Bar Association Calls Brazil’s Presence in Haiti Cruelty Against People and Troops

Brazzil Magazine covers

Organizations and social movements that participated in the World Social Forum in Venezuela last month have launched a Haitian Solidarity Campaign.

The activists demand the withdrawal of international troops from that country, cancellation of its foreign debt, and nonrenewal of the mandate of the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH), which the UN Security Council extended, Tuesday, February 14, for another six months.

"The MINUSTAH is a complete failure. It has been unable to achieve its goals, which are to train the police, disarm the population, and guarantee the election. In 18 months of activity, only 265 arms were picked up, the police isn’t being trained, and the troops that operate in the country don’t even speak the local language. Moreover, the election is beset by confusion," declared Sandra Quintela, one of the coordinators of the campaign.

In her opinion, what is needed in Haiti is professional help from doctors and social workers, for example, not the armed presence of military troops.

"They have intellectuals and organized social movements and can put together a structure without losing their national sovereignty. History shows that the Haitian people are capable of struggling," she said.

The MINUSTAH was established on April 30, 2004, by Security Council Resolution 1542. The military mission, which is commanded by Brazil, is in Haiti to provide security to the country under the provisional government.

Argentina, Sri Lanka, Jordan, Uruguay, and Peru are the other countries besides Brazil that are contributing troops to the mission.

According to João Luí­s Pinaud, a lawyer and member of the Brazilian Bar Association’s (OAB) Human Rights Council, the presence of the mission represents an act of cruelty against Haiti and the Brazilian troops who are there. In his view, the troops "are lost."

The Brazilian Army’s press office stated that troops are maintained in Haiti by determination of the UN. It also denied that the 1200 Brazilian soldiers stationed there are facing such problems as being abandoned by Haitian government officials.

The MINUSTAH press adviser, David Wimhurst, said that the mission has fulfilled its role and is striving to ensure the safety of the population and the transition to an elected government.

Agência Brasil

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazzil Magazine covers

Getting High in Porto Alegre or If Only Lula Were My President

Dateline: Porto Alegre, Brazil. If the critics of globalization who massed here are divided ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Bargain Hunters Descend Upon Brazil and Stocks Jump Up

Brazil and Latin America greatly improved Friday, October 21, as bargain hunters moved in. ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Brazil Has Two Polices: One Shines, the Other Puts the Country to Shame

On Sunday, May 27, nine people remained from the 48 arrested during Operação Navalha ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Chí¡vez is Urged in Brazil to Keep Democracy Strong

Brazil's Lula da Silva and Argentina's Nestor Kirchner called on their Venezuelan counterpart Hugo ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Stinging Gabriel, O Pensador

On his new record Gabriel O Pensador yells, “I don’t sing well. I’m not ...

Brazzil Magazine covers

Lula Soothes Brazilians, Then Asks Them to Trust Him and Go Out and Shop

Despite the international economic crisis the President of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, ...