Brazil Protests and Family Calls Shameful UK Decision on De Menezes

Brazil regretted Monday, July 17, the British prosecutors decision not to charge the police officers involved in the death shooting July 2005 in London of Brazilian citizen Jean Charles de Menezes.

"The Brazilian government regrets the decision of the Crown Prosecution Service of the United Kingdom for rendering impossible the punishment of the officers who participated in the murder of Jean Charles de Menezes", the Foreign Relations Ministry said in a release adding that a mission sent to London by Minister Celso Amorim "will continue to seek additional clarification about the prosecutors’ decision with the purpose of a final assessment".

De Menezes was gunned down July 22, 2005, in a subway car at London’s Stockwell station a few days after the terrorist attacks and bomb scare that followed.

After reviewing the report prepared by Britain’s Independent Police Complaints Commission, IPCC, prosecutors concluded that there was insufficient evidence to file charges against the individual officers involved in the 27-year-old electrician’s death.

"The two officers who fired the fatal shots did so because they thought that Mr. De Menezes had been identified to them as a suicide bomber and that if they did not shoot him, he would blow up the train, killing many people" Stephen O’Doherty, senior lawyer with the Crown Prosecution Service Special Crime Division, said in a statement.

O’Doherty added that "while a number of individuals had made errors in planning and communication, and the cumulative result was the tragic death of Mr. De Menezes, no individual had been culpable to the degree necessary for a criminal offense".

But the Metropolitan force will be charged under health and safety laws.

The Metropolitan Police officers involved in the case were operating under a shoot-to-kill policy for suspected suicide bombers.

The IPCC report was the product of a six-month investigation into the tragic death of De Menezes, who was killed a day after a series of failed bombing attempts in London on the heels of those that killed more than 50 people in the British capital on July 7, 2005.

The family of De Menezes reacted calling the prosecutors’ decision "absolutely unbelievable".

A cousin of the victim Alex Pereira said in a press conference that the CPS decision was "shameful" and criticized authorities for "taking so much time in reaching such an incompetent" conclusion".

Patricia da Silva Armani, another cousin of the victim, said she was disappointed at the legal strategy being used by prosecutors and told reporters she was angry over the decision and wondered whether there was a "cover-up".

De Menezes was followed by undercover Special Branch officers on the morning of July 22 after emerging from a block of flats in the South London neighborhood of Tulse Hill that was under surveillance by counter-terrorism units. He then took a bus to the Stockwell subway station.

Police officers mistakenly reported that De Menezes was wanted terrorist Hussein Osman, who was being sought for the failed suicide bombing of a train in London on July 21, according to press reports.

After the incident, Metropolitan Police chief Sir Ian Blair said the shooting was "directly linked" to the failed subway bombings a day earlier in London.

Initially, police reported De Menezes was behaving suspiciously in Stockwell station and disobeyed orders to halt, bolting instead into a crowded subway car, where officers tackled him and shot him to death, fearing that he might be a suicide bomber.

However information leaked from the IPCC revealed that the young man calmly entered the metro station with a ticket and had just sat down in a subway car when a police officer grabbed him and dumped him to the floor while another officer shot him eight times at point-blank range in the head.

Mercopress –


  • Show Comments (3)

  • ch.c

    Funny pretention !
    What about the innocents citizens regularly killed by your own police, such as during the May chaos in SP ?
    Even Lembe, the SP governor, recognized that some innocents were killed !

    Were they less innocent than Jean Charles ????
    May be the real name of Jean Charles was…..GOD or JESUS ??????
    Why were the number and names of these innocents not even published ?
    Was a thorough investigation even made by the Brazilian “Justice” and published just as the story of Jean Charles ?????????

    Are their family of less importance than Jean Charles family ?

    Is a Brazilian citizen killed in a foreign country more important than the thousands of innocents killed annually by the Brazilian police in Brazil ?????

    You are just ridiculous !

    To whom you want to give a lesson ?

    You better take lessons from others ! At least there will be less killings of innocents by your police force ! And by taking lessons from others, Brazil will have far less poverty, corruption, impunity and injustice !

    Afterall Brazil has the world highest poverty rate when compared to their GDP per capita !

    Brazilian police dont even kill innocent adults…but also innocent YOUNG CHILDREN !!!!!!! And you feel very proud……doing this ??????

    Shame on you ! Your society is an insult to humanity ! The EU and the USA should simply boycott your products and tell you to go to hell ! We can buy elsewhere just about everything, cheaper and of better quality !!!

    Simple !

  • guest


    “A cousin of the victim Alex Pereira said in a press conference that the CPS decision was “shameful” and criticized authorities for “taking so much time in reaching such an incompetent” conclusion”. “

    At least there is some type of justification, it was a time of terrorist attacks happening in london where many people were killed in the time leading up to the event. Not justifying what happened nor it being unfortunate.

    But it really makes people ponder how a brazilian can make such comments when there are death squads in brazil that kill people at random for no reason whatsoever and without any justification whatsoever. When these things happen in brazil some people do complain, but it’s then accepted, but if something happens in another country then its “incompetence”.

  • Judge Dread

    Some perspective….
    Just to give some perspective to this article, the offences that were considered by the CPS Special Crime Division for possible prosecution against the police officers included murder, manslaughter, forgery and breaches of health and safety legislation. It was concluded that there was insufficient evidence to provide a realistic prospect of conviction against any individual police officer.
    It is clear that the police officers thought that Mr de Menezes had been identified to them as a suicide bomber and that if they did not shoot him, he would blow up the train, killing many people.
    Now, in order to prosecute any of the officers concerned in the shooting, it would be necessary to prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that they did not honestly and genuinely hold those beliefs. In fact, the evidence supports their claim that they genuinely believed that Mr. de Menezes was a suicide bomber and therefore, as that claim cannot be disproved, there can be no prosecution for murder or any other related offence.
    However, there does appear to be sufficient evidence to prosecute the Office of the Commissioner of Police for an offence under sections 3 and 33 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 of failing to provide for the health, safety and welfare of Mr. de Menezes.
    I think that all will conclude that while a number of individuals made errors in planning and communication, and the cumulative result was the tragic death of Mr. de Menezes, no individual was culpable to the degree necessary for a criminal offence.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


You May Also Like

First Edition of Rio-à-porter Brings Fashion to the Dock of Rio’s Port

Rio de Janeiro’s first edition of the fashion and design industry salon, Rio-à-porter, held ...

Brazilian Metal Company Plans to Compete with China in Arab Market

Soprano, manufacturer of iron fittings and hydraulic equipments based in the city of Farroupilha, ...

Brazilian Jujitsu Conquers United Arab Emirates

Brazilian fighter Carlos Santos, Carlão, is organizing the first national jujitsu championship in the ...

Fair Trade and Organic Cotton Opened the World to This Brazilian Company

Based in Petrópolis, a city in the Brazilian southeastern state of Rio de Janeiro, ...

Brazil Wants Better Integration with the 10 Countries It Borders

A greater integration between Brazil and South America is one of the focuses of ...

OAS Opens New Office on Blacks with Brazilian Money

With a renewed call for a hemispheric anti-racism convention to be in place sometime ...

In Protectionist Measure Brazil Slaps 25% Tax in 100 Imported Products

The Brazilian council of ministers of the Foreign Trade Board (Camex) increased the import ...

Brazil Cuts Interest Rates to Record Low 8.75%

The BC, Brazil's Central Bank, lowered on Wednesday, July 22, the benchmark Selic rate ...

Brazil Opposition Wants OAS Mission to Check on Venezuela’s Political Prisoners

Venezuela will have to wait a little longer for Brazilian approval to get inside ...

Brazil’s Assurance: We’re Not Bankrupt, We’re Part of Solution

Brazil's new strategy for maintaining investment and expanding credit is reducing interest rates on ...