Brazil Supreme Greenlights Stem Cell Research

Stem cell research in Brazil The Brazilian Supreme Federal Court voted by a narrow margin to uphold legislation allowing research on embryonic stem cells on May 29, after almost three years of deadlock.

Research using embryonic stem cells is permitted under the country's Biosafety Legislation, approved in March 2005, although several limitations are applied, such as only using embryos created by in vitro fertilization – and frozen for three years – that would be discarded anyway.

The research has remained controversial however – particularly with religious and anti-abortion groups – as the process involves removing stem cells from embryos at a few days old, which destroys them.

The 2005 decision was contested in the same year by Brazil's then attorney general, Claudio Fonteles, who said that the legislation was against the right to life and human dignity, and therefore unconstitutional.

The ministers of the supreme court began discussing Fonteles's petition in March. But voting was interrupted at the request of the minister Carlos Alberto Direito, who wanted more time to evaluate the case.

Two days of intense debate resulted in a final tally of six out of 11 votes in favor of upholding the 2005 approval, with no amendments. The remaining five ministers voted to uphold the basic legislation but with restrictions.

The main concern raised was the need to control scientific studies. The minister Cezar Peluzo highlighted the importance of having a system for evaluating and approving requests on embryonic stem cell studies, such as an ethics commission.

"It's key to impose conditions for the research activities," affirmed the minister Ricardo Lewandowski during the voting.

Scientists, patient groups and the minister of health, José Gomes Temporão, celebrated the decision.

"The decision is a victory for life, since it meets the expectations of thousands of patients who have hope for curing their diseases. The research on stem cells opens several possibilities for finding answers for diseases that currently have no treatments. The result allows Brazilian science to take a new position in the international scenario," said Temporão in a statement.

The National Conference of the Bishops of Brazil (CNBB) "regretted" the decision.

"The decision in the Supreme Court exhibited a significant divergence on the issue, showing that there are ministers who have ethical positions similar to the CNBB. That is, it is not about religious matters, but about promotion and defense of human life," says a statement distributed by the CNBB.

SciDev.Net

Tags:

You May Also Like

Brazil Wants Indians in College

The Ministry of Education (MEC) is encouraging Indian students to acquire higher education, so ...

In 2007 Brazil Exports Grew 17% to US$ 161 Billion and Imports, 32%

Exports from Brazil generated US$ 160.65 billion in 2007, exceeding the government forecasts of ...

Brazilian Industry Grows 8.8% This Year

Industrial production in Brazil ended the month of August up 1.1%, compared with July. ...

LETTERS

CDs or Books by Keyword, Title or Author By Brazzil Magazine The destruction of ...

In Haiti Till They Send Us Home, Says Brazil’s Lula

Brazilian troops leading the U.N. peacekeeping force in Haiti will stay there for as ...

Killers of Brazilian Journalist Who Exposed Child Prostitution Get 18 Years of Jail

A Brazilian people’s jury, after two days of trial, declared three military policemen and ...

Lula Calls Brazil’s Dental Condition Shocking

Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, speaking to the nation on his fortnightly ...

Arabs Find Out Brazil Is a Good Place to Grow Their Petrodollars

The relation between Brazil and the Arab countries has crossed the boundaries of trade ...

Brazil’s E-Commerce Jumps 27%. US$ 2.5 Billion Sold in First Half

Brazil's electronic commerce grew 27% in the first half, compared with the same period ...