Brazil Rushes to Heal Wounds After WTO Talks Collapse in Geneva

Argentina and Brazil presidents, Kirchner and Lula Brazil's Foreign Affairs minister Celso Amorim believes that Mercosur must do its utmost to find a common position and talk as an only voice following the aftermath of the recent Doha round effort in Geneva where Brazil and Argentina stood on different sides.

Amorim statements not only follow the Geneva global trade talks collapse but are also an anticipation of Brazilian President Lula da Silva's official visit to Argentina next Sunday. Both countries are the main axis of Mercosur.

Talking with the Brazilian press Amorim said it was a "paradox" that Mercosur has a common united position in the Free Trade of the Americas Association negotiations and with the European Union, but "in the WTO we are incapable of such unity."

"If we consider such meeting (of WTO in Geneva) as a lesson, I agree, we must work to achieve a common, united position," underlined Amorim who described the different position with Argentina as possibly "a legacy of the past when we were divided and we all spoke for ourselves."

The WTO ministerial Geneva meeting contention had Brazil on one side, and Argentina, China and India on the other, leading emerging countries rejection of a last minute deal worked out by WTO head Pascal Lamy to unlock the talks.

Argentina's main negotiator Alfredo Chiaradia in Geneva admitted that the different positions with Brazil "generate tension inside Mercosur."

Amorim who supported Lamy said Brazil did the "right thing" and if negotiations had advanced "would have done everything possible to contemplate Argentina's interests."

WTO talks broke down when developing nations such as India, China and Argentina were unable to agree on measures to protect farmers from emerging economies. The measures would have imposed tariffs to protect farmers in case of a sudden surge in goods on the market or a drop in prices. United States was adamant in demanding an elimination of any possible transitory tariffs.

Both India and China are believed to be fearful of their rural populations which have so far been left out of the economic success of urban and industrial areas.

"There was certain intransigence on both sides," said Amorim referring to United States and India.

However, "Brazil didn't distance itself from India or Argentina," underlined Amorim. "In our position we could not come out as total hostages of the Argentine stance in a crucial moment for the overall negotiations. Besides Brazil could not justify rejecting a draft which we considered acceptable."




You May Also Like

The Seemingly Futile Battle of Brazil Against Impunity

For the Brazilian people justice is generally slow or lacking. Throughout the years there ...

Brazilian senator Heloísa Helena running for president of Brazil

Heloísa: The Leftist Maverick Senator Vying to Be Brazil’s First Woman President

Heloísa Helena, a leftist senator from the impoverished northeast state of Alagoas, Brazil, has ...

Brazil Congress Wants US Pilots Indicted for Murder in Air Accident

Brazil's Inquiry Parliamentary Commission (CPI) on the Brazilian Air Traffic has concluded its report ...

Value of Brazil Companies Up 130% in 2009. Compare this to 28% in the US

The aggregate value of Brazilian listed companies rose by almost 130% in 2009, according ...

Pixinguinha: still an inspiration

When it was announced in the 1920s that a black musician was going to ...

Brazil Vows to Keep Fighting First-World Trade Barriers

The trade barriers that need to be overcome and the effort required to reach ...

Carnaval Biz: It Brings Close to US$ 500,000 to Rio, Brazil

The Rio de Janeiro Carnaval celebration, in Brazil, is certainly spectacular. It is also ...

A Sweet and Nostalgic Trip to 16th Century Brazil and Slavery

Brazilian historian-sociologist- anthropologist Gilberto Freyre (1900-1987) wrote in his book “Assucar” (Sugar), in 1939, ...

Brasília’s Legislature Next Improbable Task: Punishing Governor and Self

Brazilian capital Brasília’s legislature will get back to work on Monday, January 11, after ...

Copenhagen: What a Farce! Obama Fizzles, China Sulks, Only Lula Shines

The most progressive US president in a generation comes to the most important international ...