News from AIDS Conference in Brazil Leads US Group to Urge Ban on Male Circumcision

In response to results of a male circumcision HIV study presented yesterday at the Third International AIDS Society Conference on HIV Pathogenesis and Treatment in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, several intactivist groups called on the United Nations to classify circumcision of male children as a human rights crime.

The study, performed on more than 3,000 African men, concluded that circumcision reduced the chance of HIV infection by 65% over an 18 month period.


Matthew Hess of San Diego based MGMbill.org said that ongoing circumcision studies in Africa are helping to perpetuate male genital mutilation.


“Although the participants in this latest study were consenting adults, in the real world circumcision is forced upon helpless children. I find it quite ironic that the United Nations condemns female circumcision as a human rights crime while it simultaneously encourages male circumcision as a preventive health measure.


“Circumcision of children is genital mutilation, regardless of gender, and the U.N. needs to take action now to ensure that male circumcision is performed only on fully informed consenting adults.”
 
Tina Kimmel, MSW, MPH, at the University of California Berkeley School of Social Welfare, said that the U.N. has a blind spot when it comes to male circumcision.


“If this study had examined the health effects of preventive mastectomy or female circumcision, one can only imagine the uproar it would have caused. Sadly, there is a double standard when it comes to boys.


“The reality in Africa and the rest of the world is that male circumcision is usually performed on children who are unable to give their full consent, and the response from UNAIDS (Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS) calling the results of this newest study “promising” shows how the power of tradition can blind otherwise intelligent and rational people to the most horrific of crimes.”


Kimmel is Coordinator of the Bay Area Intactivists Group (BANG), in Oakland, California, a group that hosts frequent public demonstrations and informational events on the consequences of male circumcision.


Dr. George Denniston, M.D., and President of Doctors Opposing Circumcision in Seattle, Washington, said that studies on male circumcision fail to take into account the sexual damage that circumcision leaves behind.


“As with female circumcision, male circumcision removes erogenous tissue and leaves the genitals with significantly diminished sexual capacity. In addition to removing irreplaceable nerve endings, circumcision initiates a buildup of callus over the soft and moist exposed membrane of the glans and remaining inner foreskin.


“The result is an even further decline in sexual sensitivity that gets progressively worse as men age. The best way to prevent HIV transmission is by using condoms, not by cutting off part of the genitals.”


Marilyn Milos, R.N., and Director of the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers (NOCIRC) in San Anselmo, California, said the U.N. should take action.


“The United Nations has a responsibility to uphold and implement the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child,” said Milos, “which calls on states to “take all effective and appropriate measures with a view to abolishing traditional practices prejudicial to the health of children”.


This terminology is fully applicable to male circumcision.” NOCIRC holds Roster status on the United Nations Economic and Social Council and has been working to change U.N. male circumcision policy since 1999.


Although the United Nations currently recognizes forced and coerced cutting of females as a violation of human rights, it does not offer the same recognition to male victims.


In light of the mounting negative medical evidence surrounding circumcision, efforts to ban male circumcision of children the same way that female circumcision is banned are starting to gain momentum, especially in the United States.


A bill proposed by MGMbill.org to ban medically unnecessary circumcision of children was resubmitted to Congress and the California Legislature earlier this year.


One U.S. lawmaker, Rep. Virgil Goode (R-VA), has already indicated support for the bill in a letter posted on the group’s website. MGMbill.org is now in the process of gathering endorsements from health and human rights organizations to prepare the bill for sponsorship.


www.MGMbill.org

Tags:

  • Show Comments (0)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Brazil Listens to Lagarde But Doesn’t Back Her for IMF Chief

France’s Finance Minister Christine Lagarde pledged to push reforms to give Brazil and other ...

IMF Lauds Brazil But Also Urges Budgetary Reform

IMF’s managing director Rodrigo de Rato, during a press conference in Singapore, Friday, September ...

Life Expectancy Jumps 9 Years in Brazil: It’s 71.8

The life expectancy of Brazilians has jumped from 62 years and six months, in ...

Brazil’s (Sí£o Paulo and Rio) Cost of Living Climbs 22 Places Among World’s Cities

Mercosur capitals figure in the lower half of the world’s most expensive cities according ...

US Imports from Brazil’s Co-ops Grow 420% in Value and 916% in Volume

The United States, was the main importer of Brazilian cooperatives products last year. The ...

Every 15 Seconds a Woman Is Beaten in Brazil, Mostly by Her Husband

A woman is beaten every 15 seconds in Brazil, which means that 2.1 million ...

Brazil’s Government in the Offensive Wants Quick Proof of Bribery Accusations

The leader of the government in the Senate, AloÀ­zio Mercadante (PT-SP), affirmed, that the ...

In Indy 500, Brazilians Bring Respect for the Past While Making History

Brazilians have always expressed a deep appreciation for the long (now 100 year) history ...

Brazil’s Embraer Delivers the First of 90 Jets Ordered by Air Canada

Brazilian jet maker Embraer celebrates delivery today of the third of 15 Embraer 175 jets ...

Brazil Goes Back on Decision to Stop Making Ethanol Cars

The Brazilian automobile industry revised its decision to stop manufacturing cars that run exclusively ...