Reviewing Bossa Nova’s Greatest Unreleased Disc

“What disc?” I can hear you asking in indignation. True enough, there is no disc. Or rather, there is, but it’s never been released. Released or not, it’s here, and since it is, and was recorded one August 42 years ago, and has long been touted as a major landmark of bossa nova, and since August 2004 cries out for a refreshing breeze, here comes the long overdue review.

by Daniella Thompson

Imagine yourself in the summer of 1962. You have never heard
most of the songs on this album, for they are receiving here their world

Aloysio de Oliveira united on stage Antonio Carlos Jobim and
Vinicius de Moraes, whose songwriting partnership is already at its end
(Vinicius has taken up with young Baden Powell de Aquino).

This is Vinicius’ first time as a performer; until now it’s
been considered unseemly for a diplomat to sing in a nightclub. Both Tom and
Vinicius sit behind the piano, oversized whiskey glasses before them. This is a
good start, but it needs professional voices.

The venue is the restaurant
Au Bon Gourmet on Avenida Nossa Senhora de Copacabana, in the bairro of the same
name. The stage is tiny and unadorned, but Aloysio crams it full.

He brings in the vocal quartet Os Cariocas, a link between the
old sambas that his own conjunto, Bando da Lua, used to sing and the new sambas
that Tom and Vinicius compose. Front and center sits João Gilberto, who makes a
specialty of both the old samba and the new.

The history-making show in August 1962

The elegant audience, whose ranks are filled from Rio’s chic
society and artistic circles, dines on French cuisine and listens attentively,
applauding and at times yelling encouragements.

Accompanied by Otávio
Bailly on bass and Milton Banana on drums, the seven men on stage unroll a
string of, yes, mostly unknown songs. Os Cariocas warm up the audience with a
rousing rendition of the brand new “Só Danço Samba,” which Tom augments with his
voice and piano:

Já dancei o twist até demais
Mas não sei
Do calipso
Ao chá-chá-chá

The message is clear: take
away foreign rhythms””I’m going back to my samba roots.

“Samba de uma Nota
Só” is more familiar; João Gilberto had already recorded it in his second LP,
O Amor, o Sorriso e a Flor. Tom takes it away, with Os Cariocas humming

Eis aqui este sambinha
Feito numa nota só
Outras notas vão entrar

Mas a base é uma só

The group steps in for the refrain and the second verse,
changes tempi and rhythms, heaps in falsettos, and finishes off the song on an
extended note.

João Gilberto now launches into “Corcovado” (also from O Amor, o Sorriso e
a Flor
). He is the one responsible for the first line of the lyrics being as
enchanting as it is; Jobim had originally written “Um cigarro, um violão.”

The interpretation is vintage João, with the added attraction
of Os Cariocas crooning quietly on the repetition. The crowd laps it up.

Num cantinho um violão
Este amor, uma canção
Prá fazer feliz a quem
se ama
Muita calma prá pensar
E ter tempo prá sonhar
Da janela vê-se o
O Redentor, que lindo!

It’s time for Vinicius to show off his new work with Baden Powell. And here
is the debut recording of what will become his signature piece, “Samba da

The movie Un Homme et une Femme is several years away yet. That long
list of names to be blessed is fresh. When Vinicius pronounces “Saravá,” the
audience echoes him. Os Cariocas join in the final refrain. Enthusiastic
applause follows.

Porque o samba nasceu lá na Bahia
E se hoje ele é branco na poesia

Se hoje ele é branco na poesia
Ele é negro demais no coração

João Gilberto returns with “Amor em Paz,” recorded the previous year on
João Gilberto. The crystalline voice is complemented by the vocal group
in a short and lyrical interlude.

Foi então
Que da minha infinita tristeza aconteceu
Em você a razão de viver e de amar em paz
E não sofrer
Nunca mais
Porque o amor é a coisa mais triste quando se

Now comes a complete unknown, marked on the disc cover only as “Bossa Nova e
Bossa Velha.” No author is indicated. Did Aloysio write this song? More than

Os Cariocas sing:

Afinal se isso é bossa nova
O que é que é bossa velha?
Diferença é
só no jeito de bater
João Gilberto disse que o samba endireitou
E que
ninguém aqui jamais desafinou
Melodia [?] Tom do tom a cantar
Poesia deu
Vinicius pra rimar
Moças descobriram professores pra lição
Marcando a
bossa nova no bater do violão

An old-fashioned, bombastic voice interposes:

Mas a bossa velha protestou
Ou, antigamente, reclamou:
dissonância, o som nasal, o atonal”

But the final conclusion is:

[…] E quando canta a bossa velha,
Canta a bossa nova

The audience laps it up. But there’s more in store. Tom introduces a song he
just completed: “Samba do Avião.” Os Cariocas alternate with him in the second

Este samba é só porque
Rio, eu gosto de você
A morena vai
Seu corpo todo balançar
Rio de sol, de céu, de mar

Prolonged applause. Cut. The piano begins playing, and a voice
from the audience calls: “Tom, muito bonito, hein!” Was he referring to “Samba
do Avião”? Now Vinicius shows that he can carry a melodic line and sings his new
collaboration with Baden, “O Astronauta.”

Será que por acaso
A flor sabe que é flor
E a estrela Vênus
ao menos
Porque brilha mais bonita, amor

Os Cariocas hum behind Vinicius, providing the decisive “Pah!” after the line
“Sim, você é linda porque 锝 and concluding with the requisite

João Gilberto comes in with two songs from his most recent, eponymous album.
First Dorival Caymmi’s “Samba da Minha Terra” (1940), originally recorded by
Aloysio’s Bando da Lua. Here we have voice, guitar, and Tom’s occasional

Quem não gosta de samba
Bom sujeito não é
í‰ ruim da cabeça
doente do pé

He follows it with “Insensatez,” just voice and guitar:

A insensatez que você fez
Coração mais sem cuidado
Fez chorar de
O seu amor
Um amor tão delicado
Ah, porque você foi fraco
Assim tão desalmado
Ah, meu coração quem nunca amou
Não merece
ser amado

And now comes the evening’s set piece: a shiny new song called “Garota de
Ipanema.” This isn’t the first version written. That one was called “Menina Que
Passa” and opened thus:

Vinha cansado de tudo
De tantos caminhos
Tão sem poesia
Tão sem
Com medo da vida
Com medo de amar
Quando na tarde
Tão linda no espaço
Eu vi a menina
Que vinha num passo
de balanço
Caminho do mar

Fortunately for all of us, both songwriters found it lame. Vinicius did much
better the second time around. For its public debut at the Bon Gourmet, Tom,
Vinicius, and João wrote a special sung introduction.

João Gilberto (in sweet voice):
Tom e se você fizesse agora uma
Que possa nos dizer
Contar o que é o amor?

Tom Jobim (in reedy voice):
Olha Joãozinho
Eu não saberia
Vinicius pra fazer a poesia

Vinicius de Moraes (in deep voice):
Para essa canção
Quem dera o João
Para cantar

[audience laughter]

Ah, mas quem sou eu?
Eu sou mais vocês.
Melhor se nós
cantássemos os três.

[more audience laughter and applause]

All three:
Olha que coisa mais linda
mais cheia de graça


The rest, as they say, is history. Not so quick, though. Os Cariocas break in
on the same track with Haroldo Barbosa and Luiz Reis’ “Devagar com a Louça,”
which sounds like an old song but in fact is newly minted in the year 1962.
These back-to-back tunes are the perfect expression of bossa nova
versus bossa velha.

We could all go home now (or play the disc again from the beginning), but not
before the final medley of “Garota de Ipanema,” “Só Danço Samba,” and “Se Todos
Fossem Iguais a Você,” which sums up the six-year partnership of Tom and
Vinicius between Orfeu da Conceição and this night of August 1962.


(unreleased; 1962) 37:24
Recorded live at Au Bon Gourmet,
Copacabana, Rio de Janeiro

01. Só Danço Samba (Antonio Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de

02. Samba de uma Nota Só (Antonio Carlos Jobim/Newton
Jobim & Os Cariocas

03. Corcovado (Antonio Carlos
Gilberto & Os Cariocas

04. Samba da Benção (Baden
Powell/Vinicius de Moraes)
      Vinicius de Moraes
05. Amor em Paz (Antonio
Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de Moraes)
      João Gilberto & Os Cariocas
06. Bossa
Nova e Bossa Velha
      Os Cariocas
07. Samba do Avião (Antonio
Carlos Jobim)
      Tom Jobim & Os Cariocas
08. O
Astronauta (Baden Powell/Vinicius de Moraes)
Vinicius de Moraes & Os

09. Samba da Minha Terra (Dorival

10. Insensatez (Antonio Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de

11. Garota de Ipanema (Antonio Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de
Tom & Vinicius

      Devagar com a
Louça (Haroldo Barbosa/Luiz Reis)
      Os Cariocas
12. Só Danço Samba (Antonio
Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de Moraes)
      João Gilberto & Os Cariocas
13. Garota
de Ipanema; Só Danço Samba; Se Todos Fossem Iguais a
      (Antonio Carlos Jobim/Vinicius de

João Gilberto: vocals & guitar
Tom Jobim: vocals &
Vinicius de Moraes: vocals
Os Cariocas: vocals &
Otávio Bailly: bass
Milton Banana: drums
Directed by Aloysio de

You can read more about Brazilian music and culture at
Daniella Thompson on Brazil here:


You May Also Like

Itaipava, a Petrópolis neighborhood a short drive from Rio

Brazil: When Rio Is Too Hot to Handle You Just Get High

Sometimes the usual enticements of Rio de Janeiro are too sweltering to handle, especially ...

Brazil’s Agribusiness Exports Reach US$ 7.9 Billion in July. A 50% Growth

Brazil agribusiness' trade balance posted two significant results this past July: exports totaled US$ ...

Brazil’s Lula Didn’t Get Money from Cuba, Says Finance Minister

Brazil’s Minister of Finance, Antonio Palocci, in testimony before the Senate Commission on Economic ...

Brazil Vows Better Help to 3 Million Working Children and Their Families

Brazil’s Program for the Eradication of Child Labor (Peti) will be incorporated into the ...

For Brazil, US and EU Crisis Has Become Chronic and Will Last for Years

Guido Mantega, the Brazilian Finance minister, admitted that Brazil may have to lower its ...

In Brazil, the Carnaval Seems to Be Over. Next Stop: Hangover

Carnaval in the historic Brazilian city of Olinda is a non-stop, noisy affair that ...

Most Brazilians Expecting Unemployment to Become Worse

Compared with the previous quarter, the Brazilian population’s expectations for inflation improved, while perceptions ...

A Lesson of Brazil with Professor Lula

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in his State of the Union address ...

All Brazil You Can Eat in London

Here it is: the Guy Burton Guide to Brazil in London. I will be ...


If successful, Porto Digital might well serve as a model for revitalizing the rest ...