Bush Administration Loses Case Against Brazilian Church in the Supreme Court

Americans United for Separation of Church and State lauded Tuesday’s, February 21, U.S. Supreme Court decision barring the federal government from interfering with religious freedom.

The high court ruled unanimously that the government "failed to demonstrate" that it had a "compelling interest in barring" the sacramental use of a tea containing a hallucinogen regulated by federal drug laws.

Americans United joined with other religious and public interest groups to urge the justices to protect the religious liberty of O Centro Espí­rita Beneficente União do Vegetal, a Brazil-based religious group whose members ingest chá hoasca (hoasca tea) during ceremonies.

"Today’s action reaffirms the importance of religious liberty," said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, executive director of Americans United. "Although this is a narrow decision, the justices reaffirmed that the federal government cannot interfere with religion without a compelling interest."

The ruling in Gonzales v. O Centro Espí­rita Beneficente União do Vegetal reaffirmed the 1993 federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), which bars the federal government from "substantially" burdening the free exercise of religion, unless it can prove a "compelling" interest in doing so.

In 1999, an American branch of O Centro Espí­rita Beneficente União do Vegetal sued the government for seizing shipments of the tea. Group members argued that the government had violated their religious liberty rights under RFRA.

In 2002, a U.S. district court agreed with the church, holding that the government did not prove that religious use of the tea is dangerous and that it had no "compelling interest" in barring its religious use.

In 2003 and 2004, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the district court’s ruling. But the Bush administration asked the Supreme Court to overturn those rulings.

In today’s ruling, the high court agreed with the lower courts, saying that the religious group "effectively demonstrated that its sincere exercise of religion was substantially burdened," and the government failed to demonstrate that the application of the burden to the religious group "would, more likely than not, be justified by the asserted compelling interests."

The high court opinion, authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, noted that for many years federal drug laws have provided an exemption for use of peyote by the Native American Church.

Roberts acknowledged a difficult task for courts in determining when RFRA should trump other federal laws.

"But Congress has determined that courts should strike sensible balances, pursuant to a compelling interest test that requires the Government to address the particular practice at issue," Roberts wrote.

Americans United is a religious liberty watchdog group based in Washington, D.C. Founded in 1947, the organization educates Americans about the importance of church-state separation in safeguarding religious freedom.

Tags:

You May Also Like

New California Bill Against Global Warming Pleases Brazil Sugarcane Industry

California has updated its calculations of sugarcane ethanol's emission reductions in a tacit admission ...

Jeers for Lula, Cheers for Chavez in Brazil

The fifth edition of the World Social Forum (WSF) ended today, January 31, in ...

Rio Group: Snubbing Washington and Pampering Havana

It comes as no surprise that after decades of playing the role of hemispheric ...

Landless and Just About Hopeless in Brazil

The Cedar Reservoir of Quixadá, Ceará, is one of the most beautiful spots in ...

Land Conflicts Up in Brazil

Last year, 39 people were murdered in land-related conflicts in all Brazilian territory. Although ...

Brazil Raises Key Rate by 0.5% to 12.25% to Curb Inflation

The Brazilian Central bank raised its benchmark interest rate this week for the second ...

An Explosive Situation in Rio: Manholes Detonating Like Bombs

Once again this week a manhole in the center of Rio, on the corner ...

Brazil Markets Start Year Subdued

Brazilian equities began 2005 in a downslope performance, as investors booked some gains following ...

Brazil’s Gol Expecting to Raise Up to US$ 350 Million in Global Market

Brazilian Airline Gol has filed a registration statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission ...

Brazil’s Lula Silences Aides Pushing for Punishment of Dictatorship Torturers

Brazilian President, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, says Brazilians should enshrine the "heroes" who ...