• Categories
  • Archives

For Women Brazil Is a Paradise. A Shame It’s Only on Paper.

Violence against women in BrazilBrazil’s legal protection of women’s rights has been praised by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights as ‘unprecedented’ and an ‘influential model’ to be imitated by all nations. While the Brazilian Constitution says that everybody must have the same basic rights, other laws provide prison penalties and fines for any situation of sexist behaviour, including the use of pejorative terms against women.

The law of the land also provides special police stations only for women, offering them specific services such as psychological counseling for victims of domestic violence, hospital treatment for victims of rape, and investigation of any crime against women.

Despite the written law, it is well known by everybody that violence against Brazilian women occurs with frequency. A 2004 document released by the UN-Habitat reveals that Brazil has one of the highest levels of incidents described as rape, attempted rape, and indecent assault against women in the world. The report also states that such violent crimes are usually underreported, and the perpetrators unlikely to be punished.

A 2001 study of 61.5 million women carried out by the Perseu Abramo Foundation found that every year 2.1 million Brazilian women are victims of physical violence. This means that every 15 seconds a woman is beaten in Brazil. It also reveals that 6.8 million Brazilian women have suffered from beatings by their partners, relatives, and other acquaintances.

In 2004 alone, explains Health Minister Saraiva Felipe, 189,000 Brazilian women over the age of 10 had been admitted to hospitals with fractures, dislocations, and traumas to various parts of the body, including the skull.

The vast majority of criminal complaints related to violence against women in Brazil have been suspended without final conclusion. A 2002 document of the World Organization Against Torture (WOAT) explains that only 2% of such complaints have led to any conviction. As for those few cases resulting in conviction, the WOAT complains that the punishment for first-degree murder and rape were ‘very light’.

According to Norma Kyriakos, a Brazilian lawyer and former attorney-general of São Paulo state, “instead of giving him [the criminal] community service [or jail sentence], judges [often] propose he pays for a basket of food or other goods for a charitable institution.

And so the man keeps doing it because he knows that’s all he’ll have to pay… Women today are still afraid to go to the police because they are afraid of their attackers… They know that when they are finished here with the delegada [i.e.; female chief police] or judge they are on their own again”.

A case which serves to illustrate the current situation occurred in 1983. The case is about a woman who was left paraplegic after suffering several murder attempts by her husband. After waiting more than 15 years for any judicial decision, she then filed a lawsuit against the country with the Inter-American Human Rights Commission. In 2001, members of this commission judged the government of Brazil guilty of negligence, omission, and tolerance with respect to domestic violence against women.

In relation to the working rights of women, the 1988 Constitution explicitly forbids any salary differentiation between the sexes. Actually, the basic law actually provides ‘positive discrimination’ in favour of working women, granting them special constitutional rights such as three months’ paid maternity leave and protection against dismissal for pregnancy.

In practice, however, the Organization of American States (OAS) reports that women bearing children have been dismissed in Brazil regardless of legislation to the contrary. The report suggests that some employers have illegally required ‘proof of sterilization’ as a pre-condition for women to be employed.

Finally, the OAS maintains that even the government itself openly recognizes that the average salary of women is 54% below what is normally paid to male counterparts possessing similar levels of education and qualification.

The constant violation of women’s rights highlights the prevalence of a ‘macho’ culture where Brazilian men are expected to ‘prove’ their ‘masculinity’ by treating women as mere sexual objects. A major problem for the application of these rights is associated with the extra-legal, sociological fact that many men in Brazil “believe they have the right to physically dominate their partners, and many women accept a submissive role”.

This ‘macho’ culture may help to explain the proliferation of sexual violence, unstable unions, adultery, and illegitimacy, as factors that might naturally lead to the widespread violation of women’s rights.

Augusto Zimmermann is a Brazilian Law Professor and the author of the well-known books Teoria Geral do Federalismo Democrático (General Theory of Democratic Federalism – Second Edition, 2005) and Curso de Direito Constitutional (Course on Constitutional Law, Fourth Edition – 2005). His e-mail is: augzimmer@hotmail.com.

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Low Interests Rates in Brazil Only After Inflation Is Under Control

Having inflation under control is an essential prerequisite for financial investors to accept a ...

This Brazilian’s Passion for Flowers Bloomed into a Prosperous Business

Flower grower Eulália Farrath manages a flower and ornamental plant production farm in the ...

Hillary Clinton Asks Brazil to Join US Against Iran and in Favor of Honduras

US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, in a visit to the Brazilian Congress said ...

Brazil Sees Itself as Model of Dealing with Youth

The governments of Brazil, Venezuela, and Argentina intend to establish joint actions for youth. ...

Brazilian Congress Probes Corruption Charges in the Postal Service

Brazil’s Post Office CPI (Congressional Investigative Commission), which is investigating charges of corruption in ...

Brazilian Fashion Expected to Grow 15% in 2005

The sixth edition of Fashion Business, an exchange mart for Brazilian fashion, was officially ...

Brazil and Chile Discuss Human Rights

President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is in Chile to discuss accords in the ...

Downtown Blues

Pátio do Colégio: São Paulo, the third largest city in the world, was born ...

Rio Never Was Paris

Rio is no longer Brazil’s federal capital and the city has gone to seed. ...

Emirates Plunk Over 300 Million in Santander Brazil

United Arab Emirates' Aabar Investments PJSC, announced it is investing US$ 328 million in ...