Too Late: 23 Years Later Brazil Justice Orders Payment of Losses Due to Economic Shock Plans

Collor plan When has all started? It is not easy to pinpoint the exact beginning of Brazil’s inflation problems. Inflation certainly got a big boost when, as they say, president Juscelino Kubitschek (1955-59), “promised the country fifty years of progress in five, but gave Brazil forty years of inflation in four.”

 Twenty years of harsh military rule (1964-85) were unable to tame the dragon of inflation so it fell to the civilian governments of José Sarney, Fernando Collor and, finally, Fernando Henrique Cardoso, to deal with the problem through a series of what came to be called “economic shock plans.”

The first one was the Plano Cruzado. The plan even had a motto: “It has to work.” But, it didn’t. And the result was disastrous. Other plans followed. All of them “had to work,” but none of them did.

At the end of the Sarney government, 1989, inflation was over 40% a month! During the Collor administration it reached 80%. Especially hard hit by the economic chaos that followed each failed plan were people with passbook savings (poupança).

August 25, 2010 (a little bit of the law’s delay here) the Second Section of the Brazilian Superior Appeals Court ruled that passbook savings losses due to the economic shock plans Bresser (1987), Summer (1989), Collor 1 (1990) and Collor 2 (1992) are to be restituted. 

The judges specified that restitutions are to be adjusted as follows (correção monetária): 26.06% for the Bresser Plan; 42.72% for the Summer Plan; 44.80% for Collor 1; and, 21.87% for Collor 2.

However, at the same time the court also ruled that the statute of limitations on class action suits for restitution was five years after the plan, effectively eliminating 99% of those lawsuits (in actual numbers, this removed 1,015 out of 1,030 claims by around 40 million people who put their money in the bank thinking it was a safe place).

Even so, there are still over 814,000 individual claims for restitution of poupança losses in courts somewhere. The STJ ruled that the statute of limitations on individual claims remains 20 years. So most of them are still valid.  

Financial experts have calculated that someone with money in a passbook savings account during the period the four plans were foisted upon the country, 1987 to 1992, would have lost around 95% of his money.

The decision by the STJ Second Section can, and certainly will be, appealed. It can go back to the entire STJ and to the Supreme Court.

ABr

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil Targets Blacks and Women in New AIDS Campaign

The Brazilian government started yesterday, World AIDS Day, an awareness campaign among Brazilians that ...

Brazilian Congress Inquiry on Bribery to Summon 40 People

The Commission of Inquiry of the Comptroller-General’s office of Brazilian Chamber of Deputies approved ...

US Senators in Brazil to Learn How Ethanol is Made and Distributed

A group of American senators begin a week-long visit to Brazil this Friday, April ...

Brazil Vows to Keep Fighting First-World Trade Barriers

The trade barriers that need to be overcome and the effort required to reach ...

Paraguay Wants at Least US$ 2 Billion from Brazil for Itaipu Energy

Brazil is expected to pay its South American neighbor, Paraguay, a bigger share of ...

Brazil & Co Welcome Venezuela as Mercosur’s Fifth Member

The Mercosur is about to get its fifth member. Tomorrow, July 4, Brazilian President ...

Brazil’s Landless Resist Police and Killer Militias

A Brazilian Military Brigade, under orders from sub-commander Paul Mendes, on Tuesday, June 3, ...

Arabists Gather in Rio to Promote Arab Studies in Brazil

Brazilian and Portuguese scholars of Arabic language and literature and Arab history are getting ...

British Foreign Secretary to Meet Brazilian President in Advance of G8 Summit

British Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett will visit Brazil between July 2 and 4 at ...