Brazil’s Supreme Wants to Have a Final Word on US Boy Sean Goldman’s Case

Brazzil Magazine covers

Sean and David Goldman Two years after generating headlines in Brazil and the United States the case of Sean Goldman will be reviewed in the Brazilian Supreme Court (STF). There’s no date yet, however, for this procedure.

By a majority vote, the ministers of the First Panel of the Supreme Court decided Tuesday, November 29, that the Court should finally position itself on the dispute of relatives over the custody of American boy.

In 2009, the case created an international legal war centered in the dispute between the Brazilian maternal family of Sean and his American father, David Goldman.

The ministers of the First Panel understand that it is up to the plenary of the Supreme Court to have the final word on the matter because this is a test case, which involves the implementation of international treaties, and that should guide other similar procedures in the future.

Sean Goldman was born in the United States in 2000, the son of an American father and Brazilian mother Bruna Bianchi. The mother brought him to Brazil in 2004 for a holiday, but decided to get a  divorce and remain in the country. She remarried and died in 2008 from complications in childbirth.

David Goldman claimed custody of the child, arguing that the international law dictates that the boy should live in the country where he was born and raised.

After a battle between the Brazilian family court and the biological father, then president of the Supreme Court, Gilmar Mendes, authorized the departure of Sean at the end of 2009 through an injunction. However, the merits of the request were never analyzed.

The case has also created conflict within the Supreme, since the Minister Gilmar Mendes disallowed the rapporteur of the proceedings, Justice Marco Aurélio Mello, in determining the departure of the boy. Marco Aurélio, in his opinion, had ruled that Sean stayed with the maternal family.

ABr

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazzil Magazine covers

For Brazil the Paraguayan-Brazilian Row Over Itaipu Is Just Political

According to Brazilian president's international affairs advisor, Marco Aurélio Garcia, differences between Brazil and ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Cabinet Changes in Brazil Don’t Stop Market’s Bleeding

Latin American shares witnessed another mixed session Wednesday, with shares following a similar pattern ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Indians from the Americas Gathered in Brazil Want Their Rights Spelled Out

In an effort to reach a consensus on a document to be called "An ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Rebuffs Amnesty and Says It’s on the Right Path

The national secretary of Public Safety in the Ministry of Justice, Luiz Fernando Corrêa, ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Only Loses to Chile in High Cost of Living in South America

Chile, Brazil and Uruguay have the highest cost of living in Latinamerica according to ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Monte Verde, Brazil’s Alpine Trap for Tourists, Is Also a Green Gem

If you are unfortunate enough to live among the mayhem and madness of São ...