The Frying of a Black Minister in Brazil

The Frying of a Black Minister in Brazil

What the Lula administration wants is Minister Benedita da
Silva’s seat, but they avoid mentioning
the inactivity of her
Ministry. The already-almost-former Minister would likely claim
that she has no
budget funds—an uncomfortable argument
that unveils the intestines of Lula’s neo-liberal policies.


Carlos Chagas


Let us put things in their right perspective. This campaign against Minister for Social Welfare Benedita da Silva,
which was unleashed by the government itself, has the smell, shape and depth of a craftly set-up operation. With prominent
aids to President Lula on board, including his Chief of Staff José Dirceu and PT president José Genoino, the true intention
here is to destabilize the image of the Minister and fry her in a way that prevents her to remain as Minister.

It’s a Skin Thing

We must question, first of all, how the whole thing—Benedita’s trip to Buenos Aires, with airfare and
accommodations paid by the taxpayer, in order to participate in an evangelic event and have a meeting with her corresponding Minister in
the new Argentine government—hit the newscasts. Who provided all the newspapers, always friendly and coached, with
the information about the cost and purpose of the scanting periplus?

Why did the Public Ethics Committee, subordinated to the Chief of Staff, decide on a preliminary condemnation of
the Minister, exhorting her to return the money paid for the tickets to the Treasury without even hearing her or giving her
the right of defense? Why does the PT President keep hitting her every other day with condemnations without having made
a single phone call to obtain clarifications?

What they really want is Benedita’s seat, but they avoid mentioning the fact, which could well be the primary reason,
i.e. the inactivity of the Ministry of Social Action. This is because the already-almost-former Minister would likely retort by
claiming that the reason she has accomplished so little is the utter lack of budget funds—an uncomfortable argument that unveils
the intestines of the neo-liberal policies still in course. There could be yet another reason for the massacre, though: the
Minister is black and she comes from the slums. Would the same thing happen if, instead of Benedita da Silva, we had
Favre (the mayor of São Paulo, Marta Suplicy, who is married to Luis Favre), for example, as Minister?

Coordinated Reaction

Palocci and his gang are busy facing the increasingly frequent exhortations in opinion polls, Congress, the
president’s cabinet and within the PT itself, that the time has arrived for profound changes in economic policy. First we had the
reaction to the position spearheaded by Itamaraty (Ministry of Foreign Affairs) and supported by President Lula in Cancún, with
Brazil shouting in protest and demanding equal treatment in our trade relations with rich countries.

Now, in spite of having had their ears pulled by the head of the government, the economic team reloads and fires
again by way of the meticulous disclosure to the press of confidences made by the Minister of the Economy that they need one
more year of arrocho (tourniquet) and neo-liberalism in order to save Brazil from chaos.

The key-word is "perseverance", a mere synonym for a continuation of the same ideas and the same people. They
defend themselves by attacking and alerting everyone about the dangers of abandoning the recessive stance, drastically
reducing interest rates, decreasing the superávit
primário (primary surplus) and beginning the public investment phase, aid to
domestic producers, job creation and wage increases.

Much praise has been going around for former Minister Pedro Malan, with talk about erecting him a statue. The
problem is that if they do manage to get one more year, Lula will then have reached half of his term, making it more difficult and
even unfeasible to set up the so-called spectacle of growth. Could this be the objective of the financial system they seem to
be representing?

The Northeast

Congressional blocs from Bahia upward are at a boiling point following the comments made by Marta Suplicy that
"o Nordeste é complicado" (the Northeast is complicated). The mayor from São Paulo was reacting to the decision by the
Senate to postpone the review of a request for a R$ 493 million (US$ 164 million) loan to be invested in transportation.

Nothing wrong with her claim, if were not for the unusual indignation of Marta against northeastern legislators
accused by her of being against São Paulo and linking this operation, in their imagination, to the creation of political favors for
her reelection.

The Northeast may be complicated, but it is also exploited. The reasons behind it are secular reasons, a result of
poverty and the treatment received from federal governments, almost always representing the interests of the richer party. São
Paulo does not enter the equation, just like Pilates is not mentioned in the Creed,
notwithstanding the recognition for its
efforts, capacity and success. The
paulistas continue to demonstrate that Brazil is viable.

We must admit, though that the Mayor was unfortunate in her choice of words. Her way of expressing her frustration
for not being able to return to
paulicéia (São Paulo) with the millions in her purse was unjust and simplistic. From Teresina to Salvador
and including Fortaleza, Natal, João Pessoa, Recife, Aracaju and Maceió, all mayors are equally eager for some welcome
reais and centavos to apply in public transportation.


Carlos Chagas writes for the
Rio’s daily Tribuna da Imprensa and is a representative
of the Brazilian Press Association, in Brasília. He
welcomes your comments at

Translated by Tereza Braga. Braga is a freelance Portuguese translator and interpreter based in Dallas. She is an
accredited member of the American Translators Association. Contact:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

Chavez Promises Lula No Brazilian Company Will Be Nationalized in Venezuela

Hugo Chavez, the president of Venezuela, told his Brazilian counterpart, Luiz Inácio Lula da ...

Brazil’s Petrobras Lowers Investments in the Next Four Years to US$ 138 Billion

Petrobras, the Brazilian state-controlled oil and gas multinational, disclosed that its board of governors ...

Brazil Votes in Favor of UN’s Declaration on Indian Rights

The UN Human Rights Council approved on June 29 the Declaration on the Rights ...

Slow-Growing Brazil Is Holding Back LatAm’s Expansion

Latinamerica is the developing region which will expand less in 2006 – below Asia ...

Brazil Government Debt Stable at 51.7% of GDP

Brazil’s net government debt remained stable in March at US$ 481.83 billion (R$ 1.021 ...

Lula’s Ex-Chief of Staff, Vows He Won’t Resign from Brazilian Congress

Brazilian Federal deputy José Dirceu (PT-São Paulo state) presented the Ethics Council of the ...

The Foley Scandal’s Brazilian Skinny Dipping Connection

The sexual advances against under-age pages in the American Congress that brought down Mark ...

Brazil to Get a US$ 33 Billion Trade Surplus This Year

Brazil’s cumulative trade surplus for the year to the first week in November is ...

Despite Loss in Venezuela, Brazil’s Petrobras Has Record Profit

Brazilian state-controlled oil company Petrobras ended 2006 with a net profit of 25.9 billion ...