David Goldman Wins Another One in a Brazilian Court. The Lins e Silvas Must Pay Costs

David GoldmanAnother scene of the drama involving American David Goldman and his son Sean who was taken from by the mother when the boy was 4 to live in Brazil unfolded in a Brazilian court. Goldman won a lawsuit in which the Brazilian family wanted money for all the American’s alleged badmouthing about them.

Sean’s stepfather, Brazilian João Paulo Lins e Silva, a very rich and famous lawyer and his father, Paulo Malta Lins e Silva, also a lawyer, had filed a lawsuit against Goldman asking for compensation for moral damages. A Rio court denied the request.

The decision, which can still be appealed, was taken by Rio de Janeiro’s 13th Civil Court. The plaintiffs were sentenced to pay court costs plus attorney’s fees fixed in 20% of the cause’s value.

In the lawsuit the Lins e Silvas argued the “good image of the lawyers” was damaged by the “irresponsible and inappropriate behavior” of Goldman, who “did all he could to make the lives of the authors into a real hell.” They complained Goldman had called Sean’s Brazilian family kidnappers.

Sean family in Brazil said also that the website maintained by Goldman Bring Sean Home hurts does harm to the Lins e Silvas’ honor with its “clear intention of collecting money.”

The lawsuit text supports the argument that the Bring Sean Home campaign made by Goldman and his friends on the Internet was a direct and aggressive attack against the Lins e Silva family and Brazil’s whole justice institution.

Father and son also say that Goldman’s campaign to get his son back ended up harming their legal career. Paulo Lins e Silva noted that the organizers of a conference in Buenos Aires, Argentina, canceled his participation as a speaker after he appeared in the news.

Goldman’s defense argued that the site Bring Sean Home was not created by him but by friends who were touched by his struggle to get his son back to the United States. On the interviews to the press, the defense argued that the authors didn’t present any content that could prove the “violation of honor.”

In its decision the court observed that there is no evidence that Goldman’s campaign had anything to do with the cancellation. Judge Ledir Dias de Araújo said that most likely the reason was that Lins e Silva was considered as someone who lacked exemption to make a speech since he was experiencing in his own life a theme he was going to discuss.

Araújo also wrote that “much of the manifestations expressed by the defendant (David) were legal decisions. Thus, they are not random events or personal opinions, but based on sources. As for moral damage, this is the human suffering, pain, sorrow, sadness unfairly imposed on others.” All in all Goldman was just exercising his freedom of expression.

The judge concluded that she had not seen any practice of the defendant that might have caused moral damage to the authors, since the American didn’t commit any illegal actions capable of offending the morals of the authors, having only exercised his right to express himself, without any excess.


You May Also Like

Agreement Promotes Mutual Cultural Understanding Between Arabs and Brazilians

A memorandum of cooperation to promote and disclose cultural activities about the Arab world ...

Brazil: Times Affair Fractures Lula Administration

Brazilian President Lula’s decision to expel the New York Times correspondent has cracked the ...

Brazil to Propose Preventive Agreements to IMF

Brazil’s Minister of Finance, Antônio Palocci, will participate in the annual meetings of the ...

Brazil Ready to Lend US$ 60 Billion to Help Businesses

In a bid to speed up the Brazilian economy's recovery, Brazil is going to ...

Kerry Snubs Brazil and Latin America

John Kerry had the right woman at his side when accepting the Democratic nomination ...

Fear of Higher Interest Rates Brings Brazilian Market Tumbling Down

Latin American stocks tumbled, as investors took profits and reacted to gloomy analyst commentary ...

With Astronaut Mission Brazil and Russia Tone Up Technological Ties

Brazil’s Air Force lieutenant coronel Marcos Pontes will be the first Brazilian to travel ...

2016 Olympics: Athletes of the World, Pack Your Bags, We’re Flying to Rio

At the end, the charm of president Barack Obama, his wife Michelle and that ...

Underground Brazil

The big cities keep getting bigger. To survive, millions have been operating a prosperous ...

AIDS Among Poor Women Goes Up Sharply in Brazil

Brazil’s Non-Governmental Agencies (NGOs) are organizing demonstrations in 12 Brazilian states in an effort ...