Preventive Censorship: Brazil’s Latest Weapon to Muzzle the Press

Front cover of Brazil's Metrópole magazine Reporters Without Borders has recently voiced its concern about a wave of Brazilian court orders imposing "preventive censorship" on news media in Brazil. In most cases, the orders are issued by local courts and are often quashed on appeal. Nonetheless, they feed a climate of intimidation and encourage self-censorship.

"Legal measures against news media that defame, insult or violate the right to privacy are not in themselves open to criticism, but when courts use this as grounds for censoring a program or banning a media from mentioning someone by name, the result is a climate that does not favor free expression," the press freedom organization said.

"An elected official has the right to complain when his private life is publicly exposed without his agreement, but when he obtains a court ban on any mention of his name, he is depriving the press of its right to refer to him as a public figure," Reporters Without Borders continued. "Preventive censorship is an abuse of authority and we hope the many cases, including those mentioned here, will be overturned on appeal."

In the most recent case, the mayor of the northeastern city of Salvador, capital of Bahia state, João Henrique, got a court to ban the Metrópole media network (which includes a radio station, magazine, website and blog) from mentioning his name.

If the group violates the ban, it will be fined the equivalent of US$ 104,000. The court also seized 30,000 copies of the group's free magazine, which had a cartoon of the mayor on the cover

The case has a political background. Metrópole chairman Mário Kertész was himself Salvador's mayor twice (1979-1981 and 1986-1989), and he has never hesitated to use his media to settle personal scores with his successor, whom he calls the "unspeakable one" in his blog.

On June 15, a court in the southeastern state of São Paulo banned Folha de Vinhedo, a weekly based in the city of Vinhedo, from publishing an interview in which Paulo Cabral, the Vinhedo municipal government's former legal secretary, accused various local officials and businessmen of corruption.

The ban was requested by two businessmen named in the interview, Rogério Sanches Cunha and Osias Daudt, and a local judge, Herivelto Araújo Godoy, whose lawyer said Cabral was "under the influence of alcohol" when he gave the interview.

Ruling that the interview would "sully the credibility of the Vinhedo judicial authorities and prosecutor's office," judge Ana Lúcia Xavier Goldman ordered "preventive censorship" of the newspaper on June 1st and 15. She also preemptively ordered a fine of about US$ 300 for each copy of the newspaper published in violation of the ban.

On March 4, São Paulo state judge Maria Isabel Caponero Cogan issued an ordered preventing privately-owned TV Record from broadcasting an investigative report implicating Itaquaquecetuba mayor Armando Tavares Filho in alleged corruption and illegal enrichment.

On 9 February, a court in the southern state of Santa Catarina banned the Gazeta de Joinville daily newspaper from mentioning the names of Joinville mayor Marco Tebaldi, his wife and Taiza Thomsen, a former Miss Brazil, after it referred to an alleged affair between the mayor and the former beauty queen. The "preventive censorship" order was accompanied by a preemptive fine of US$ 1042 for each day it violated the ban.

Tags:

  • Show Comments (2)

  • forest Brown

    PREEMPTIVE FINE !!!!!!!!!
    if it was me and i had to pay the fine for one day i would have made it full front page pic in color , and the next two pages the rest of the storie.

    now back to the net press cant stop what you cant see comming at you . nothing like bad very bad press to get the goverment to act right or stop what they are doing .

    with all the people out of work in brasil we could shadow them 24/7 till we got them on film .

    then make it news to all of brasil

  • bo

    Once again…
    the brazilian judiciary at work trying to hide the corruption that goes on in this country. “Amizade”….gotta love it! One just has to shake his head when you hear some try and not only equate, but try and say that the brazilian press is more “free” than the american press.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

US Investigates Shrimp Dumping by Brazil

Investigators from the Department of Commerce of the United States are in Brazil as ...

Brazil Adopts DuPont System to Protect Food Chain Against Pathogens

The Brazilian Ministry of Agriculture has selected the DuPont Qualicon RiboPrinter system, for its ...

Brazil’s PT Is Dying of Arrogance and Disregard for the Future

It appears that the Workers Party (PT) has suddenly died. That sentence, however, contains ...

Venezuela Not Ready for Prime Time in a Mercosur Dominated by Brazil

Venezuela’s July 4 official accession to the Mercado Común del Sur (Mercosur), of which ...

While Others Might Struggle Brazil Is Ready to Thrive in a Greener Planet

The world leaders have confirmed the prisoner’s dilemma; unfortunately the entire world will face ...

Brazil’s Petrobras Says Buying Out Shell in South America Is a Strategic Decision

Brazilian government owned oil-company Petrobras confirmed the acquisition of Anglo-Dutch oil giant Royal Dutch ...

Brazil Just Set a New Record of Energy Consumption

Brazil’s National Electricity System Operator (ONS) reported a new record of consumption this past ...

Agriculture Represents 36% of All Brazilian Exports

2008 was excellent for Brazil in foreign trade of agribusiness products. Sector exports reached ...

Brazil: US Confederates Find a Home

The Stanleys departed for Brazil on the rainy morning of April 6, 1876. They ...

Spain Invests US$ 74 in Brazilian Tourism

The Prime Minister of Spain, José Luiz Zapatero, disembarked yesterday in BrasÀ­lia to pay ...