Brasília’s Governor Bad Season: Supreme Keeps Him in Jail and Impeachment Starts

Federal District's governor José ArrudaBrazil’s Supreme Court on Thursday voted 9 to 1 to keep the governor of the Federal District, José Roberto Arruda, in jail, denying his lawyer’s second writ of habeas corpus in a case in which Arruda and others are accused of trying to bribe a witness in a Federal Police investigation known as Pandora’s Box.

Three weeks ago the federal appellate court (STJ) ordered Arruda and five others to be incarcerated acting on a lawsuit brought by the chief federal prosecutor and a government attorney following the release of a videotape showing the bribery attempt.

At that time, a first habeas corpus was denied by a single Supreme Court justice (on emergency duty) who, among other things, declared that it was not necessary for two-thirds of the local Federal District Legislative Assembly (CLDF) to give prior approval before the governor could be imprisoned even though this is in the Federal District constitution.

Interestingly, the only vote against denying habeas corpus yesterday was based on the opinion that there is a need to follow Federal District legislation, which requires approval of a two-thirds majority of the CLDF to imprison the governor. The contrary vote was by the newest member of the court, justice Dias Toffoli.

In a verbal opinion against Toffoli’s reasoning, justice Carmen Lucia declared that the temporary imprisonment of Arruda was absolutely necessary for the continuation of Pandora’s Box investigations.

Arruda’s lawyer, Nelio Machado, said his client was the victim of a moral lynching. And that his arrest was “an unnameable violence,” and that since his imprisonment he has received “disparate and unequal” treatment in court.

Machado went on to say that the arrest of Arruda was the result of a “plot” hatched between the appellate court (STJ) and government prosecutors. That accusation was denied by the deputy chief prosecutor, Deborah Duprat, who pointed out that since the governor’s arrest new evidence in the case has been uncovered.

Impeachment Authorized

There were only 19 deputies present Thursday for the vote on the impeachment motion against governor José Roberto Arruda (five deputies were absent). But when the vote took place it was a total reversal of fortune for Arruda: all 19 voted in favor of the motion.

Just a short time ago Arruda was a governor with 19 allies in the assembly. As of now, the bureaucratic machinery goes into motion, a timetable is in operation and there are specific deadlines. First, Arruda’s lawyers have 20 days to present the governor’s defense.

If the motion makes it through the next stages, including a special committee, it will go to the floor of the assembly where, in a final vote, it must get approval of 16 deputies to be passed.

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

In Brazil Nepotism Never Dies

There are an estimated 20,000 "positions of trust" in the Lula administration and according ...

500 Years of Inquietude

Francisco Julião used to defend agrarian reform forcefully arguing that it had to be ...

Brazil Sends Hollywood Movie on Homosexuality to Vie for an Oscar

The Way He Looks (Hoje Eu Quero Voltar Sozinho, in the original Portuguese), directed ...

Law and Reprisals Make Brazil’s Freedom of Press Ranking Low

Brazil ranks 63 in the Reporters Without Borders fourth annual World Press Freedom Index. ...

Brazil Says Stopping WTO Talks Wasn’t Their Decision

Negotiations among four key World Trade Organization (WTO) governments over a new global agreement ...

Sanitation policies will receive support from PAHO

Measures to provide all Brazilian homes with access to public water and sewage systems ...

Tears and Laments Won’t Help Relations, Brazil Tells Argentina

The recent Argentinean Industrial Union’s (UIA) call for changes in the Mercosur’s trade rules ...

Brazil: Alleged Killer of US Nun Says He Acted in Self-Defense

The man accused of killing American nun and rain forest defender Dorothy Stang told ...

Brazilian and US Scientists Get Inside and Promising Look of Degenerative Brain Disease

Scientists for the first time have watched agents of brain-wasting diseases, called transmissible spongiform ...

Brazil Embraer’s Sales Double

Brazil’s aircraft manufacturer Embraer net sales increased by 113.5% during the third quarter this ...