Lula or Cardoso? Who Should Get the Credit for a Better Brazil?

Cardoso and LulaEver since Brazilian president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva took office in 2003 this argument has been going on. Have things improved in Brazil because of policies and decisions Lula made? Or have things improved because there was a continuation of policies begun in the Fernando Henrique Cardoso administration?

It looks like the question will be one of the central issues in this year’s presidential election as it shapes up more and more like a battle pitting the PT (Lula’s Workers Party) against the PSDB (FHC’s Party of the Brazilian Social Democracy).

In an interview in Porto Alegre for the newspaper, Jornal do Comércio, Lula declared that it was incorrect to say that the success of his administration was due to just continuing the policies of Fernando Henrique.

According to the president, those policies would have been insufficient for his administration to have achieved the levels of accomplishment it has. Nor would the country, following only the FHC economic financial standards, have been able to come out of the international financial crisis in such good shape, said he.

“As a matter of fact, you can see that following the policies of the three pillars of FHC economic policy (floating exchange rate, inflation targets and primary surplus) Brazil did go broke in a crisis [1999] and had to get help from the International Monetary Fund,” Lula pointed out.

Lula explained that improvements in the economic policies he inherited from the previous administration were fundamental to his government’s good performance. He said, for example, that the maintenance of the floating exchange rate was combined with the accumulation of international reserves in such a way that it reduced the country’s vulnerability to external turbulence, “enabling us to respond quickly to the financial crisis.”

Lula said another improvement was in setting credible and adequate inflation targets coupled with the Accelerated Growth Program (PAC), with the result that interest rates have come down as the economy expanded.

Lula pointed that as for fiscal policy, starting in 2003 his administration decided to link primary surpluses with programs that transferred income to poor families, creating a mass consumer market that began to receive government spending.

“These are people who never got a cent of government money. Today these people, a third of the population, are taken into consideration. In the past, governments only operated to benefit a different third of the people, the ones in the upper levels. They did not care about the rest.”

According to the president, income redistribution in the direction of the poor is more than a question of social justice and basic rights. It creates a consumer market, boosts production and stimulates commerce.

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (2)

  • denny

    Brazil benefited from focused leadership and sensible policies by both presidents.The country has the capacity to take on more credit but must make sure it’s on the books to avoid problems like U.S.,europe,japan have.

  • Capnamerca

    From what I see . . .
    The economy is being stimulated more by credit and usury interest rates than anything else. Beware of the use of credit to control the economy. Don’t think I know what I’m saying? Just look at the United States.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil 101

Question: "Is Brazil all it’s cracked up to be?" By Philip Blazdell Dear Mr. ...

Brazilian Company Brings Intelligent Showers, Bathtubs and Locks to Miami

Brazil's I-House, The Innovative House, a manufacturer of high technology equipment for households based ...

Brazilian Study Shows That Humans Kept Animal Freezing Instinct

Standing still when a threat is detected is a defensive, protective reaction. This ancestral ...

Sí£o Paulo, Brazil, Turns 453 and Gets 453-Meters-Long Cake

South America's largest and most dynamic city, São Paulo, in southeastern Brazil, celebrated this ...

Brazil Ventures into Space with a Little Help from Russia, China and France

In 2006 Marcos Pontes, a Lieutenant Colonel in the Brazilian Air Force, became the ...

In Spite of Everything Brazilians Must Keep the Dream Alive

In the past, we ran risks and we had objectives. Now, there are no ...

October 1994

CONTENTS: Cover story: Population: slowing the pace (p. 8) Minister talks too much (p.14) ...

Brazil’s Supreme Refuses to Order Arrest of Adman Involved in Vote-Buying Scheme

Brazil’s president of the Federal Supreme Court (STF), Minister Nelson Jobin, denied yesterday a ...

Brazil’s Associados Enlists U.S.-AdStar to Spice Up Advertising

U.S.-based AdStar, a leading application service provider for the classified advertising industry, announced that ...

Forever Tunes

Producer Ricardo Cravo Alvim thinks that marchinhas resist because they were created with the ...