Out of Africa: Race in Brazil and the US

Out of Africa: Race in Brazil and the US

In Portuguese, the word for "race",
raça, is not surprisingly the same
as the word used for
"breed", and the word raça is used for both
animals and humans. The subtext of the word "race" is still

inherently imbued in eugenic ideology, otherwise known as
"social Darwinism." There is only one human "race."

Alan P. Marcus


The politics of "race" has currently been part of an intensely emotional discourse, described as either
"political-correctness-gone-astray" or "extreme-right-wing-racism". Recently there has been a heated controversy over
"affirmative action" in the USA and in Brazil. The controversial issue has again propelled the word "race" into the

The word "race" has emerged with a self-revealing past, perpetuated by its current popular use and political
context. If one forgets for just one moment, the political context of "affirmative action", or whether it is right or wrong, the
idea that "affirmative action" presupposes a plurality of so-called human "races" is interesting in itself.

It is interesting because the premise here is that there is actually more than one human "race".
Furthermore, most interesting is the confusion, hatred and misrepresentations generated from a word such as "race".
Recently, "race" has been used in political parlance for various political maneuvers and has become embedded in
contemporary usage as a pseudo-scientific term.

The word "race" has traveled, particularly in the past 500 years, through a troubled historical road, shrouded
at best, in European and North American ethnocentrism, and overtly at its worst, filled with violence and hatred.
At the end of the nineteenth century, racist, sexist and ethnocentric ideologies that focused on human
phenotypes to justify human intellectual and social rank, such as eugenic ideology (from the Greek
Eugenes: "of good stock"), and made headway into popular culture.

The word "race" is furthermore interesting because of its semantics and the popular sub textual connection
with the word "breed", used to describe animals (i.e.; beagle, poodle, collie). In the Portuguese language, the word
for "race", raça, is not surprisingly the same as the word used for "breed", and the word
raça is used for both animals and humans.

The subtext of the word "race" is still inherently imbued in eugenic ideology, otherwise known as "social
Darwinism" (not from Charles Darwin’s work, but a misrepresentation of it). That is, the belief of how and why
humans are "hard-wired" to pursue success or failure, based on ancestry alone, however, always used to justify
"success" of certain populations and thus shamefully tipped in favor of populations of "Nordic-European" ancestry. The
idea that popular and political perception applies the understanding of animal behavior to the understanding of
human behavior is not only flawed, but also invalid.

We may imagine that human genes are figuratively, the bullets in a gun, and social environment is the
trigger. Popular thinking addresses the different "breeds" of dogs with their respective stereotypical behavior and
personality traits (i.e.; pit bulls are aggressive and poodles are meek) and political thinking addresses human "races" within
its respective social paradigms.

However, humans are the least "hard-wired" beings on this planet and the least physically well-suited for the
"natural" world. The idea of eugenics or "social Darwinism" presupposing humans are "hard-wired" or "adapted" for
success or failure, as if humans were "adaptable" for modern life like a polar bear for the Artic cold or a mountain goat for
high altitudes, is nonsense, as is eugenics itself (i.e.; "of good stock").

The American Association of Physical Anthropologists has in fact called for the eradication of the term
"race", on the basis of it having no scientific validity. The more appropriate and scientific term is "ethnicity", which
denotes cultural as well as genetic dynamic complexities among humans. There is only one human "race" but several
different human ethnicities.

The word "race" has become entirely political in nature, with significant repercussions in the social, the
educational and the political realms. The politics of "race" has been used in the past for political agendas under the
guise to justify certain human differences. To
explain human differences, is not the same as to
justify these differences.

The social, income and educational differences in the USA and Brazil are tipped on a vertical level, not on a
horizontal level, and to attempt to address this "verticality" is to try to explain certain differences not based on one
variable alone (i.e.; "race"), but on several variables (i.e.; access to education and healthcare) and cultural
complexities. Oversimplifying complicated issues is always intellectually dangerous, and to reduce and isolate "race" matters
as "political-correctness-run-amuck" only illustrates shortsightedness.

The recent archaeological findings in the Afar region in Ethiopia, Africa, help us to understand how our
ancient ancestors from millions of years ago (Austrolopithecus
Afarensis), as well as our modern ancestors from a
few thousands of years ago, (only recently "discovered"), came from the African continent. The human migrations
that left Africa and eventually settled in various places around the world shaped the differences we currently "see"
as diversity. "Race" is an unfortunate and exclusionary fundamental in the understanding (or
misunderstanding) of modern politics, popular culture and history.

However, despite its fundamental political importance, its relevance in scientific understanding and its
contemporary popular semantics, the word "race" is in serious need of a patchwork to mend its structure. This
structure, rather than excluding, binds humanity to a unique common past, to the universals rather than the particulars,
and to a marvelous history we all share.


Alan P. Marcus is a Brazilian living in the USA. He is currently working on his Master’s of Science
at the Department of Geosciences, Human Geography, at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Contact
e-mail: amarcus@geo.umass.edu


document.write(“Email this article“);

Discuss it in our Forum

your comments to Brazzil

/ Go




Forum Site Map
/ Old
Old Forum1
Forum B
Old Board

/ 4
/ 3000
/ Archive
/ Privacy
/ Daniella
Investment in Brazil




You May Also Like

Lula Blames Inflation on Brazil’s High Interest Rates

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva said today that his Administration wants interest ...

Alive and well in the Internet

The Internet is giving Brazilian filmmakers a new lease on life. Sites showing Brazil’s ...

Experts Expecting Lower Interest Rates in Brazil

According to the average expectation of market analysts, Brazil’s official annualized benchmark interest rate ...

More Jobs and Better Wages in Brazil 2004

Brazil’s industrial employment registered stabiliy in November, 2004, compared with October. This finding of ...

Relatives of Brazilian Killed by London Police Keep Demanding ‘Truth and Justice’

A month has passed since police shot and killed Jean Charles de Menezes, a ...

Brazil’s Goal: To Export US$ 1 Billion in Jewels

Brazilian jewellery and precious stone exports generated US$ 237 million in the first four ...

China-Brazil Partnership Gets Bigger and Closer

A trade mission from the Chinese province of Hubei is in São Paulo, in ...

IADB Ends Week-Long Meeting in Brazil, Vowing More Loans for LatAm’s Infrastructure

The 47th Annual Meeting of the Inter-American Development Bank (IADB) ends today, April 5, ...

World Bank Lends Record US$ 18 Billion to Brazil and Latin America

The World Bank Group (WBG) committed US$ 17.9 billion in fiscal year 2010 – ...