Women in Brazil: So Protected Still So Abused

Brazilian mother with her babyWomen are granted by the Brazilian Constitution with an impressive quantity of ‘fundamental’ rights. The Constitution fully recognizes the equal value of both sexes, manifesting for their equality of basic rights and obligations before the law.

In its Article 5, provision XLI, the Brazilian Constitution says that it is an obligation of the state to promote the welfare of everyone without sexual discrimination.

In relation to matters of labour law, it is good to remember that women have more rights than men, as Article 7 establishes special rights for them, including an earlier retirement and protection at the job market.

Whereas the Brazilian Constitution says that everyone possesses the same legal rights, ordinary legislation has provided penalties of prison and fine against sexist behaviour, including the use of pejorative term against women.

The law has even established special police stations for women, offering them relevant services like psychological counselling for victims of domestic violence, hospital treatment for victims of rape, and investigation of crimes against women.

Thus the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights regards the Brazilian model of legislation, particularly in what it says about ‘gender-specific police station’, as ‘unprecedented’ and an ‘influential model’ to be imitated by all other nations.(1)

Despite of what the law describes, everybody knows that violence against women has occurred with an utmost frequency. According to the United Nations (UN), Brazilian women are ‘frequently exposed’ to sexual victimization.

A document released in 2004 by the UN-Habitat reveals that Brazil has one of the highest levels of incidents described as rape, attempted rape, and indecent assault against women. What is worst, the report suggests that such crimes are normally underreported, with perpetrators unlikely to be punished.(2)

The vast majority of criminal complaints related to violence against women are suspended without their final conclusion.

In 2002, the World Organization Against Torture (WOAT) reported that only 2 percent of all complaints involving acts of violence against women led to any sort of conviction.

For the cases resulting in conviction, the WOAT comments that punishment for heinous crimes like first-degree murder and rape are ‘very light’.(3)

In regard to working rights, the Brazilian Constitution has forbidden salary differentiation between both sexes, although, as a matter of legal fact, it actually upholds a ‘positive discrimination’ in favour of women.

As mentioned earlier, women have been granted with special constitutional rights which include, among others, three months of paid maternity leave and legal protection against dismissal for pregnancy.

In practice, however, the Organization of American States (OAS) has reported that women bearing children can be dismissed regardless of legislation to the contrary.

The same report suggests that some employers have illegally required ‘proof of sterilization’ as a basic condition for women to be employed.(4)

Finally, the OAS says in its official document that even the government itself recognized that the average salary of women is 54% below of what is normally paid for male counterparts at similar level of education and qualification.(5)

References:

(1) Organization of American States; Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Brazil. Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, 1997. http://www.cidh.oas.org/countryrep/brazil-eng/index%20-%20brazil.htm

(2) UN-Habitat; State of the World’s Cities: Trends in Latin America & the Carribean. 2004. http://www.unhabitat.org/mediacentre/documents/sowc/RegionalLAC.pdf

(3) U.S. Department of State; Country Reports on Human Rights Practices – Brazil. Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labour, February 25, 2004. http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2003/27888.htm

(4) Organization of American States; Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Brazil. , Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, 1997. http://www.cidh.oas.org/countryrep/brazil-eng/index%20-%20brazil.htm

(5) Organization of American States; Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Brazil. , Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, 1997. http://www.cidh.oas.org/countryrep/brazil-eng/index%20-%20brazil.htm

Augusto Zimmermann is a Brazilian Law Professor and PhD candidate for Monash University – Faculty of Law, in Australia. The topic of his research is the (un)rule of law and legal culture in Brazil. He holds a LL.B and a LL.M (Hons.) from the Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro. Among others, he has published many articles in several languages and countries, and two law books on the subject of democratic federalism and constitutional law. His e-mail is: augustozimmermann@hotmail.com.

Tags:

You May Also Like

The Rise of the Brazilian Empire

Brazil’s imperialism is generally overlooked by Brazilians. The boundaries of Brazil were created mainly ...

Brazil’s Finance Minister Seems Convincing While Defending Himself from Kickback Charges

Brazilian Minister of Finance, Antonio Palocci, held a press conference over the weekend to ...

Leaders of Police Rebellion in Brazil Use Women and Kids as Human Shields

Human shields: the same tactic used by Saddam Hussein during the US invasion of ...

Brazil Hikes Gas 10%, a First in Three Years

Brazil's Finance Minister, Guido Mantega, has just announced a 10% hike in the price ...

Brazil Recognizes There’s Still a Long Way to Integrate Indians in Society

The executive secretary of Brazil’s Ministry of Justice, Luiz Paulo Barreto, participated, Tuesday, March ...

For Investors Worldwide Brazil is Priority Number 1 in LatAm

Although Chile is considered the market with the most favorable environment for business, only ...

Brazilian Channel for the Young Now on Joost

PlayTV Brazil, a Brazilian game channel, which also offers music and movies  launched its ...

The Unique "Brazilianness" of Brazilians

The rampant and gross indifference to the separation of the various populations of Latin ...

Brazil Hosting Chinese and Russian Presidents Next Week

Hu Jintao, the president of China, will be visiting Brazil, Venezuela and Chile in ...

Basic Schooling Now Takes 12 Years in Brazil Too

Brazil is moving to expand its basic education system (elementary schooling) to 9 years, ...