Brazil on the Verge Again of Regulating Journalists’ Work

A new federal law regulating the work of journalists that was approved by the Brazilian senate earlier this month poses a "dangerous" threat to press freedom in Brazil, Reporters Without Borders said this Tuesday, July 25, urging President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva to veto it when it is submitted for the executive’s approval on 27 July.

The law distinguishes between journalists who are officially recognized and those who are not.

"It would be strange if the federal government were to endorse this law now after abandoning a similar attempt to regulate journalism which it presented to parliament two years ago," the press freedom organization said.

"These attempts to legislate about the work of journalists are liable to create an oppressive and dangerous division between ‘official’ or ‘recognized’ journalists and those who are ‘underground’ or ‘fringe’," Reporters Without Borders continued.

"By definition, a journalist is anyone who produces or processes news and information, not someone who is authorized to do so by virtue of a diploma or membership of a professional association."

The organization added: "It would also be a flagrant legal and political contradiction for President Lula to agree to this new law after signing the 1994 Declaration of Chapultepec on press freedom in May."

The proposed law for the "promotion of the profession of journalist" was presented to parliament by chamber of deputies member Pastor Amarildo. It was approved by the senate and was debated by the chamber of deputies without being amended. It is now up to the president to endorse it or to veto it, either partially or in its entirety.

It incorporates some of the provisions of the abortive bill presented by the government two years ago. Under one of the provisions, the number of categories of journalistic and communications work that would require a degree in journalism is increased from 12 to 23.

Among those who would now need to have a degree are photographers, cameramen, graphics specialists, illustrators, archivists, journalism teachers and sports commentators. The National Council of Archives has pointed out that the profession of archivist is regulated in a 1978 law.

The press and journalists are split over the law. The National Federation of Journalists (FENAJ) and several journalists’ unions are in favor, but the National Association of Newspapers (ANJ) and many leading newspapers are very critical.

The former think it will provide more protection for journalists, who for the most part are poorly paid and have few guarantees. The latter fear it could give the government a degree of political control over the media.

The controversy also centers on another aspect of the law, the creation of a regulatory body on the lines of the Federal Council of Journalism (CFJ), which under the previous bill had the job of "orientating, disciplining and controlling" the profession, issuing press cards and imposing administrative sanctions. It was the outcry about this aspect that forced the government to withdraw the earlier bill, and it has been toned down in the new law.

The Declaration of Chapultepec that President Lula signed on World Press Freedom Day on 3 May is based on a broad definition of freedom of information and expression, and has been signed by virtually all of the western hemisphere’s presidents since it was adopted by the Inter-American Press Association on 11 March 1994.

It reaffirms that the right to inform and be informed "is not something authorities grant, it is an inalienable right of the people." It also insists (in point 8) that it should not be obligatory for journalists to join guilds or professional associations.

Reporters Without Frontiers – www.rsf.org

Tags:

  • Show Comments (3)

  • Web2.0Newspapers

    http://www.web2.0newspapers.com/?p=19 — nos escrivamos sobre esse coisa um porquinho… we’ve written about this a bit in the context of a longer blog psot — check us out.

  • Payday Loan Advocate

    Government Control…
    The novel Brave New World by Aldous Huxley was published as a warning. It tells the tale of London in the year 2540, in a dystopian future in which the government controlled every aspect of the citizensˢ۪ lives, down to not allowing any dissenting, or in other words free, thought. This was Huxleyˢ۪s vision of what will happen to societies if the government was allowed enough leeway to impose their iron fist into the everyday lives down to thoughts, words, and free choice of the citizens. This novel was controversial, and still is, but what is worse still is that his and also George Orwellˢ۪s cautionary tales of restriction of governmental regulation are beginning to come true, even here in the land of the free, the USA. For instance, the California government has allowed zoning of Los Angeles to include where fast food restaurants cannot have a store open. Burger joints are becoming outlawed, and one of the next targets is the payday loan industry, which has already come under fire. Many politicians and candidates are pledging to rid their respective states, municipalities, and also the entire United States of this legitimate and valuable service industry. Many of these politicians are hoping to get elected so that they can serve their own self interest or the banking lobbyˢ۪s interests. How far should they be allowed to go before we, the American people, say enough? Post Courtesy of Personal Money StoreProfessional Blogging TeamFeed Back: 1-866-641-3406Home: http://personalmoneystore.com/NoFaxPaydayLoans.htmlBlog: http://personalmoneystore.com/moneyblog/

  • Stephen White

    E Journalists
    So what about the hundreds and maybe thousands of writers producing pieces on the internet inside Brazil as well as in the exterior? This is a absurd law!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

comment *

  • name *

  • email *

  • website *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ads

You May Also Like

Steel Production and Foreign Sales Fall in Brazil

Even though Brazil registered a 12.4% drop in the production of crude steel during ...

The Rise of the Brazilian Empire

Brazil’s imperialism is generally overlooked by Brazilians. The boundaries of Brazil were created mainly ...

Brazil’s Lula Loses Some of His Moral Luster

One of the great dangers in following Brazilian politics is that you can become ...

Lula: ‘Brazil Won’t Play a Supporting Role Anymore!’

Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, addressing an audience made up of dozens ...

In Brazil, IMF Only for a Rainy Day

Speaking to journalists at the Palácio do Planalto, December 23, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio ...

Who Owns the AIDS Drugs? Brazil Has a Forum to Discuss the Matter.

A forum this week in Teresina, state of PiauÀ­, in the Brazilian Northeast, will ...

Despite Spotty Record on Human Rights Brazil Gets UN Seat

Brazil, Chile and Argentina figure among the 15 members elected on Wednesday, May 21, ...

34 in 2008: Brazilian Indians Are Committing Suicide at a Faster Pace.

The suicide rate among Brazil's Guarani-Kaiowá Indians is on the increase, a just released ...

Corruption Scandals Tilting Brazil’s Governmemt to the Right

The Brazilian government has been racked by a series of corruption scandals that many ...

Brazil Bank Workers Keep Strike After 6.5% Raise Offer. They Want 11%

In Brazil, the latest offer from the bankers is a salary increase of 6.5% ...