Death Threats and Lawsuits Can’t Silence This Lone Brazilian Journalist

Brazilian journalist Lúcio Flávio Pinto
Death threats, physical assaults and 32 lawsuits – this is what freelance
journalist Lúcio Flávio Pinto has faced as a result of the one-man battle he is
waging in the northern Brazilian city of Belém, capital of Pará state, the main
gateway to the Amazon jungle.

“I feel like Prometheus,” says Pinto, who has published the “Jornal Pessoal” (Personal Journal) in Belém every two weeks since 1987. Corruption, land property fraud, and abuse of power by the leading local media group are the main targets of his investigative journalism, in a state that is notorious for the large number of political and social activists who are murdered.

Responding to the 18 lawsuits still pending against him takes up “80 percent of my time,” he tells. His enemies, he says, are trying to use the justice system to entangle him and divert his attention and energy away from his work, drastically reducing the time he has available to investigate and write, while increasing the possibility of some lapse in his defense.

The legal web in which he is enmeshed made it impossible for him to leave Belém to receive a prize in the United States in 2005, for fear of missing court dates and hearings, which could have serious consequences.

The situation reminds him of Prometheus, the hero of Greek mythology who stole fire from the gods to give to humans, and as punishment was chained to a mountain where an eagle would come down every night and eat his liver.

The mission of Pinto’s Jornal Pessoal which is a completely individual effort, is to report on events and issues that are ignored by the big media because of the economic or political interests of their owners.

Just 2,000 copies are printed and sold at newspaper stands, to “provide citizens with the information they need to reach decisions and to fight with the powerful in conditions of equality.”

The paper carries no advertising and has no source of revenue beyond sales, which do not always cover the costs. The solitary mission that Pinto has taken on, of being an “annoying pebble in the shoes” of the powerful, is a difficult one.

He does not accept financial support because credibility is his best weapon and requires total independence. He lives in a modest house and drives a 20-year-old car.

Jornal Pessoal is “a prison; a golden one but still a prison,” he says. To defend himself, with some help from lawyer friends, he has had to study law on his own, and has become an expert in Brazil’s press laws. To investigate cases of business corruption, he learned how to analyze balance sheets and understand the “minutiae” of accounting, which enabled him to denounce many shady business deals or arrangements that hurt the local population.

Pinto did not choose this thorny path out of a lack of alternatives. In his 41-year career as a journalist, which began when he was 16, Pinto has won a number of prizes, including two international awards: the International Golden Dove for Peace Award (Colombe d’Oro per la Pace) from the Italian institute for international research Archivio Disarmo, in 1997, and the International Press Freedom Award from the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists, in 2005. He is also the author of 10 books on the Amazon jungle region.

He had already gained a reputation as a reporter and writer with a deep knowledge of the Amazon and was writing for two major daily newspapers when he published, in September 1987, the first issue of Jornal Pessoal.

His paper was inspired by a similar initiative by Isidor Feinstein Stone, an iconoclastic investigative journalist from the U.S. whose independent I.F. Stone’s Weekly, published in Washington from 1953 to 1971, was regarded as highly influential.

The Jornal Pessoal emerged when the Belém daily O Liberal refused to publish an investigative report by Pinto in which he pointed to the involvement of two big businessmen in the murder of former congressman Paulo Fonteles, who as a lawyer defended poor farmers involved in land conflicts in the state of Pará. The newspaper’s owners were worried about losing advertising revenue if they printed the story.

Many local events and stories have only been covered by the Jornal Pessoal because they have involved powerful individuals or companies. These range from financial scandals and corporate corruption to the mysterious 1991 murder of a member of the local elite in Belém, which was related to money laundering and drug trafficking, as revealed by the Jornal Pessoal.

Months later, other newspapers, which initially kept silent on the murder, published the widow’s version that her husband had committed suicide. Pinto pointed out that this was impossible, because the fatal shot came from three meters away. The federal police later seized nearly a ton of cocaine near Belém from people with links to the killing.

The incident gave rise to “the saddest moment of my career,” said the journalist. After a press conference with the police, Pinto announced that he would have an “off-microphone conversation” with the police commissioner in charge of the case. Other reporters initially said they wanted to participate, but when Pinto insisted that they promise to publish the content of the dialogue in their papers, “they all left.”

Pinto frequently cites this incident to criticize today’s “tame” journalism, which he describes as a “toothless lion – ensnared by interests.” The younger generations “do not know how to identify facts,” preferring instead to editorialize or to work as news anchors, and many reporters keep information to themselves to use in their private consultancies, he complained.

His harshest criticism is aimed at the style of journalism practiced by the Maiorana group, which dominates the media in the state of Pará, owning newspapers and TV and radio stations. Pinto worked for the Maiorana group in the 1980s, and broke off relations over irreconcilable differences.

But his biggest battle is against the “colonization” of the Amazon jungle, which he said is the victim of decisions reached outside of the region that do not take the welfare of the local population into account, but merely focus on supplying outside markets.

The state of Pará is the clearest illustration of this phenomenon. Major mining operations of iron ore, bauxite, manganese and other raw materials, as well as the huge Tucuruí hydroelectric dam, the second largest in Brazil and the fourth largest in the world, are operated by foreign corporations and mainly benefit markets abroad.

The energy produced by Tucuruí and sold at subsidized prices keeps down the cost of Brazil’s aluminum production, which accounts for 15 percent of Japan’s aluminum supplies, said Pinto.

In the 1970s, he closely followed the process by which the United States was gradually displaced by Japan as the most influential economic power in the Amazon jungle region. He took part in extensive prize-winning coverage on the region, when he was living in São Paulo, Brazil’s biggest city, and after he returned to Belém in 1974, as correspondent for O Estado de S, Paulo newspaper, which he left in 1989.

“Lúcio Flávio Pinto is a walking data bank on the history and stories of the Amazon,” as well as a “model of rigorously independent journalism” and “responsible exercise of citizenship taken to the extreme,” said Roberto Smeraldi, coordinator of the Friends of the Earth International’s Amazonia Program.

It would be very useful “to put his knowledge and experience at the service of interesting initiatives for the development of the Amazon region,” but he chose his “personal journalistic battle as his absolute top priority, assuming a declared solitude,” he added.

Pinto’s talents could have a greater repercussion through alliances with like-minded movements or institutions, agreed Marcos Ximenes Ponte, executive director of the non-governmental Amazon Institute of Environmental Research (IPAM) and a former dean of the Federal University of Pará, where Pinto worked as a professor for seven years.

Mario Osava is a Rio-based Brazilian journalist specialized in environment, economic integration and social issues. Osava has worked in adult literacy, filmmaking and community organization in Brazilian favelas, He has lived in Cuba, Chile, Belgium, Portugal and Angola. The author welcomes comments at

This article appeared originally in the IPS website:

© IPS Inter Press Service, 2007


You May Also Like

11.4 Million Families in Brazil Make Less than US$ 36 a Month

The Brazilian government and the institutions that oversee federal spending formalized a partnership, January ...

Petrobras Surplus 600% Bigger than Last Year’s

Together the greater supply of Brazilian oil for export, the reduction of spread (the ...

Brazil Goes on High-Level Trade Mission to North Africa

Businessmen from Brazil willing to go on a mission to North Africa, organized by ...

Best-seller Books, Plays and Movies

By Brazzil Magazine Dois Perdidos Numa Noite Suja (Two Lost Souls on a Dirty ...

Brazil Gets New Cardinal. He Will Be Choosing Next Pope

São Paulo's (Brazil) Archbishop Odilo Pedro Scherer was named cardinal on Wednesday, October 17, ...

Brazil’s Finance Minister Knocks on Door of Private Sector

During a speech in the Planalto Palace yesterday, November 10, before the Economic and ...

Revenue Down in Brazil by 2%

Brazilian government revenue was US$ 9.581 billion (25.745 billion reais) in November which, although ...

Like in the Movies: Robbers Tunnel into US$ 65 Million from Brazil’s Central Bank

A group of robbers stole a record 65.2 million US dollars by tunneling into ...

Brazilian Steel Production Is Down 10% This Year

Brazil produced 2.5 million tons of raw steel in May, 3.3% more than in ...

Brazil’s TAM and Gol Sell Air Tickets to Be Paid in 48 Months

Brazil's Gol and TAM airlines, which between them account for close to 90% of ...