Brazil Supreme Delays Decision on Giving Watchdog Agency Punitive Power

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazilian Chief Justice Cezar Peluso Brazil’s Supreme Court has delayed a decision on the most eagerly awaited case on the docket: the question of the power of the National Justice Council, a government’s watchdog agency to punish judges.

The case is based on a lawsuit filed by an association of judges (Associação dos Magistrados Brasileiros – AMB) that seeks to limit administrative and, especially, correctional activities by the CNJ. The Chief Justice, Cezar Peluso, simply did not call up the case at Wednesday’s session.

According to justice Marco Aurélio Mello, who is handling the case, the postponement may have been an attempt to calm things down after declarations by Eliana Calmon, the Inspector General, that “bandits in togas were hiding in the judicial system.”

“This is just not the right moment to judge this case. We need to let things clear up a little more,” said Marco Aurélio.

However, another justice, Luiz Fux, said the only reason for not bringing up the AMB suit was a lack of time.

On the other hand, court observers raised the possibility of an attempt by the justices to reach a prior agreement and avoid a public argument.

Prior discussion of cases (called “conference” in the United States and a bedrock of US Supreme Court procedure) is not the rule in Brazil.

Justices reach their own opinions alone and express them separately in open court. Brazilian Supreme Court sessions can often feature verbal fireworks.

The idea of prior discussion is not universally popular among the justices. For example, justice Marco Aurélio Mello declared: “We should take our seats and express opinions spontaneously. There is no room for prior agreements on what we do in court. This is a courtroom, not a theater.”

When Chief Justice Cezar Peluso was asked after the session yesterday if there was a date for discussion of the AMB suit against punitive action by the CNJ, he just said it continued to be on the docket. That translates as: postponed until further notice.

ABr

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Hath No Fury Like a Mayor Scorned

It’s the mayors’ turn. Since yesterday, at the federal capital, municipal officeholders have not ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Is Bridging the Gap Between the Rich and the Poorest

Brazil’s economy has grown, on average, 4.5% over the last for years. Per capita ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil to Send Dental Records to Help Identify New Orleans Victim

The Brazilian Ministry of Foreign Relations informed that the United States government asked the ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Of gold and history in Minas Gerais

Built with the wealth from the gold rush, Ouro Preto is an historical monument. ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Is Counting on US$ 20 Billion in Private Capital to Modernize Ports

The Brazilian government hopes the projects it is developing for improvement of Brazil’s main ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Gets Upgrade from Fitch. It’s BB All Over.

Fitch has upgraded the ratings for Brazil as follows: Long-term foreign currency Issuer Default ...