst! Wanna Buy a Brazilian Franchise?

Brazilian franchises will get federal government support to expand to international markets. A group ...

Brazilian Indians Granted Land on Indigenous People’s Day

Five indigenous lands had their bounds officially confirmed April 19, when the "Day of ...

Brazil University Gets LatAm’s Largest Shared-Memory Supercomputer

Brazil's Universidade Federal do ABC (UFABC) recently purchased a high-performance computer and storage system ...

Brazil Offers ‘New Geography of Trade’

São Paulo is getting ready for the UN Conference on Trade and Development. The ...

Promising Land

Rancharia is 1 of 49 special projects in the state of Bahia supporting 2,250 ...

The Frying of a Black Minister in Brazil

What the Lula administration wants is Minister Benedita da Silva’s seat, but they avoid ...

São Paulo city

37% of All Brazilians Live in Six Cities

27.2% of the 5,507 municipalities in Brazil lost population between 1991 and 2000. On ...

Indian Assassination Has Doubled in Brazil from 20 to 40 a Year

The extreme social exclusion and lack of government actions for truly protecting the rights ...

Lula Is Supposed to Defend Brazil. Instead He’s Been on Bolivia’s Side

Brazil’s president came under fire from critics who say he caved into pressure from ...