A Candid Talk with Gerald Thomas, Brazil’s Brightest Prima-Donna

Brazilian Gerald ThomasTrying to explain one’s art and motivation, while defending a particularly individualistic view of the same, can be a time-consuming impediment to progress for any professional artist, as it surely must be for most people inside or outside the public domain.

But to say that Gerald Thomas, the talented director, writer, producer, illustrator and designer, has a particularly “individualistic” point of view, is clearly an understatement: he is absolutely, without hesitation, Brazil’s most controversial contemporary stage figure.

His copious plays and uniquely identifiable pieces, along with an impressive and ever-expanding body of operatic work – not to mention his Dry Opera Company and frequent collaborations with composer Philip Glass – have certainly enlivened the dramatic and performing arts to no end.

With constant “exposure” of his avant-garde ideas in the press and in the theater, however, Thomas has been forced at times into expressing his own level of frustration in no uncertain terms, as evidenced by his much-publicized butt-baring episode at Rio’s Teatro Municipal in August 2003.

Residing in London for most of the remainder that year, he returned to New York in March 2004, for the opening of his play Anchorpectoris (The United States of the Mind) at LaMaMa Experimental Theater, on E. Fourth Street in Greenwich Village – the scene of his first stage triumphs with ex-mentor Ellen Stewart and the works of playwright Samuel Beckett.

In this, his most recent interview, completed in the U.S. after the successful run of his Um Circo de Rins e Fígados (A Circus of Kidneys and Livers) in Brazil, Thomas quite candidly delves into, and expands upon, a wide range of subjects, i.e. his early career as an illustrator and in the opera house; his major artistic and literary influences; his personal recollections of John Lennon’s death and 9/11; his criticism of Brazil’s Minister of Culture, Gilberto Gil; his future plans for the coming year and beyond, among which are his long-awaited stage-acting and directorial film debuts; and the release of his new book, Suicide Note.

Politics mingled with art – ah, there’s the Thomas rub; and if ever there were an example of the two intertwining and becoming indisputably one, then Gerald Thomas would be held up as the premier exponent, Brazil’s poster-boy for artistic and political activism.

U2’s Bono Vox, beware!

Brazzil – The first thing I’d like to know more about, as I’m sure our readers would, too, is the origin of your name: is it really Gerald Thomas?

Gerald Thomas – It’s my first and middle name. The full name is Gerald Thomas Sievers.

Brazzil – Have you had any identity crises or cultural clashes because of your American-sounding moniker?

Gerald Thomas – I’ve always been a Nowhere Man or, when I was a kid in school, a Nowhere Boy. I came to realize that very soon, because I never, ever fitted in. I was always from “abroad,” from “another culture.” At home, we never ate what the people of the country we lived in ate and that made me feel terrible. I remember the very first time I was invited (by the neighbors on the ground floor in Leblon, Rio) to come and eat dinner with them. I was stunned at the amount, the variety of different foods on the table, amongst which, black beans. We had been in Rio for about a year and all I knew was boiled potatoes and meat of some sort or another. Suddenly, this colorful rainbow opens up and I felt so great about Brazil.

Brazzil – You learned recently that you were born in New York City but moved to Rio at an early age. Despite most articles (including my own) claiming you were from Brazil, how has living in places like the Big Apple, Rio de Janeiro and London contributed to a better or worse sense of your own individual identity?

Gerald Thomas – In Brazil, I have to say that I was born there, given the nature of my criticism of the government and Gilberto Gil, the minister of himself. No foreigner would ever be able to say such things without being thrown overboard. But a real and intriguing question does exist about the place where I was born: I do have three birth certificates and I do carry a German passport. It’s weird in a way to feel as though you belong to all of those places and, yet, the only place I can really call home are a couple of blocks on the East Side of Manhattan, between St Mark’s Place and E. Third Street on Second Avenue. I guess my parents must have registered me every time my father (the non-biological one) was moved by Lloyd’s Insurance from one country to another. That may have been a smart move.

Brazzil – Indeed it was. But have you ever experienced a feeling of loss when you go abroad because of your country of origin or your Jewish background, in view of the apparent pride you have in being Brazilian?

Gerald Thomas – I know that the Jewish thing should play an enormous role here…but it doesn’t really. I guarantee you that I would be a rich man now if I had played that card but reality has it that I never felt very comfortable with those rituals. My bar mitzvah was awkward, I felt terribly awkward, having to memorize all that stuff phonetically. Plus the “father that brought me up” (the man of my life!) wasn’t Jewish himself and, during the years as a volunteer at Amnesty International in London, I got to know a lot of Catholic priests who were protecting political prisoners in Brazil. I thought that those people were so great. They showed me Italy for the first time. It was through their eyes that I saw the Vatican, its little holes and labyrinths…

Brazzil – It’s a fascinating place. Since then, you’ve been all over the world, practically, and you’re always on the move. Are you comfortable with the ever-increasing globetrotting demands of your career?

Gerald Thomas – Always less comfortable because traveling nowadays is a problem, it consumes far more energy out of you with all the “checkpoints,” and cities are growing out of control, making traffic impossible, irritatingly so. I used to be productive in planes: open up the laptop and work. Nowadays, the guy sitting next to me in business class is just concerned with getting drunk. So no, thanks. I’m not going to wait until his margarita spills all over my PC.

Brazzil – I don’t blame you. In contrast, throughout his life composer Richard Wagner was often referred to as a man “possessed.” Are you similarly possessed, and by what?

Gerald Thomas – I try to stay away from things like that. And as for what’s written about mythological characters, one never knows. Was it really so? Some people are furious, some are angry, others are simply frustrated and have tantrums and History can turn all that into “being possessed.” I am as cool as can be because when I have dealt with the actors, I remain in the theater and deal with all the other technical aspects of the play or opera I’m staging.

Brazzil – That’s probably the best approach. With opera being such an international endeavor, how many languages are you fluent in?

Gerald Thomas – I really only speak three languages: English, Portuguese and German. The rest is parroting my way around the world.

Brazzil – Yet you speak with a slight British accent. Would it have been more difficult for you career-wise if your name had been Caetano or Chico and you had spoken with a Brazilian accent, or spoken no English at all?

Gerald Thomas – Well, that is difficult to answer since there are thousands of British or American or Australian or Canadian directors in the world who’ve achieved nothing in spite of their well-spoken English. I think that I owe my position in the world to my talent. Bluntly speaking, that’s it.

Brazzil – I agree. Speaking of talent, who was the person or persons whose views influenced you the most as a youth?

Gerald Thomas – Samuel Beckett and Caetano Veloso, Hélio Oiticica and Haroldo de Campos. Marcel Duchamp, Marcel Duchamp and Marcel Duchamp. Saul Steinberg. Steinberg and Steinberg.

Brazzil – That’s quite an impressive list. Where did opera first come in and how did you eventually come to stage it?

Gerald Thomas – That was in 1987 in Rio, and The Flying Dutchman was the victim. A very conceptual piece to begin with, I decided to stage it in such a way that the place was Berlin, East and West, divided by the Wall. The dead man (the Dutchman) and his vessel would appear on the East Side, and Senta would be waiting for him on one of those wooden platforms built by the Allies, forced to look over onto the other side. But all of that was metalanguage, since it all played as an installation watched by a “false” audience inside a mega-exhibition hall: the Kassel Documenta. So, two years before the fall of the Wall, it had already become an “installation of the past, an artwork worth nothing compared to the thousands dead trying to cross it.”

Brazzil – Have your musical and operatic tastes subsequently evolved over the years?

Gerald Thomas – Yes and no. I have gone back and decided on opposite extremes such as Mahler and Schoenberg. I could sit all day and just vary between recordings of their works…

Brazzil – You seem to show a strong “affinity” for modern music, i.e. Arnold Schoenberg, Philip Glass, Karlheinz Stockhausen, Ferruccio Busoni, and others, which you’ve used frequently in your pieces. Is there a specific reason for this?

Gerald Thomas – But I also steal from Wagner and from Mendelssohn and from Haydn. There isn’t a specific choice for the moderns, though it gives me pleasure to work with someone who is alive and well, rather than some corpse.

Brazzil – Have you ever used or thought of using Brazilian classical or popular music in any of your works?

Gerald Thomas – Other than Villa-Lobos, I know very little about Brazilian classical music. You were the one telling me about Carlos Gomes. I do know how to drum the samba, since I am one of a very few allowed into Mangueira to be part of the drum section of their victorious samba school.

Brazzil – Then you must know Marisa Monte, whose father was connected at one time to Velha Guarda (The Old Guard) da Portela Samba School in Rio?

Gerald Thomas – I was an “adviser” to her, when she first put her legs and voice on stage, through the hands of Nelson Motta: that was in 1986.

Brazzil – You started out as a graphic artist and illustrator – a very good one, I might add. How has this early background in art and design bolstered your work on the stage?

Gerald Thomas – Difficult question: I’ve told you before – or maybe I haven’t – that, at age fourteen, I managed to creep my way into the rehearsals of Victor Garcia’s version of Genet’s The Balcony in São Paulo. Undoubtedly one of the greatest stagings of the 20th Century, this vertical production not only caused a hell of an impression on me, but I also learned a great deal about the theater while being there every day (and night, ALL night!!!). I learned what “modern and experimental theater” was and how that integrated with the visual arts, somehow. In other words, I was experiencing a live Bosch painting, as it were. Then, two years later, in London, I sort of “infiltrated” the Royal Shakespeare Company while Peter Brook was rehearsing his Midsummer Night’s Dream. So, all the visual arts and dramatic arts came together as a whole.

Brazzil – You once worked at The New York Times, The Boston Globe and other newspapers. Do you still find time to illustrate for publications that are outside your normal field?

Gerald Thomas – No fun no more! I illustrate the programs of my own plays and the posters and I “design” or draw each and every one of the scenes that are to be staged…but that’s about it as far as drawing is concerned, commercially. I have a lot of recent material, but I keep all that to myself. Who knows one day there will be an exhibit?

Brazzil – Most recently, you’ve designed the posters and programs for Um Circo de Rins e Fígados (A Circus of Kidneys and Livers), staged at Teatro SESC/Pinheiros.

Gerald Thomas – Yes, I’m involved in every single aspect of the theater, even in the soundtrack. Too involved!!! Some call me obsessed but I just find it normal since it’s an object of my creation and nobody else knows exactly what’s going on in this head of mine. So, instead of spending hours explaining, I might as well just do it myself.

Brazzil – Do you prefer doing it all yourself, or do you leave certain tasks to others?

Gerald Thomas – Well, let’s say I delegate a little.

Brazzil – Is this a form of “control” over the creative process?

Gerald Thomas – Look: we play being God! So, in the black box we can control the temperature, the smoke, the lights, the volume, the exactness of everything. That’s why I am present as much as I can at every performance. I have a little corner where I hide and even communicate with the players and gesture to them frantically, according to how the performance is going that night. Since I give all the cues, I can change things on the spot. I tell the actors in a clear voice that they can understand (when the PA system is loud enough) and, there it is: a brand new scene, created on the spot, on that very night for that specific audience, depending if there was some MAJOR news that day.

Brazzil – Moving on to Brazilian pop music, bossa nova, seventies rock and Tropicália, were you attracted to any one style over another?

Gerald Thomas – I was very involved with the Tropicalistas. Still think that this was one of the most innovative movements ever! On the other hand, I was going to The Royal Albert Hall to some classical symphony, or to Berlin to watch Herbert von Karajan, or to see and listen to Jimi Hendrix or Led Zeppelin here at the Filmore or at the Earl’s Court Arena.

Brazzil – Do you still enjoy the music of the Beatles? Hendrix? John Lennon?

Gerald Thomas – I progressed as times progressed. I loved Nirvana and Pearl Jam and so many new bands out there that this interview would become as long as the Yellow Pages. But I still go back to the old icons, sure!

Brazzil – You do resemble Lennon, you know, especially in your earliest photographs. You once portrayed him on the stage, did you not?

Gerald Thomas – Yes, that was meant to be a joke. “Os Reis do Ié Ié Ié” (A Hard Day’s Night) was the reunion of the Dry Opera Company and it was to have had only TWO performances. But you know how things go. Offers come in and the whores that we are…we end up accepting them!

Brazzil – You posted a poignant remembrance of the 25th anniversary of his death on your blog, http://www.geraldthomas.com. Do you remember the shooting?

Gerald Thomas – As if it was yesterday! It was a spooky day for me, because it so happens that I had brought a former political prisoner from Brazil, a poet himself – Alex Polari de Alverga and wife – and all he wanted was to be photographed in front of the Dakota building. So, that’s what we did that day. Almost all afternoon we were there, outside Lennon’s door. Little did I know what was to follow: When I dropped the couple off at an apartment that I was vacating and driving myself to my new Village loft, I heard Scot Muny come to the microphone and make the announcement. Unbelievable. I rushed over to the Upper West Side (out of instinct, I don’t know…) and found a bunch of people there in tears…

Brazzil – You were an eyewitness to 9/11, and from your apartment window, if I’m not mistaken. How did that terrible event affect you personally?

Gerald Thomas – I am not the same any more. I’m on medication. I lost friends. Witnessing what I did, as did millions of other New Yorkers…it changed my life, Joe. It changed the world. Look at the world today. Look at how Bush played the cards in his favor. Sometimes I’m up at night rethinking the entire scene, over and over and over and over, and when paranoia sets in with those photos of the Pentagon and those commercials on TV (reopen 9/11.com, or something to that effect) and think that some of it could possibly have been staged!!!!! The whole entire affair of how this country invaded Iraq under false premises of WMDs and other lies, resulting in the mess that we’re now in. The world now hates America more than in any other time in recent History and this fucking fool…

Brazzil – How did these feelings about 9/11 compare to what you felt after Lennon’s untimely end?

Gerald Thomas – If the “dream was ever over,” it is NOW.

Brazzil – Have these two tragedies soured you on living in large cities?

Gerald Thomas – Which two tragedies do you mean, 9/11 and Lennon? I wouldn’t even begin to compare…Terrorism is something so fucking abominable and incomparable to individual murder by a crazy lunatic!

Brazzil – Let’s talk about literature and poetry, something that has occupied you personally and professionally for the better part of 40 years. When did you first learn about concrete poetry and the de Campos brothers?

Gerald Thomas – I was fourteen years old, living here in NYC with Hélio Oiticica, and he wouldn’t stop talking about the de Campos brothers. And he had some of their early works. So, I picked up whatever I could and started to read them, or leaf through those “pages.” I was fascinated, as you can imagine, because there I saw a mixture of words and images, almost something in 3-D, touchable and so “lucid,” inexplicably so. Words meaning others and it came to my perception, that early on there was this “thing” called metalanguage. I was addicted at that age. Have been since.

Brazzil – What other literary figures impressed you the most as an artist?

Gerald Thomas – Oh, as you know, there is Beckett – which also later developed into a personal relationship lasting until his death – Joyce, Gertrude Stein, Pound, Conrad, Hegel, Kafka, Kafka, Kafka, and the Greeks, and as I sat in the British Museum Reading Room doing my studies, so many authors came across my eyes: it would be silly to name all of them. It would also trivialize them. But there was this one William Shakespeare who still hasn’t left me and I am not intending to leave him either.

Brazzil – You’ve presented numerous works by your close friend Samuel Beckett, along with Shakespeare, Brecht, Kafka, Heiner Mueller, and others. What contributions have they made toward the overall formation of your art?

Gerald Thomas – No, I’ve never done Brecht (not that I can remember), but I have been a guest of the Berliner Ensemble, during the days when Berlin was still divided by the Wall. Well, all of those playwrights are – combined – part of what I am. If put together, vertically and horizontally, with what I have lived through empirically, the stories I was brought up with (the holocaust) and the theater I built into my wardrobe as a child in order to “be somewhere”…what I’m trying to say is that ALL of which I have read and seen (and still do) causes an enormous impression on me. That’s why I still don’t know exactly what to make of 9/11 and seeing the WTC being hit. Being that the WTC were the towers of my generation: except for the Citicorp building, the rest of NYC was all built. I saw those two faceless monsters going up: they were the Warhol buildings (multiplications) or the Godot buildings: “nothing in two acts,” as Walter Kerr once described it in the New York Times. He later resigned, this critic that is, because he realized that Godot was indeed THE masterpiece of the 20th Century and he didn’t have perception then, in the fifties. He said goodbye to his readers by saying that he must have ruined hundreds of lives of talented authors and actors and the like.

Brazzil – You’re a prolific writer yourself, as well as a playwright and journalist, having contributed a number of articles to Folha de S. Paulo, Jornal do Brasil and other publications. Have you ever considered giving up show business for a career in journalism as a critic or political commentator?

Gerald Thomas – Never! I keep a journal. This journal is, finally, going to be published next year. The title is “Suicide Note.” I was offered a column in the most prestigious page in the most prestigious paper in the world (just guess), but in order to do that, I would have to give everything else up. I would have to be a “political traveler.” As much exposure as that would give me and throw me right into the limelight of mainstream AmeriKa, I declined because I cannot justify breathing on this planet without the theater or the opera. So, I will continue doing my work and other people, such as Wladimir Krysinski, yourself, David George, Haroldo de Campos, Flora Sussekind, and so many others, will contribute with their opinion. “O Encenador de Si Mesmo” (The Staging of the Self) is a compilation of such texts.

Brazzil – Your stage productions bear the hallmarks of silent cinema, German expressionism, surrealism, film noir and theater of the absurd. Have I left anything out?

Gerald Thomas – Yes, you’ve left “me” out.

Brazzil – I stand corrected! In fact, you’ve peeled away most theatrical elements down to their barest essentials – that is, little or no dialogue, stylized acting, non-specific sets, and dramatic, sophisticated lighting. Is this what you’ve tried to accomplish with your Dry Opera Company?

Gerald Thomas – No, that is because I’ve chosen such scenes to go on a tape to travel commercially around the world. I chose precisely the most viable scenes to go on such a tape: but if you saw the pieces in their entirety, you’d see a lot (and some people actually have complained in the eighties that there was verbal hemorrhage) of text in those plays.

Brazzil – A while back, a New York Times piece hinted at your early fascination with light and shadow – and there is certainly no shortage of light, shadow and smoke on display throughout most of your works. Are you still as captivated by these effects as you once were, or have you moved beyond this aspect of your art to other things?

Gerald Thomas – I think that, like everyone else, I go through phases. This latest play, “A Circus of Kidneys and Livers,” has very little of those: it’s basically the text and the actors that matter.

Brazzil – Good point. That said, the late Orson Welles was once described as the “boy wonder” of the stage, a master at multi-tasking who could act, write, paint, design, produce, direct, market and promote his works – all at the same time. As formidably talented as he undoubtedly was, Welles spent his entire life actively selling the myth of his supposed “genius” to all comers. Would you categorize yourself as a genius in the Welles mold, i.e. someone who writes, directs, produces, markets, promotes, illustrates and innovates, with the same non-stop intensity as he showed in his youth?

Gerald Thomas – No, but I fake it just as he – later in life – claimed he did. F for Fake is a great film. I would throw rotten eggs at any artist who would consider himself a genius! Seriously! At this day and age, after deconstructivism, iconoclasty…genius? Give me a break!

Brazzil – Besides physically, what characteristics differentiate you from a Welles?

Gerald Thomas – Well, if I had accomplished Citizen Kane at age 24, I would seriously give myself up as satisfied. It’s one of the best movies ever, EVER made. I’ve never thought of myself as anything close to Welles. In fact, while he was still alive, I almost came close to inviting him to play Hamm, in Beckett’s Endgame. That was right after directing the legendary Julian Beck, who died while we were touring with “The Beckett Trilogy,” 1985 (Christ! 20 years ago!).

Brazzil – Many felt that Welles peaked early on and never recaptured the inspiration he initially showed with his classic Kane. You’re 51 now – that’s more than twice Welles’ age at the height of his fame – and you’ve accomplished so much more in the theater than he ever did. What would you still like to do that you haven’t done as yet, theatrically?

Gerald Thomas – You must be joking! Welles was truly an INTERNATIONAL CELEB, and with clout. Whether what he did or didn’t do in the theater was good or not, I don’t know. The photos make things look rather kitsch. People who have seen it and described it to me say that it stank! But who am I to judge? Look at where the boundaries of my work stop and look at Welles!!!!!! My obit will be one paragraph long (if that!), while his…

Brazzil – Your most favorable reviews have been for works that thrive on controversial subjects. Do you identify personally with the struggles of the protagonists of Moses und Aron, Doktor Faust, Tristan und Isolde and Don Giovanni?

Gerald Thomas – I actually do. Moses especially, with the stuttering problem. And with the fact that it was a “spoken/notated” part, especially difficult to memorize for a player, when the entire orchestra is blasting notes of a completely different nature. Plus, that biblical subject matter does interest me very much – always has – so…Schoenberg’s life itself has always interested me, or, rather, fascinated me. So, putting it all together: Busoni and Schoenberg go hand-in-hand; Faust by Goethe is my favorite book (and until this date I have not entirely deciphered it, either in German or in English, or in Haroldo de Campos’s version: “Deus e o Diabo na terra de Fausto” – God and the Devil in the Land of Faust). There you have the perfect subjects for me to delve into the darkest areas of the humanities, so to speak.

Brazzil – You actually changed Faust’s profession from alchemist to artist – a painter, to be exact. Was this a conscious choice on your part, a sort of autobiographical statement?

Gerald Thomas – Certainly autobiographical.

Brazzil – Were you deliberately placing yourself into the stage action, and are you a frustrated actor at heart?

Gerald Thomas – Not anymore! I premiere, as an actor, next April in “Asfaltaram o Beijo” (They Cemented the Kiss), an homage I pay to Beckett and the years we spent meeting in Paris.

Brazzil – Do you regard yourself as more of an individualist and outsider, much in the manner of a Moses or a Faust?

Gerald Thomas – A total outsider, always. I was talking to Philip Glass just now and was telling him about the success “Circus” had, and how one has to constantly renew this pact with the world “within”, with the audience and with the press…It’s as if the world were a big memory bank that, given a month or two of our absence, would forget us altogether.

Brazzil – Have you thought about tackling other characters of this type, for example, Britten’s Peter Grimes, Wagner’s Tannhäuser, or Berg’s Wozzeck?

Gerald Thomas – I am ready for all three of them.

Brazzil – Aren’t you really more like Moses’ brother, Aron, a sort of manipulator of language and the spoken word?

Gerald Thomas – The image of me in the press certainly may appear so. But that has to do with the fact that the press is lazy. I ask you: how can any one person manipulate the press? How do you do that? With money? Drugs? Chocolate? Sex? How exactly? What does that phrase mean? As in a previous answer, I am timid and profoundly involved with sensitive questions about the nature of who we are. I am also very traumatized about the nature of who we are and what we are capable of doing. Aron wasn’t concerned with any of that: he merely wanted to sell his golden calf.

Brazzil – Nothing you’ve done on the stage could possibly be construed as being a part of the mainstream. Has this “inaccessibility” to the general public, as it were, bothered you in any way?

Gerald Thomas – Sometimes the media builds this image out of nothing, just as it always has throughout History with not-so-easily-consumable-artists. But when some audience member walks in open-hearted, he/she will find that my work isn’t all that inaccessible after all.

Brazzil – Wouldn’t you prefer to be less on the cutting-edge and enjoy rather more widespread critical success?

Gerald Thomas – Joe, I’ve been given all the awards there were. The Molières and the (forget the names, really). I dropped the last Molière just to show the audience in Paris that it was made of chalk and not marble, and said quite bluntly that I hated to be endorsed by the middle classes. Those awards are given out by critics. I have no complaints, except for financial ones.

Brazzil – In your opinion, is the notoriety you’ve obtained the best measure of triumph in your case, or are there other modes of measurements?

Gerald Thomas – I think that everyone who earns a certain amount of notoriety does so because of a number of factors: the media constructs its own circus and makes you into a “complex” and complicated “personality” (o polêmico) and the rest, of course, has to do with the work, with the fact that I am, in a way, untouchable, because I work in so many countries and have the endorsement of the top critics and the top houses in the world.

Brazzil – Your frustration did manifest itself strongly at Rio’s Teatro Municipal in 2003, where you bared your buttocks after being roundly booed for Tristan. Could you explain what led to that encounter?

Gerald Thomas – I had received news that Haroldo de Campos had died just before the opening. That had already left me in a state. The boos don’t bother me. They actually amuse me. You can see that in the tape I sent you where I deliberately include minutes of it, as I enter the stage, during the curtain call after Flying Dutchman. But when I hear a rehearsed chorus from the first few rows, “little Jew boy, go back to the camp” (judeuzinho, volta pro campo!), that…made my blood pressure rise up and…I lost it. And the rest is History. It took me a year to get acquitted, and in Brasília, by the Supreme Court!

Brazzil – Did the ruckus have anything to do with the appearance of a third major character introduced by you into the drama, namely Dr. Sigmund Freud?

Gerald Thomas – Absolutely yes! And the fact that I used cocaine as an analogy for the love/death potion given by Brangäne to Isolde. A mess from the start. Pressure from the start because the artistic director of the Municipal knew my concept an entire month before I left London, since I had published it in my column, at the time, in the now nearly defunct Jornal do Brasil (a paper financed by Rio’s former governor Anthony Garotinho).

Brazzil – That was quite an unusual touch, wouldn’t you say, to have the title characters analyzed by modern history’s most famous shrink?

Gerald Thomas – That’s my job! Otherwise, just have the conductor stage the damned thing, as Karajan did so many times. Why call me? To sell tickets and fill the house. The Municipal has never been so sold out EVER!!!!!

Brazzil – Do you find Brazilian audiences are less tolerant of these sorts of novelties than other audiences are, say, the Americans or the Europeans?

Gerald Thomas – No, they’re just as open minded. But not when it comes to Richard Wagner! Man! Wagner is stronger in Brazil than anywhere else…I mean, the traditionalists. But on the following nights we saw none of those problems. And may I point out that the troublemakers were just a handful within 2500 well behaved, opera-lovin’ people.

Brazzil – What are your views on the current state of classical music and opera in Brazil?

Gerald Thomas – Joe, you know as well as I do that Brazil moves in waves and nothing lasts. Some say this is a good thing, some say it’s bad. It’s certainly the opposite to Europe and their secular cultural struggles, which never seem to end. It’s still the eternal anti-Schiller play and so on, or the latest version of the “anti-Hamlet” for the 100th time. So, Brazil is very creative since this lack of tradition liberates its artists from this heavy commitment to battle these ghosts. Yet, I find that this also leaves an incredible emptiness which leads to the popularity of the soap opera culture (novelas) and the overwhelming LOVE Brazil has with television, more so than the U.S. (I find). So, as for your question, classical music and opera haven’t made a mark in Brazil because year in, year out there will be a Sala São Paulo, for instance, with heavy emphasis on classical programming – which is fantastic. But will it last past this current mayor? Or the next?

Brazzil – What can be done to improve the unfortunately low expectations for classical artists and the performing arts there?

Gerald Thomas – Famine and poverty are the first priorities. To hell with the arts!

Brazzil – Has the Ministry of Culture done much in the past few years to give aid and comfort to the arts?

Gerald Thomas – Gilberto Gil has certainly done a lot for himself! He is the Minister of Himself, and the ministry is called the “Ministério Gilberto Gil de Morte à Cultura” (The Gilberto Gil Ministry of Death to Culture). His fees for performing around the world have tripled and he simply loves to travel with Lula and shake hands with heads of state worldwide. It’s a scandal, it’s a shame and, yet, nobody says anything about it because the PT (Partido dos Trabalhadores – Workers’ Party) is a true Stalinist revengeful party and it wouldn’t amaze me if, soon, there were a blacklist: something equivalent to the McCarthy era here, except in reverse. Dreadful!

Brazzil – What are some of your future plans with respect to opera? Is there anything you can talk about openly?

Gerald Thomas – I’m involved in certain German operas at this moment that are almost embarrassing to mention: I call them train station noise (at 5 a.m., when the trains are pulling in) but I have to direct these so-called “avant-garde” things because they pay and they pay well. There is also an opera “in development” with Philip Glass, which is based on Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales, and Bayreuth says it wants me in about one hundred years from now.

Brazzil – This latest Thomas-Glass collaboration is exciting news for fans. In the past, many legitimate theater and film directors often ventured into opera. There was a time when Luchino Visconti, Franco Zeffirelli, Tyrone Guthrie and Margaret Webster were all actively involved with its staging. This trend has returned somewhat with the recent operatic participation of Werner Herzog, John Frankenheimer, William Friedkin and Anthony Minghella. Do you think film directors have a better “eye” for stage detail, so to speak, than the average opera or theater director has?

Gerald Thomas – I usually find that film directors are a total flop on the stage: here are two completely different languages. You might as well call a bricklayer to do the job! People are under the impression that “performing art” is one and the same. That is the biggest and dirtiest mistake ever. Imagine if you were to call Picasso to retouch or restore the Sistine Chapel, or Francis Bacon, for that matter. Michelangelo and the two I’ve mentioned are all involved in the “painting” media, but sectors are not to be confused.

Brazzil – Have you given any thought to directing your own movies?

Gerald Thomas – Yes, I begin shooting “Ghost Writer” in about a year from now. I’m still developing the screenplay.

Brazzil – What else would you like to direct, if given the chance?

Gerald Thomas – I’m an obsessive writer, so I’ll just continue to write my pieces. I think that History needs to move forward and we need to tell the stories of the times we live in, in whatever way we can. If we just keep on restaging The Seagull over and over and over, or the classics, we won’t be telling people 500 years from now what the 21st Century was about.

Brazzil – That’s so true. By the way, do you have many friends or acquaintances in the movie business?

Gerald Thomas – Yes, I’m very close to Hugh Hudson, who directed Chariots of Fire, amongst other wonderful films, such as American Revolution; and Cacá Diegues, the Brazilian filmmaker.

Brazzil – You made a cameo appearance in a film by Brazilian director Walter Salles. How did it feel to be directed by someone else instead of your doing the job yourself?

Gerald Thomas – Oh, please don’t remind me of that. If I could…if I had the money I’d buy those frames and cut myself out of that movie…I wasn’t directed. Someone just said “roll” and there I was.

Brazzil – You’re probably the most well known, most talked about, and most written about Brazilian stage personality on the world scene today. How do you feel about that lofty position?

Gerald Thomas – I am very lonely and suffer just like anybody else when I turn on the news. Frustration kicks in, just like with anybody else. I don’t feel special, in fact, I don’t feel anything: all of which I’ve done – I feel – has somehow been reduced to ashes. Don’t ask me why or how. It’s just a holocaustic feeling but, all the same, true. It’s vapor, it weighs nothing. I must reinvent myself, especially in this current world of NO values, of information overload, of shopping malls, of super-consumerism, iPods, Internet, where people don’t really learn (they just copy and paste or use it for chats). This globalization has flattened Columbus’ world. It’s one with no memory or a weak one: it’s drugged, drunk, money-driven or driven by one god against another. We’re back to the Middle Ages, except that we have modern tools. It’s a horrible place where my profession doesn’t exist, really. So, all that I read about myself – I feel – I’m reading about someone who doesn’t exist; i.e. someone else or a ghost: a GHOST WRITER.

Brazzil – I sense the theme of your screenplay at work. Has this constant exposure in the press hampered you to any degree? You don’t seem intimidated or ambivalent by all the attention – how do you maintain your composure as well as your personal privacy?

Gerald Thomas – It’s impossible to have privacy when you’re having dinner and people are coming up to you constantly wanting to take a snapshot of you (with them, preferably).

Brazzil – Thank you so much, Gerald, for your openness about yourself and your art.

Gerald Thomas – Thank you, Joe.

A naturalized American citizen born in Brazil, Joe Lopes was raised and educated in New York City, where he worked for many years in the financial sector. In 1996, he moved to Brazil with his wife and daughters. In 2001, he returned to the U.S. and now resides in North Carolina with his family. He is a lover of all types of music, especially opera and jazz, as well as an incurable fan of classic and contemporary films. You can email your comments to JosmarLopes@msn.com.

Copyright © 2006 by Josmar F. Lopes


You May Also Like


Of all changes occurred in the last two decades, the most impressive was the ...

A project to bring books to a Brazilian favela

Our Own Minimally Invasive Library Thrives in a Brazilian Favela

The idea originated from an article read during the time I was taking an ...

Exports Grow 19% and Imports 60% in Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil

Rio Grande do Sul state, in the south tip of Brazil, had a 60% ...

Brazilian Court’s Latest Decision: Amazon’s Belo Monte Dam Is Off

In the latest chapter of a decades-long dramatic battle between environmentalists and the government ...


Brazilian theater started to flourish in the ’30s with the production of texts by ...

Brazil Very Active at First Meeting of UN’s Human Rights Council

Brazil’s Minister of Foreign Relations, Celso Amorim, is participating today, June 19, in the ...


Those women dressed in tight clothes are now sambaing, vigorously. The whole place has ...

IMF Couldn’t Be More Pleased with Brazil

The Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) completed December 15 the ninth ...

Brazil’s Coalition Party Warns President and Threatens to Become Opposition

Brazilian president Dilma Rousseff is “playing with fire” in the way it addresses relations ...

Brazil’s Lula Wants Urgent ‘Democratization’ of the UN

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva said that the participation of developing countries ...